11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Stillwater

“Delicious, fresh, hand made pizza. We love patronizing this local establishment. We'll definitely be back!“

“Best pizza in town! Why?
Real, melty cheese!
Thick, rich red sauce!
Thin, firm Crust!
Generous toppings!
Locally owned and operated!
Because of the fresh, high-quality ingredients, this Pizza Man earns a 10/10 - Pizza Dude“

“fantastic first experience!“

“Food and service were great as always! Disclaimer says prices in store and in advertisements are cash prices and subject to an up charge. A petty money grab, in my opinion, but at least it's upfront. Nothing is said about online prices, and since cash payment is not an option, one would assume the upcharge is included, but it is not. It's only $1, but it's the idea of sneaking in a bs charge that is annoying. Just be upfront and honest about pricing and stop adding in additional charges and price your menu accordingly.“

“Great food, great service, great staff. We had the fungi burger, tavern burger, pomme frites, dipping sauces(they have a lot), and French onion soup. Everything was perfectly cooked, hot, juicy, crispy, and delicious. Our server was Kendall and she was well informed on the specials and the menu, she was polite and friendly and remembered our orders and asked the right questions. All around impressive.“

“Thank you for fantastic service on a large last minute order...and correcting it when I messed up! I appreciate you! Definitely will order again. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!“

“They do a good job when they get the order correct. I have to order a create your own and pay more for my pizzas to get them made correctly. If I order a standard pizza and modify it they always mess it up. So I pay the $3-$4 more per pizza to get them correct.“

“Great service and delicious entrees!“

“My girlfriend and I stopped here while we took a trip out to Stillwater. It has a nice old restaurant feel and it seemed well kept and clean. The pizza itself was really good and our server was really good and friendly. We both would highly recommend.“

“Fun dive bar. The bartender was very nice and helpful. He obviously is very familiar with his regulars. For us that have never visited his bar before, he was sure to let us know up front this is a cash only establishment. It is nice to know so we do. It look like fools scrambling for a atm at the last minute.The beer selection is just right. They had plenty of offerings in several spectrums of beer. The liquor offerings are very plentiful for this level of bar.We will be back again and I hope to enjoy the Harbor Bar more often.“

“It was a great! We sat on the patio at 5:30. Good food, lots of family w/kids. I will go back again. My husband like the Mac and cheese and I had a Rachel that was good.

Kid-friendliness: Lots of room for the kids on the patio.“