50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cottleville

“We had our son and daughter in law’s rehearsal dinner at Mellow Mushroom and boy, did we choose a great place! They had us all set up for 25 people beautifully when we arrived and was quickly introduced to our amazing server, Katie. Between her and her crew of helpers (for lack of a better word), we were taken care of so well. Tara, the bartender also tended to us with quick and excellent service. The general manager Ahmad checked on us several times to be sure we were happy and everyone was taken care of. Food and drinks were quickly and deliciously served and enjoyed. The atmosphere is so fun and upbeat. I don’t think we had one problem (except us being 7 minutes late - so sorry about that!!). We go to Mellow Mushroom as a couple and a family and now we can add as a wedding party and extended family. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!“

“We had a great time visiting Plank Road Pizza. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. We tried the sausage pizza while there and it was fantastic! The way they spread out the thin sausage was my favorite part!“

“We had a very enjoyable lunch on 8/22/2025. It was quiet since it was during school hours, the food was great, the service was outstanding for us. We plan to return as often as we can, however, it is a long drive for us, so it may not be as frequently as we would like. I love the food choices, the pricing is competitive and the service from paying to picking up our finished plates was done quickly. I look forward to our next visit.“

“Love this style of pizza and mod’s is consistently great. Also… why is their music so good! I need to find this mix… heard boys don’t cry and then Tears for Fears head over heels and then Alice In Chains no excuses. Maybe I don’t know how to use Spotify very well, but I’ve never gotten a good mix playlist like this.
good atmosphere and dependably great pizza !“

“We came in on a Thursday, with a reservation for 6. They were ready and waiting for us, complete with the high chair we requested for our little one. The staff were so friendly and helpful. There was a rehearsal dinner celebration going on so the place/atmosphere was very lively and fun, but our service was not neglected. Our food was amazing!! The meatballs were definitely the best I have had and I’m very picky about my meatballs. Garlic shrimp rigatoni was awesome, lasagna delicious. We had pumpkin cheesecake that was phenomenal. We had another dessert called a Pizookie that was blueberry lemon and was sort of like a cookie and a pie/cobbler. It was amazing. We all left very full and very happy, with plans to return for dinner again soon, as well as trying out their brunch. Go check it out.“

“This is a very friendly place to get great food! It could be my new favorite place to get pizza. The wings were so good, my wife said they were among the best she has had, and she is very picky when it comes to wings. Awesome job Woodson Stonefire!!“

“One of the best burgers I have ever had. Every bite was juicy.“

“My family and I finally made it out. And the cheese garlic bread and pizza was everything I remember it being when I was a teenager. Absolutely delicious! The staff was extremely pleasant and the restaurant itself was very clean. Keep up the great job - can’t wait to make it back.“

““Deeelicious” according to the kids! Came for the summer reading coupons, but will definitely be back!“

“Probably the best experience at a restaurant we’ve ever had. Ethan, the waiter, was personable, accommodating, and friendly! Food was exceptional as well!“

“Just tried the pizza for the first time. The Buffalo Pizza was very good. Nice flavor. I would definitely order again.“

“Always good experience here. I order on app and pick it up. It’s ready when I get there and order is always correct. Baking pizza is easy and clean up is easy with the disposable trays included. The dairy free pizzas are really good too.“

“some of the best pizza I have had in awhile.“

“Best Italian restaurant in St Louis! Period!!! I cant wait to go again and again with my wife and life partner, i need to try everything on the menu. LOL. It is hard to get a reservation but it is absolutely worth the wait MAMMMA MIA enjoyyyy“

“Every time we order the pizza is absolutely perfect. I feel like I’m so close to Chicago I can see Wrigley Field out my windows … Tonight’s pizza (Original) was out of this world Puuuurrrfffeeeccttt !“

“I stopped by imo's pizza recently, and I have to say—it was one of the best pizza experiences I’ve had in a long time.

First, the pizza was absolutely top-notch. I ordered the sweet heat, and it was a perfect blend of flavors.

But what made the visit even better was the service, especially from the manager, megan. From the moment I walked in, they were welcoming, attentive, and clearly passionate about their work.

Great food is important—but great people are what bring you back. This place has both.“

“The employees are incredible. This has been a complete disaster… I am from out of town. I only look forward to Imo‘s pizza and their air-conditioning was out. It was uncontrollably hot we were sweating. The staff was obviously uncomfortable. I am appalled. I think I overheard them saying it has been weeks. It’s not a positive environment for anyone. Very disappointed in this location. I am only leaving a five star review because I feel so bad for the staff that I don’t want them to reap the negative energy from obviously a bad owner.“

“Stuffed squash blossom, delicious!! Did not get the margarita had a different cheese pizza with garlic can’t remember the name. It was great except 2 slices had no cheese. Will definitely be back but need more cheese!!“

“The pizza itself was good. However the potato skins were not, they had a old stale taste. Maybe they used potatoes that were not fresh. Worst potato skins I ever had and I payed for two orders of them. I may try the potato skins again, I will update if we do. Service was okay, the young lady was not very friendly when I walked in. A older man came out from the back and did help. Overall not terrible, we will try this location again, but the Cave Springs location was always the best.“

“Pizza that I can say is. Beyond words great tasting . Plenty of. Meat vegetables. Cheese.“

“Been there many times over the years. Their NY-style pizza is great 👍“

“We stopped in on a whim and so glad we did. My husband had the deep-fried cannolinia with special sauce and I had a Steph special pizza with traditional cheese and they were both delicious 🤤😋 The only thing that made it better was the Italian cannoli for dessert! Thanks Patty for explaining everything and helping us figure it all out 😁“

“The wait was a bit long but well worth it. Staff was very kind and it was some good pizza“

“I did an online order. You guys deserve a kiss on the cheek frl. Remembered my red pepper flakes and parmesan, gave me a bunch of it. The alfredo is on point!! Mushrooms and broccoli made to perfection!!! Lovely cheesecake, like how you put strawberry sauce on the side.

