50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cottleville

“We had our son and daughter in law’s rehearsal dinner at Mellow Mushroom and boy, did we choose a great place! They had us all set up for 25 people beautifully when we arrived and was quickly introduced to our amazing server, Katie. Between her and her crew of helpers (for lack of a better word), we were taken care of so well. Tara, the bartender also tended to us with quick and excellent service. The general manager Ahmad checked on us several times to be sure we were happy and everyone was taken care of. Food and drinks were quickly and deliciously served and enjoyed. The atmosphere is so fun and upbeat. I don’t think we had one problem (except us being 7 minutes late - so sorry about that!!). We go to Mellow Mushroom as a couple and a family and now we can add as a wedding party and extended family. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!“

“We had a great time visiting Plank Road Pizza. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. We tried the sausage pizza while there and it was fantastic! The way they spread out the thin sausage was my favorite part!“

“Great food, amazing arcade!“

“I can’t recommend Liliana’s enough! They were very accommodating for a surprise party and made it an easy choice to host it there. Fantastic food and very quick serving time. The staff was awesome and our server Erin was the absolute best! She went above and beyond and made the night special. Our family will definitely be coming back because of her!“

“Great pizza. The soda fountain is self-serve and has plain soda-water available. The jalapeños have some heat on the back end. There are so many great toppings available. This location has ricotta cheese available for salad or pizza toppings.“

“This is a very friendly place to get great food! It could be my new favorite place to get pizza. The wings were so good, my wife said they were among the best she has had, and she is very picky when it comes to wings. Awesome job Woodson Stonefire!!“

“A very welcoming neighborhood pizza place that always is delicious! Better than their pizza is their service. A staple for this community“

“One of the best burgers I have ever had. Every bite was juicy.“

“Best pizza in town. Amazing crust!!! Friendly, customer service.“

“My family and I finally made it out. And the cheese garlic bread and pizza was everything I remember it being when I was a teenager. Absolutely delicious! The staff was extremely pleasant and the restaurant itself was very clean. Keep up the great job - can’t wait to make it back.“

“My family tried out this place tonight and the food was amazing. Great service, typical sports bar atmosphere. We had the sampler (wings, hot sauce, the wings were not hot at all but the flavor was amazing!!), the KSHE pizza ( it had the feel of a homecooked pizza, wonderful). Looking at the menu were are already looking forward to out next trip to try new items!!“

“Always good experience here. I order on app and pick it up. It’s ready when I get there and order is always correct. Baking pizza is easy and clean up is easy with the disposable trays included. The dairy free pizzas are really good too.“

“Awesome food and service!!“

“Just tried the pizza for the first time. The Buffalo Pizza was very good. Nice flavor. I would definitely order again.“

“The manager on staff, Tyler Masters was so kind and welcoming. He also kindly answered any questions I had about the menu. Our food was made promptly and tasted delicious. I tell all my friends to go to this location simply because it never fails to be the best! 10/10“

“I love this place. There aren't too many thin crust places nearby but this is definitely my favorite out of them. The pizza is always delicious, the wings are always perfectly cooked, the salads are pretty filling, and the people here are always so friendly. I highly recommend checking this place out!“

“I’d like to say each visit I receive friendly attitudes. This is as important as the food quality. This location is full quality compared to other locations in St. Charles County is the best in my opinion. The customer service is top-tier. I’ve never encountered bad at customer service at this location.

Thank you so much“

“We get Nancy’s often, but tonight was special. We got a thin crust and an original stuffed Chicago-style deep dish. The crusts and toppings were absolutely perfect!!! My husband is from Chicago and this reminded him of home! We HIGHLY recommend!“

“The staff were friendly, the food was hot and amazing, and the place was super clean. Stopped in for a meal while traveling back to Chicago from Louisiana and decided to dine inside. I have been to other Fazoli’s but this location was just pure perfection. Great job with this location and the staff!“

“We were celebrating our daughter receiving her Ph D. This place was highly recommended. Had a WONDERFUL experience. The food was fabulous. The staff extremely friendly. Nice wide open space. Being in the business. I was watching the other staffs interaction with guests and other co workers. EXCELLENT VIBE in the house. HIGHLY recommend. All in All. Guests Staff. Food. Cleanliness. Home Run. Great Job 👊👊👍👍“

“We had a lovely dinner at NOTO last night. One thing I like about NOTO is their menu changes seasonally which keeps it fresh and exciting. They have amazing Neapolitan pizza which was certified by AVPN in Italy. Service was spectacular. Charming atmosphere. I started off with NOTO house salads. Chefs kiss. Mortadella is a no-brainer for me. My partner got the Salsiccia. They were absolutely delicious. The whole experience definitely brought us back to Italy. We also liked the patata a lot. I did make a reservation one month in advance but it’s worth the wait. Highly recommended!“

“Pizza that I can say is. Beyond words great tasting . Plenty of. Meat vegetables. Cheese.“

“This location always does a great job. Orders are correct, well prepared, and delivered shockingly fast. I love that someone draws little hearts on the packages, which makes me feel connected to the very real, hard working people that prepare our food. THANK YOU! Here's a heart back ❤️“

“Love their Wacky Weds.!!! Enough pizza for a family of 6-8. (2 xlarge deluxe pizzas $29.00) Thin crust STL Style pizza with Imo's famous provolone cheese topping.

