50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Eureka

“this review is for the new Rexburg location in Mother hibbards have stopped in there four times within the last week to try the food and they never have anything in the warmer. no pizzas nothing. I went in there tonight. no food in the warmer. the kids that work there are sitting on the floor up against the wall doing absolutely nothing. Do they only serve Pizza at lunch and zero food for dinner? there's nothing anywhere that says what times they have food what time? they don't have food so tonight I went from hangar 54 right over to Valley wide and got me a personal pizza and now I'm headed to work.“

“Everyone that ate the pepperoni pizza said it was amazing. My son and I had the chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks and ravioli sampler it was all really good and seasoned perfectly. The marinara sauce for the ravioli was delicious and I do not like normally like any marinara sauce but this tasted and looked fresh. Service was amazing and neat place.“

“Eureka Dominos always delivers great pizza, as we ordered & like it just came out of the oven. The Drivers are also always friendly & demonstrate a level of care, as if they are delivering it to a friend. Great stuff Dominos Team, deserving of recognition because it is a consistent experience over many years of living in Eureka. Thank you!“

“It is definitely old-school style! It was once a drugstore from back-in-the-day and has been Primo's for the past 20+ years. The staff was very friendly and courteous, and my food was BEYOND exemplary — totally fantastic! My burger was hot and juicy and fresh off the grill, and the French fries were piping hot and tasty! I recommend highly!! And .... don't walk out the door without a milkshake!!“

“Fast and great pizza and friendly delivery“

“Came to eat here after a long day at six flags and it was great! I left my bag at the restaurant and they went out of their way to mail it back since we live out of state! The food was great and so was the staff, would definitely recommend!“

“The dough, sauce, sausage was fantastic! They have a great sweet sauce. Will order again soon“

“DELICIOUS 🤤 we will be back in town next month and SO excited to dine here again!!“

“This pizzeria is highly underrated! Their food is absolutely delicious. Better than takeout. Any day. Prices are great if you do go you have to get the stuffed crust cheese bread. It’s so good the butter and the sauce that comes with it absolutely wonderful.“

“Best pizza I have found since moving to STL four years ago! But not just the best here. One of the best ever!“

“Delicious pizza, clean restaurant and good customer service“

“Outstanding flavor! Loved the sauce and the cheese...everything!“

“We ordered from Cecil's (Ellisville) last pm.... We were not disappointed! The pizza was very good! The only way to improve would be to go back to the old ovens & cornmeal under the crust while cooking. Cecil's Valley Park continues to disappoint... Many chances & they are horrible. Imo's Twin Oaks... also horrible... No question...Cecil's Ellisville is the go-to! Run the Buy one get one for $4 like St. Peters, Please.“

“The wait was a bit long but well worth it. Staff was very kind and it was some good pizza“

“Staff was friendly and fast. Clean. Great deals!!! VERY fresh ingredients

Vegetarian options: Absolutely LOVE the gourmet vegetarian pizza!! I'm not a vegetarian, but this is my FAVORITE pizza! Delicious!

Kid-friendliness: LOVE the mini-Murphy where my daughter can make her own little pizza. She looks forward to it!“

“Best pizza ever! The dough is to die for and you can watch them make your pizza 🍕! Staff is AMAZING!“

“Great atmosphere! Great drinks and fun games!“

“We have traditionally gone to Bartolino’s South County. When they opened the one in West County we were very happy because it’s close to home as well as a very nice place to have dinner or lunch.. We have had dinner there several times And each time the food has been great and the service excellent. Very nice courteous professional people tonight we had Michell as our attendant and she did an excellent job. The atmosphere is very nice yet very comfortable business casual. Prices are not cheap, but considering what you get they’re fair. We will continue to go to Bartolino‘s, and we consider it one of our favorites for a good Italian.“

“Helpful staff and fun place for my little guy.
Definitely the best Chuck E. Cheese around! The bouncy area was a great addition to our time there to bounce around after we ate, which we ate as a break after he finishes the arcade games. Tasty food and also a clean location.

