20 Best Italian Restaurants near Eureka

“Everyone that ate the pepperoni pizza said it was amazing. My son and I had the chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks and ravioli sampler it was all really good and seasoned perfectly. The marinara sauce for the ravioli was delicious and I do not like normally like any marinara sauce but this tasted and looked fresh. Service was amazing and neat place.“

“DELICIOUS 🤤 we will be back in town next month and SO excited to dine here again!!“

“Everything!!!Great dinner, drinks and atmosphere! Bartenders are on point!“

“LOVE Mia Sorellas. Amazing dinner, delicious cocktails and A+ atmosphere! Added to my favorite spots list.“

“We have traditionally gone to Bartolino’s South County. When they opened the one in West County we were very happy because it’s close to home as well as a very nice place to have dinner or lunch.. We have had dinner there several times And each time the food has been great and the service excellent. Very nice courteous professional people tonight we had Michell as our attendant and she did an excellent job. The atmosphere is very nice yet very comfortable business casual. Prices are not cheap, but considering what you get they’re fair. We will continue to go to Bartolino‘s, and we consider it one of our favorites for a good Italian.“

“great place to eat , friendly atmosphere, toasted ravioli and salads are the best .“

“My family was in last night for dinner and the staff was very friendly and the calzones were delicious! We love Sauce on the Side and this visit was probably the best dinner we have had there. We will definitely drive a little further to this location!“

“We ate there for the first time tonight and I can’t say enough great things about this place! We had our son who is a little over 1 with us. Mom and dad just trying to have a date night and the owner and our waitress went above and beyond! The owner was so sweet and generous just making it feel like home and our waitress was so attentive and on top of that the food was absolutely amazing!!! We will definitely be back! ❤️“

“We were in St Peter’s Mo. and were going to go to Olive Garden for my Wife’s birthday, when I told our clerk at the hotel she said she would recommend the Pasta House over the Olive Garden. We went and had supper. Everything we had was great better than the other place. We took desert back to the room and it was great. I would recommend to anybody.“

“Amazing pizza! Best lasagna! Great staff! 5 Stars!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Pictured below is the Gonzo calzone- Salami, dates, spinach, garlic herb cheese, mozzarella, mascarpone-ricotta blend, and garlic oil with garlic butter on the side. My husband looked at me like I was crazy when I read off dates but the slight sweetness against all of that savory is what made it!! We also tried the Fatty B, Meat me in St Louie, Magic Carpet Ride, and the Gyro. They were all amazing but the Gonzo and the Gyro were my favorites. The Magic Carpet Ride is also a must try if you're into mushrooms.“

“The dough, sauce, sausage was fantastic! They have a great sweet sauce. Will order again soon“

“We had an amazing time at Joey’s today, mostly thanks to our bartender Abigail! She was so kind and patient with us which is greatly appreciated, especially considering she’s in the heat all day. Lovely lady, literally will ALWAYS choose the patio if she’s out there.“

“Best pizza I have found since moving to STL four years ago! But not just the best here. One of the best ever!“

“We came and Darryl assisted us with our party we were planning, he was amazing! He answered any questions I had about the menu and catering. He was very patient and polite. Thanks for making our party amazing. We recommend 10/10 every time! Food was PHONOMINAL! Can't wait til our next event! Thanks Candicci's“

“Outstanding flavor! Loved the sauce and the cheese...everything!“

“We ordered from Cecil's (Ellisville) last pm.... We were not disappointed! The pizza was very good! The only way to improve would be to go back to the old ovens & cornmeal under the crust while cooking. Cecil's Valley Park continues to disappoint... Many chances & they are horrible. Imo's Twin Oaks... also horrible... No question...Cecil's Ellisville is the go-to! Run the Buy one get one for $4 like St. Peters, Please.“

“5 stars.

We walked in around 11am Saturday, 07/18/26, and could tell something was off, chairs still up, register not yet opened for the day. The employee at the counter kindly welcomed us in for dine-in anyway.

When it was time to pay, he and a coworker from the back had to figure out the register together from scratch, clearly not their usual job, no training, but they stayed calm, worked through it, and got us checked out correctly without complaint or excuse.

Food came out perfectly prepared and exactly as ordered.

Whatever staffing gap caused this, these gentlemen handled it with patience, kindness, and professionalism. Five stars for them, they showed up and made it work. Excellent problem solving under pressure.“

“I have eaten at many Pasta Houses over the years, since the 80’s, and today’s experience at this location is the best I’ve ever had. Both my friend and I had hot, delicious food and Tammie is one of the best waitresses we’ve ever had. We both have managed restaurants so it is not easy to impress us, so this is a real accomplishment!“

“First time having St Louis style pizza. The taste was good on the sweet heat and all meat pizzas. The square-shaped pieces are convenient for snacking on. However, the cuts could have been deeper. Most of the pieces were fused back together by the cheese.“