Parking: Not tons of parking but sufficient. This location does more delivery and take out service.“

“I’m staying in hotel across the street. Delivery was fast. And the wings……AMAZING. Fall off the bone. So tender. Think I’ll order pizza tomorrow night.“

“The side salad was so big and delicious it could have fed two or been a meal by itself. We got a large pizza with 4 toppings. There were three of us and we only ate half of it. They load the toppings on, the pizza was good and filling.

Wheelchair accessibility: Tables and chairs are movable and make it easy for wheelchairs.“

“I had lunch at Halftime yesterday and the food was wonderful. The special of the day was a Smashburger, homemade chips and a salad. I also shared some southwest chicken rolls as an appetizer. The southwest chicken rolls are always great, but I really loved the Smashburger and homemade chips. The chips had a really tasty seasoning on them. Apparently, this meal was a special only and not on the everyday menu, but it should be. Everything was delicious and our server was great.“

“I was trying to find a sweet older lady’s house to help her with her bathroom project and she mentioned IMOS found her so I actually called the store for help whom ever the gentleman was was not only helpful but he actually got the lady on the phone for a three way call to try and assist. UNBELIEVABLE DEDICATION TO SIMPLY HELP OTHERS!“

“Always great service! Been going to this location for decades. The best around.

Parking: Spots infront of restaurant &huge parking lot belonging to Walmart one row behind &to the side. Plenty of parking for the whole strip.

Kid-friendliness: The ladies are super friendly with my kids. Always answering questions &asking them how they are doing also&what they are interested in. So nice. Family feelings when we walk in the door.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes. We've managed a walker.“

“The wait was a bit long but well worth it. Staff was very kind and it was some good pizza“

“Cons
1. The bar stools are far too close together.
2. Even though I was given an extra half pour for the extra long wait in getting my (1) order of wings, which I appreciate greatly, it still took far too long to get my (1) order of wings.
3. No Laphroaig, please stock Laphroaig.

Pros
1. The Kickin' Buffalo wings are out of sight (especially with a Rumple Minze shooter)
2. The bar staff are phenomenal (should actually be #1)
3. Very excellent choice of beers on tap
4. Keep rocking it Kerry“

“Been there many times over the years. Their NY-style pizza is great 👍“

“Beats the food in my home country of Sri Lanka by a mile. I usually get 3 buckets two Matt steaks and cheese fries while I’m here.“

“As always, I absolutely love the food here. As someone born and raised in St. Charles, the pizza here always fills me with a nostalgic glee. While the prices have gone up since I was a kid, the staff and atmosphere make up for that alone, while the food makes it even better. I heavily recommend this pizza to everyone, in and especially outside the state!“

“Great Gluten Free Pizza and loved the salads . Why did you guys remove yourself from Doordash??? We ordered from there all the time because we live in st Peter’s .“

“Vegetarian options: Garlic bread, salad, veggie pizza

Parking: In front and back

Kid-friendliness: It's not rowdy. Sports plays on TV. Workers have always been nice and respectful. Easy access restrooms.

Wheelchair accessibility: No steps. Wide doors.“

“Delicious food and excellent Customer Service. 5*****“

“The manager is awesome and immediately corrected our problem. We called in because we were delivered 2 burnt pizzas (one side of each pizza) and explained we were certain they probably just got stuck in the conveyor belt and he was understanding and agreed this was the problem while sending us a fresh new order right away. He said he’d get them to us in 30 min and I tell you it was like 30 min on the dot. Great manager that did his job and wasn’t rude like ‘cough’ Papa John’s management. We’ll be ordering again because mistakes happen and he corrected the issue at hand and with kindness! I say 4 stars because the first round was burnt but the guy for sure gets 5 stars. This is what gets you returning customers. :)“

“Pizzas are awesome. If it is a fully loaded meat lovers pizza. Have them cook it longer in the oven. Sometimes they take it out too early and it's not all the way done but overall. Absolutely 100% best pizza. Makes me want to order a pizza right now at 9:29pm“

“Met the owner...he's extremely passionate about preparing everything perfectly!

And it shows!! Best Imo's I've had in years...slightly browned cheese and a perfectly crisp crust!

I get Imo's every time I get back in town and I will be sure to go out of my way to get it here again.

There is one table in the convenience store and I ate it there. Otherwise, it's takeout“

“Delicious 😋“

“Not only is it the best Pizza in STL it is the most reasonably priced pizza in STL. ***best Pizza ***best price***“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Love Cecil Whittakers pizza.“

“great customer service 👍🏻“

“Stopped her to check out the Gluten free menu. Let me tell you… The service from the host stand to table service was awesome! The GF menu was extensive. Best pasta I have had. Didn’t taste like GF. Thank you so much! We will be back.“

“On July 12, got two orders of the hot honey chicken tender sandwich. They were overcooked and were hard and dried out. The last time I had them, they were cooked just right and very tender. Lately, I feel it is hit or miss.“

“Get the lettuce wrap now and then instead of bread - really decent and their delivery people are great.“

“Great food and service! Pizza, burgers, and steak night are my favorites! Great service and friendly atmosphere. Music, trivia, and other fun activities!“

“Went here while passing through to introduce a newbie to St. Louis style pizza. Got the Great Tastes of St. Louis box. The staff was busy when I walked in but acknowledged my presence, apologised, and asked if I could please wait a moment. When I was served they were kind and accommodating. The food was prepared quickly and I got exactly what I expected. It's not the most amazing place for St Louis style, but it was quick and easy and still tasty. We all loved the Cinnimos the best though 😆. In summary, great service, okay food.

Parking: Parking is great, except for the GIANT potholes.“