Chuck E. was also friendly & came out like clockwork.“

“Crafty always has tasty in house brews to try and fresh brick oven food I love that they are dog friendly and the staff are easy to talk to.
I enjoy going in the late afternoon/ early evening and enjoying a bit of quiet on the patio with a late lunch!!“

“On July 12, got two orders of the hot honey chicken tender sandwich. They were overcooked and were hard and dried out. The last time I had them, they were cooked just right and very tender. Lately, I feel it is hit or miss.“

“Great food and staff! Very attentive“

“I was passing thru MO on I-44. I saw sign for Imo's. I get an Imo's Pizza every trip to/thru MO. I had never been to the Pacific location. It was the best Imo's Pizza I have EVER had, & I have had many!!! Manager Amber was so helpful & kind. I was tired from driving all day from OK, where I had just finished a dog-sit, on my way to a MO dog-sit. The staff were very nice. It was my best experience in all the visits to an Imo's!!!! My trip continued with me being tired, but full & uplifted by my wonderful experience!! Thank you Amber for your kindness & generosity & uplifting attitude!!!“

“It is either Jesses or papa johns, doesnt take a rocket scientist to figure out who to call. Food is great as well, best cheeseburger around for the money.“

“Amazing pizza! Best lasagna! Great staff! 5 Stars!“

“Great family atmosphere, good food.“

“My favorite place for a burger in West County. Beer is cold and staff is friendly. Good healthy options if you’re into that kind of thing. Golf simulators, but remember to make a “tee time” which is easy to do via their website.“

“Amazing service and really good food! Thank you so much!“

“Consistently good STL style pizza and sides, fast polite delivery staff. 👍👍“

“The food was delicious! Our server was Carol and she was absolutely amazing!! Very attentive, cheerful, fun and organized!! I will definitely return the next time I'm in town!! Definitely a 10/10 experience!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“staff is great and take care of there guests“

“Neely had stopped cleaning in a timely manner upon our arrival to bring us menus took drink order & quickly returned with drinks & took our order then gave it to the Mgr Stephanie & another fellow behind the counter , Chris i believe. Neely returned to cleaning until our pizza was ready & promptly brought to our table. Have to say our food was delicious & our dine in experience was a pleasure & I should add in my past experience in general that's not been the case & have refrained from eating at restaurants & It was a welcome return. 1 vote for Pizza Hut as role model to all restaurants to offer a nice clean busy atmosphere in tandem with polite kind staff & service.“

“We came and Darryl assisted us with our party we were planning, he was amazing! He answered any questions I had about the menu and catering. He was very patient and polite. Thanks for making our party amazing. We recommend 10/10 every time! Food was PHONOMINAL! Can't wait til our next event! Thanks Candicci's“

“I don't normally order pizza from any pizza place. I am usually disappointed and I am price sensitive. I decided to do Domino's because they are running a special. I ordered a specialty pizza with some extra fixings on it. Probably one of the best pizzas I've had in years. the vegetables were perfect especially the chunky tomatoes. large chunks of moist chicken and just the right amount of cheese on my favorite thin crust. I just could not stop eating this great pizza. the gal Autumn at the cash register was very friendly also.“

“The northern lights pizza delivery guy is the greatest ever. He works at the one by Zona Rosa He recognizes me by face, remembers our conversation from 8 months ago. 5 star service every time. He Deserves a raise“

“These sandwiches they're making are awesome! I've got other favorites - those chocolate lava cakes or w/e, chicken+bacon alfredo pasta, thin and crispy sausage bacon pizza w/garlic sauce... Oh, and chicken wings!
I've had ALOT of Domino's, especially over the past 20 years, probably close to 2k orders, and it's extremely rare for anything I get to be anything but delicious.
I'd suggest you use the 20% off entire order deal - you generally save a little more than the others. And then you can give the folks who work there a tip with what you save. They consistently do an excellent job and deserve it.“

“5 stars.

