17 Best Pizza Restaurants in St. Peters

“This place is incredible, and I understand why making a reservation is such a hassle.

When we arrived at our designated time, we were promptly seated and greeted by our server, Erica. She was incredibly friendly and helpful, suggesting dishes that we might enjoy the most during our visit. For our first course, we had risotto balls accompanied by a refreshing salad. Both dishes were bursting with fresh flavors and textures.

For our second course, we indulged in a delightful brick oven pizza topped with pasta. After savoring both courses, we never felt bloated, as all the ingredients were imported from Italy and tasted absolutely divine. It was as if we were on an Italian vacation, dining at a restaurant.

To top off our meal, we enjoyed cannolis and gelato, accompanied by a refreshing Americano coffee. These desserts were incredibly refreshing and satisfying.

What truly set this place apart was the ambiance, the thoughtful gesture of providing separate silverware for each course, and Erica’s exceptional ability to engage us in meaningful conversations.

This place is absolutely worth the wait. You won’t find food like this anywhere else, unless you visit Italy. I highly recommend it; as an Italian myself, it reminded me of my Nonna’s cooking.

Arrivederci e a presto!“

“When I have a good experience, I review it! It is just the smallest touches that make my experience off the charts here. Amazing good, the people were VERY friendly, understand, and above all honest. Above all the was fresh, quick, and yummy! We will definitely be back when we pass through Missouri next time!“

“I stopped by imo's pizza recently, and I have to say—it was one of the best pizza experiences I’ve had in a long time.

First, the pizza was absolutely top-notch. I ordered the sweet heat, and it was a perfect blend of flavors.

But what made the visit even better was the service, especially from the manager, megan. From the moment I walked in, they were welcoming, attentive, and clearly passionate about their work.

Great food is important—but great people are what bring you back. This place has both.“

“Always good experience here. I order on app and pick it up. It’s ready when I get there and order is always correct. Baking pizza is easy and clean up is easy with the disposable trays included. The dairy free pizzas are really good too.“

“Finally got got to try the legendary Pirrone's Pizzeria Florissant while playing a great gig at Bunkers Tavern yesterday! 😊🍕💥 Awesome pizza with thin crispy crust and they use provel cheese! 💚 RECOMMENDED! 👍“

“Been there many times over the years. Their NY-style pizza is great 👍“

“I had lunch at Halftime yesterday and the food was wonderful. The special of the day was a Smashburger, homemade chips and a salad. I also shared some southwest chicken rolls as an appetizer. The southwest chicken rolls are always great, but I really loved the Smashburger and homemade chips. The chips had a really tasty seasoning on them. Apparently, this meal was a special only and not on the everyday menu, but it should be. Everything was delicious and our server was great.“

“This location successfully gets the crust crispy, even with conveyer ovens!

The addition of Pepsi zero fountain soda is nice, but will someone please tell Pepsi they always need to include Diet Dr. Pepper.

This location is right next to a fast EV charger as well.“

“Pizzas are awesome. If it is a fully loaded meat lovers pizza. Have them cook it longer in the oven. Sometimes they take it out too early and it's not all the way done but overall. Absolutely 100% best pizza. Makes me want to order a pizza right now at 9:29pm“

“Delicious food and excellent Customer Service. 5*****“

“Great food and service! Pizza, burgers, and steak night are my favorites! Great service and friendly atmosphere. Music, trivia, and other fun activities!“

“Love Cecil Whittakers pizza.“

“Great daily specials, homemade soups, fabulous pork steaks, yummy appetizers, best pulled pork nachos in town!“

“Although I'm still mad at corporate for dropping crust flavors, this Pizza Hut location has consistently been top-notch.

I order from them once every week or two. Pizzas, boneless wings and/or fries. A mix of delivery or pickup.
The buffalo burnin' hot sauce is straight addictive!

My order has been correct and cooked to perfection every time, and service is always super friendly and timely.

Correction: I think they once gave me original fries instead of cajun fries. But the fries are amazing, so I didn't mind.“

“Ised to be my favorite for pizza. Anymore they can’t deliver on time and can’t take an order right.“

“I've had nothing but excellence from here. I decided I need to give them a solid review after I messed up and had them deliver to somewhere I wasn't anywhere near. I was in the dakotas and accidentally ordered using the previous address there in st. Louis. Called them up and explained, got excellence customer service and a refund. You guys are the best there is and thank you.“

“We usually go to the highway k location. Tonight I picked up from the Mexico location in St. Peter’s. The 10 minutes that i was in the store, I observed the way the young lady worked the counter. She did an excellent job. She worked fast and managed to take orders, give orders, fill the portal and so on. She got people in and out quickly! Keep up the good work. My receipt had the name Bradley c.“