18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Buffalo

“My hands shake really bad when I'm in an episode and the young ladies working were SO kind! They helped me scan my card because I couldn't do it and made sure my bags were secured in my shaking hands. They even offered to carry in out for me. Every time I go here I'm impressed by how wonderful and kind the youth workers are to customers.“

“First time in Buffalo at this tasty mom & pop pizza. Delicious cauliflower and gluten free crust-the freshest ingredients, excellent service! The food was amazing! Five stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️We will definitely stop here again.“

“A hometown gem with comfort food, good vibes, and flavor done right! I had the juicy cheeseburger with golden fries and a cold beer—pure hometown goodness. My wife had the detroit style pizza-perfect. My sweet tooth couldn’t resist a brownie with ice cream. We recommend this great place. 🇺🇸“

“Staff is very friendly here. The food is also a few bumps above what I have come to expect from Domino’s at other locations. The staff do a good job making sure the toppings are evenly distributed, the cook is done well, and the crust is made properly and cooked evenly.

I like the window pickup option. It’s a nice addition. The young gal who gave me my food was also very pleasant and wished me a wonderful rest of my day. Props to this location for hiring a great staff and providing good food!“

“So grateful to Nate & Jessica hosting our annual Taco Bar fundraiser.“

“I rec'd an email about special pricing for 2 days. Ordering on the website is easy. Applying the discount is easy. The pizza is ready to pick up at the time you tell them you will be there. We eat half for dinner and the next morning there is leftover pizza available for breakfast.“

“As usual we had fantastic food! We tried some new app’s and can not wait to try more. Fun fact, my Autistic son loved your pepperoni pizza! He eats very few kinds and the fact that he enjoyed your restaurant was great for me! We can add another place of approved places for him!! The atmosphere is beautiful and fun. Our service was top notch! Always the most important part for me. We will be back!“

“The pizza was good. I ordered online well ahead of time so I don't know how long it took. I deducted a star because the pizza was sliced terribly uneven. It's not hard to cut a pizza into 8 even slices and it's difficult to feed multiple people when u have some slices that over twice the size of other slices.“

“I purchased 2 large pizzas over Memorial Day. I was disappointed in them because the pizzas I picked up were not the quality I was used to. I called Lilly, Manager of the Monticello and expressed my disappointment. She told me she was happy to know that and she would replace them for me when we wanted. I'm very happy to report that I called Lilly and she remembered me and said the pizzas would be replaced free if charge. I see why the Monticello store is exemplary. Thank you Lilly“

“Top notch! I love Pizza Ranch wherever I go. Monticello is the 214th location The Legendary Pizza Ranch Guest ever visited.“

“Ordered pizza tonight for a Halloween party, pizza was amazing as always! David and his wife are wonderful people! Always a good pizza night with Primo!“

“change back to the original pineapple pieces.“

“It's unfortunate that Pizza Hut decided to change their personal pan pizzas. I am not a fan of the current version. It's more hand-tossed than deep dish and doesn't taste like “Pizza Hut”. This location used to sell breadsticks and no longer sell those either. Which is also a shame. The staff is nice. The place clean. Usually you have to wait for pizza to be cooked. It's got weird hours. My teen, however, would eat here everyday if I let her.“

“We hosted our twins' 2nd Birthday in their side room recently. the staff went above and beyond for us, making sure everyone had drinks, great food, and a clean spot to sit and visit at. They made life easy for celebrating my kiddos. Everyone said their meal was fantastic and thought it was such a great deal to have the kiddos birthday there. We will definitely be doing that again!“

“We had a quality issue with a recent purchase, but Tyler went above and beyond to make it right. From the moment we reached out, he was professional, empathetic, and proactive. He not only resolved the issue quickly but also followed up to ensure we were completely satisfied. It’s rare to experience this level of genuine care and commitment to customer satisfaction. Tyler turned a frustrating situation into a positive one, and we're truly grateful. Exceptional service like his deserves to be recognized—thank you, Tyler!“

“I don’t know I was reading everybody’s poor reviews, but I thought you know what I’m gonna try the pizza anyway. I am a real pizza snob. I’m very very fussy and let me tell you, this pizza was absolutely amazing! I had extra sauce put on it in the sauce is very good With great flavor. I got the thin crust. It was nice and crispy, had pepperoni, mushrooms, fire, roasted green, and red peppers And onions. I couldn’t have asked for a better flavored pizza. He said it would be done in 10 minutes and I got there and it was done in 10 minutes. The guy who waited on me. I also had made it. I wish I had remembered his name. He was very pleasant.“

“My mother in law ordered some Pizzas, 1 for herself and 2 for her son and myself. I went into dominos 3 times today. The first time the order wasn't right, so I went back in and told them what was wrong and a lady that worked there sounded like she had it under control, so, we left and went back 15 mins later and the female I talked to in the first place literally wasn't anywhere to be found and she didn't even put in the order. So, this Man who works there his name is Chris, he got right to making my experience way better than expected by making a large (was originally a medium) and throwing in a Brownie for free and he was very apologetic and professional. Thank you, Chris at Domino's in Monticello, MN! The Pizza was awesome, but the BROWNIES.... OMG they are amazing! You rock!!!“