We walked in around 11am Saturday, 07/18/26, and could tell something was off, chairs still up, register not yet opened for the day. The employee at the counter kindly welcomed us in for dine-in anyway.

When it was time to pay, he and a coworker from the back had to figure out the register together from scratch, clearly not their usual job, no training, but they stayed calm, worked through it, and got us checked out correctly without complaint or excuse.

Food came out perfectly prepared and exactly as ordered.

Whatever staffing gap caused this, these gentlemen handled it with patience, kindness, and professionalism. Five stars for them, they showed up and made it work. Excellent problem solving under pressure.“

“One of the things about Imo's is that they vary quite a bit by location. Some locations are great, some are just okay. Some are sad! This one isn't a top-tier Imo's on food quality alone, but it is pretty good. I'd give it four out of five starts food-wise. However, I do like that it's a real restaurant with dine-in, while so many Imo's aren't any more. It's nice to be able to sit down and enjoy when it's hot and fresh.“

“I'm too afraid to pick up a pizza from here because their drivers act like it's their first day behind the wheel every time they're whipping in and out of that lot. a couple pieces in the passenger seat doesn't change the skills required to operate a vehicle safely boys“

“If you’re like me, you like crispy, thin crust pizza with fresh ingredients and MOZZARELLA cheese. This place delivers! This was some of the best thin crust pizza I’ve had in the area. I ordered a bacon/pineapple and sausage/pepperoni. Both were so delicious we were fighting over the last few slices.

I had a rough experience my first time as they were struggling with a short staff. I originally posted a poor review and the owner reached out to me personally. The owner was super cool and apologized for the experience and offered me a gift card. Their response totally turned around my experience and impression. I will most certainly come back! Excellent pizza and excellent service.“

“Very well ran location I was very agreed with nice pleasant people. There was fast service food is ready accurate on time I like to drive-through option for pick ups that makes things easy. I love the app. I wish you could get a little bit more squares than how much you have to spend but oh no this is a great location. I do the sandwiches and they're always great. You know if you're missing out if you haven't tried them.“

“I’ll be real—walking in, I wasn’t sure what to expect. The place has lost the vibe it used to have: no tables, no pinball…feels more like a waiting room than a wing joint. Definitely miss the old energy and the breaded wings from back in the day. BUT credit where it’s due: the staff was super friendly, and those wings? 🔥🔥🔥 Absolutely hit the spot. I threw a little salt on them and they went from good to straight-up bangers. If you’re in it for the flavor and not the ambiance, this place still delivers. Would love to see them bring back some of the old charm, but for now? Still worth the stop.“

“First time having St Louis style pizza. The taste was good on the sweet heat and all meat pizzas. The square-shaped pieces are convenient for snacking on. However, the cuts could have been deeper. Most of the pieces were fused back together by the cheese.“

“I've ordered for pickup well over a couple dozen times and delivery a handful of times. The pizza is the best in saint louis, especially any of the magnifico line. Everyone responds quickly when I go in and 1 time they forgot our family sized salad for delivery and after calling they quickly got it out to us. This place is great and its Insane seeing any bad reviews. The chicken wings are also delicious and very well sauced.“

“Apparently nobody told me the Slices n' Sticks I wanted HAD A VARIANT called the Detroit Style! Ended up getting a big round pizza instead.

Came in March 2026. The pizza was okay. Got the pepperoni crazy Puffs and they were better.“

“a little bit of a mix-up with my delivery order (mostly on my part), but the delivery man and mike (who answered my call) were both super friendly and helpful. sorry to them for the issues, but they resolved it very quickly!!!!!! great customer service“

“These guys are great they went out of their way to help me and get the order right as it was a very large order for a big luncheon for one of my customers. I picked it up and they loaned me warming bags to take so that the pizza stayed warm I highly recommend these guys“