Sugarwitch
$ • Ice Cream, Coffee ShopsAbout Sugarwitch
Customers' Favorites
The Tara Ice Cream Sandwich
Classic Peanut Waffle Taco
Zelie V GF
Truffles
'Witches
Brownie
Tiramisu
Ursula
Gideon
Elphaba
Sugarwitch Reviews
208 ratings
Share your opinion about Sugarwitch
Unique ice cream sandwiches and ice cream tacos made on site in this historic location. Rotating menu. Welcoming & friendly service! A definite must try if in the area.
Very friendly service, easy parking, day pick up, wonderful desserts and ice creams! I highly recommend giving them a try
Delicious banana pudding waffle taco
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 3 - 10PM |
| Thursday | 3 - 10PM |
| Friday | 3 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 8PM |
Sugarwitch is a charming little shop with a nostalgic vibe, offering a delightful menu with locally made ice cream pies and a variety of allergen-friendly flavors. The staff is very friendly, helpful, and has a great sense of humor, being upfront about low stock. The mint chocolate and lemon lavender sandwiches are delicious, and the Canoli Latte, though not large or hot enough for some, has a nice flavor. Customers have raved about the iced lavender mocha as well. The store has a beautiful, artistic atmosphere with posters and a sense of community that visitors love. Many customers find the flavor combinations uniquely perfect and describe the place as a hidden gem, often discovering it through TikTok. The shop caters to gluten-free and vegan diets, ensuring an inclusive experience for all dessert lovers. While prices are high, the quality of the sweets, including seasonal flavors like Hilda pumpkin pie ice cream, makes it worth visiting. Whether on a busy weekend or a quieter weekday, Sugarwitch promises a quick service, delicious products, and a cute atmosphere that keeps customers coming back.