Peggy Jean's Pies

$$$ •

503 E Nifong Blvd, Columbia
(573) 447-7437


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Peggy Jean's Pies

Stopped by their store on Saturday. Had never been before and we are from out of town so we thought we would get pies to take back with us. I purchased two was a brownie type pie and the other was a blueberry. The brownie pie was just okay, but the blueberry pie was just awful! It was dried out and not very sweet. We will NOT go back. Old pie!

Got a pie for my birthday, but the order was delayed for 40 minutes. The pie was not even set when the person handling them said, just put it on the refrigerator. We did that right away and after many hours it only turned tu mush. Ultimately we decided to freeze it, but turned into a frozen blob. The flavor wasn’t even special. Too bad because I heard good things about this place.

The pies at Peggy Jean’s Pies are seriously the best. I’ve had a lot of pie and none can top Peggy Jean’s, from the flaky, perfect crusts to the fillings and incredible toppings. And the small ones are perfect because you can get 2 or 3 of those when you can’t decide which variety to get! Our favorite is the Peanut Butter Chocolate, it is outstanding!!!

More Reviews(72)


Monday 10AM - 6PM
Tuesday 10AM - 6PM
Wednesday 10AM - 6PM
Thursday 10AM - 6PM
Friday 10AM - 6PM
Saturday 10AM - 5PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.