Love love love“

“When I have a good experience, I review it! It is just the smallest touches that make my experience off the charts here. Amazing good, the people were VERY friendly, understand, and above all honest. Above all the was fresh, quick, and yummy! We will definitely be back when we pass through Missouri next time!“

“Always great service! Been going to this location for decades. The best around.

Parking: Spots infront of restaurant &huge parking lot belonging to Walmart one row behind &to the side. Plenty of parking for the whole strip.

Kid-friendliness: The ladies are super friendly with my kids. Always answering questions &asking them how they are doing also&what they are interested in. So nice. Family feelings when we walk in the door.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes. We've managed a walker.“

“We went to the new location in Wildwood on Father’s Day, with some friends, and it was refreshing watching the children playing games, and families together. This place is going to be a great success in Wildwood. Congratulations, we certainly enjoyed ourselves yesterday.“

“Great daily specials, homemade soups, fabulous pork steaks, yummy appetizers, best pulled pork nachos in town!“

“Delicious food and excellent Customer Service. 5*****“

“Ised to be my favorite for pizza. Anymore they can’t deliver on time and can’t take an order right.“

“I was trying to find a sweet older lady’s house to help her with her bathroom project and she mentioned IMOS found her so I actually called the store for help whom ever the gentleman was was not only helpful but he actually got the lady on the phone for a three way call to try and assist. UNBELIEVABLE DEDICATION TO SIMPLY HELP OTHERS!“

“IMO’s is the come through when you don’t feel like sitting down and just want to carry out a good pizza. St. Louis style, so always ask for crisp but not burnt. Salad and dressing is good and toasted ravs!
Specials if you call store are always good!“

“Finally got got to try the legendary Pirrone's Pizzeria Florissant while playing a great gig at Bunkers Tavern yesterday! 😊🍕💥 Awesome pizza with thin crispy crust and they use provel cheese! 💚 RECOMMENDED! 👍“

“Pizzas are awesome. If it is a fully loaded meat lovers pizza. Have them cook it longer in the oven. Sometimes they take it out too early and it's not all the way done but overall. Absolutely 100% best pizza. Makes me want to order a pizza right now at 9:29pm“

“Vegetarian options: Garlic bread, salad, veggie pizza

Parking: In front and back

Kid-friendliness: It's not rowdy. Sports plays on TV. Workers have always been nice and respectful. Easy access restrooms.

Wheelchair accessibility: No steps. Wide doors.“

“I got a pizza with garlic alfredo sauce and italian sausage and extra cheese. My pizza arrived as ordered. I had to wait for a refill of my drink twice. The was only 1 server working today at lunch and for the size of this place they should have a second server at lunch.“

“Great food and service! Pizza, burgers, and steak night are my favorites! Great service and friendly atmosphere. Music, trivia, and other fun activities!“

“I had lunch at Halftime yesterday and the food was wonderful. The special of the day was a Smashburger, homemade chips and a salad. I also shared some southwest chicken rolls as an appetizer. The southwest chicken rolls are always great, but I really loved the Smashburger and homemade chips. The chips had a really tasty seasoning on them. Apparently, this meal was a special only and not on the everyday menu, but it should be. Everything was delicious and our server was great.“

“Everything is always on point and very tasty. Lori is , by far, my favorite bartender. What can I say., I probably go more cause she is there! Their wings are the best and the Blue cheese 🧀 Rocks! St Charles location is by far the best!“

“Great Gluten Free Pizza and loved the salads . Why did you guys remove yourself from Doordash??? We ordered from there all the time because we live in st Peter’s .“

“Delicious 😋“

“My first time trying Imo’s pizza with my family. I got the Taste of St. Louis, with a sausage pizza. Pizza was 10/10. Provel bites 10/10. Toasted raviolis 10/10. Great service from the guy working around 6:45-7 on 9/6. He definitely takes pride in his work and cares about the food he’s giving out. 10/10 would recommend. Thank you for the STL experience!!“

“Great food and staff! Very attentive“

“This location successfully gets the crust crispy, even with conveyer ovens!

The addition of Pepsi zero fountain soda is nice, but will someone please tell Pepsi they always need to include Diet Dr. Pepper.

This location is right next to a fast EV charger as well.“

“Our waiter, Mike, was personable and quick. The food was good and hot. Loved the cream the chef added to the Manhattan clam chowder.“

“Not only is it the best Pizza in STL it is the most reasonably priced pizza in STL. ***best Pizza ***best price***“

“Awesome atmosphere, delicious food, fast and friendly service!! 12 out of 10!“

“On July 12, got two orders of the hot honey chicken tender sandwich. They were overcooked and were hard and dried out. The last time I had them, they were cooked just right and very tender. Lately, I feel it is hit or miss.“

“Candicci’s catered our wedding, and it was everything we hoped for and more! We heard tons of praise from guests saying it’s the best food they’ve ever had at a wedding! Every single dish was delicious, and the portions were generous. Every guest was full and happy! Jeff was super responsive, communicative, and easy to work with. They gave us a free tasting before we booked so we knew exactly what we’d be getting. The whole catering team was professional and accommodating, especially with dietary restrictions. They were also very affordable! I cannot recommend Candicci’s enough!“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“