50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cottleville

“We had our son and daughter in law’s rehearsal dinner at Mellow Mushroom and boy, did we choose a great place! They had us all set up for 25 people beautifully when we arrived and was quickly introduced to our amazing server, Katie. Between her and her crew of helpers (for lack of a better word), we were taken care of so well. Tara, the bartender also tended to us with quick and excellent service. The general manager Ahmad checked on us several times to be sure we were happy and everyone was taken care of. Food and drinks were quickly and deliciously served and enjoyed. The atmosphere is so fun and upbeat. I don’t think we had one problem (except us being 7 minutes late - so sorry about that!!). We go to Mellow Mushroom as a couple and a family and now we can add as a wedding party and extended family. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!“

“We had a great time visiting Plank Road Pizza. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. We tried the sausage pizza while there and it was fantastic! The way they spread out the thin sausage was my favorite part!“

“We had a very enjoyable lunch on 8/22/2025. It was quiet since it was during school hours, the food was great, the service was outstanding for us. We plan to return as often as we can, however, it is a long drive for us, so it may not be as frequently as we would like. I love the food choices, the pricing is competitive and the service from paying to picking up our finished plates was done quickly. I look forward to our next visit.“

“There's nothing I would change about this location. Great service and the workers making and preparing the food, in addition to the man checking us out at the counter were all fabulous. We came here around 6pm on Saturday night, May 30, 2026. They all deserve a raise. Quick food preparation. The salad was fresh, and the pizza was hot. Would highly recommend visiting this location. Love that the outdoor seating area was quiet and clean.“

“Great, family style Italian food.“

“This is a very friendly place to get great food! It could be my new favorite place to get pizza. The wings were so good, my wife said they were among the best she has had, and she is very picky when it comes to wings. Awesome job Woodson Stonefire!!“

“One of the best burgers I have ever had. Every bite was juicy.“

“My family and I finally made it out. And the cheese garlic bread and pizza was everything I remember it being when I was a teenager. Absolutely delicious! The staff was extremely pleasant and the restaurant itself was very clean. Keep up the great job - can’t wait to make it back.“

“Always good experience here. I order on app and pick it up. It’s ready when I get there and order is always correct. Baking pizza is easy and clean up is easy with the disposable trays included. The dairy free pizzas are really good too.“

“Great pizza typically. We’re regulars. The sauce tasted a little different than usual. But pizza was still good. Provel bites were not edible this time, went in the trash. Tasted really salty. Not sure will be getting those anymore, definitely not the same ones we’ve been getting for the past 7 years.“

“Just tried the pizza for the first time. The Buffalo Pizza was very good. Nice flavor. I would definitely order again.“

“some of the best pizza I have had in awhile.“

“Probably the best experience at a restaurant we’ve ever had. Ethan, the waiter, was personable, accommodating, and friendly! Food was exceptional as well!“

“Every time we order the pizza is absolutely perfect. I feel like I’m so close to Chicago I can see Wrigley Field out my windows … Tonight’s pizza (Original) was out of this world Puuuurrrfffeeeccttt !“

“DELICIOUS 🤤 we will be back in town next month and SO excited to dine here again!!“

“Outstanding. Little Pricey for pasta. We will definitely return. Food was amazing pizza was delicious“

“When I have a good experience, I review it! It is just the smallest touches that make my experience off the charts here. Amazing good, the people were VERY friendly, understand, and above all honest. Above all the was fresh, quick, and yummy! We will definitely be back when we pass through Missouri next time!“

“Received a recommendation to try this location again after a recent management change. Was not disappointed. Delicious food and friendly staff. Got to meet the new manager Patrick. It was great to see the care and professionalism he had for the store and with the customers. 10/10 would recommend.“

“The wait was a bit long but well worth it. Staff was very kind and it was some good pizza“

“My grown sons and I had dinner there tonight and everything was fantastic. Staff were very polite and helpful and the food came to the table promptly, fresh and hot! Restaurant and restrooms were very clean. I ordered pizza takeout at the end of dinner for another family member who said the pizza was excellent! We look forward to coming back again soon.“

“Ised to be my favorite for pizza. Anymore they can’t deliver on time and can’t take an order right.“

“Finally got got to try the legendary Pirrone's Pizzeria Florissant while playing a great gig at Bunkers Tavern yesterday! 😊🍕💥 Awesome pizza with thin crispy crust and they use provel cheese! 💚 RECOMMENDED! 👍“

“Great lunch service, and Imo's is a very well known St Louis style pizza brand. Cracker thin crust, provel cheese, and all the traditional toppings. The guys working here are great and the food is good, but the building really needs to be updated.“

“Service was excellent. Portions were huge. Food was very average. Chef salad basically had lunch meat thrown on it. Shrimp dinner was boring. Pictured here is seafood pasta, which was *okay*. Large enough to share. But, again, the service was great!“

“First time in St Louis. Heard I had to try it from ESPN. It was amazing 🤩“

“I initially tried to place my order through the app, but it wasn’t working. I called the store, and the person who answered was extremely helpful. The manager even stepped in to assist, and she was just as helpful and kind. The food was amazing, and the delivery driver was great as well. I really appreciate the excellent customer service!“

“I walked in there to order a pizza and I was very nice and respectful and I was the only one in the place. When I looked in the kitchen the guy was doing something to my pizza and when I left and took the pizza home their was hair on my pizza and it wasn't from his head. I was so disgusted and angry and I ended up throwing my pizza away. If YOU DON'T LIKE YOUR JOB THEN QUIT AND I WILL BE REPORTING THIS.“

“Everything is always on point and very tasty. Lori is , by far, my favorite bartender. What can I say., I probably go more cause she is there! Their wings are the best and the Blue cheese 🧀 Rocks! St Charles location is by far the best!“

“Been there many times over the years. Their NY-style pizza is great 👍“

“We were having trouble ordering through the website so we tried to call the Imo’s closest to our branch and were on hold forever. When calling this location, someone answered right away and was VERY pleasant and helpful. We were technically outside their delivery area but they made an exception for us and delivered to us anyway. The woman who took our very large order was so friendly & patient. Our delivery driver was also very friendly & helpful. Our food was hot and fresh and packaged well. We were very satisfied with our experience & would highly recommend!“

“Great daily specials, homemade soups, fabulous pork steaks, yummy appetizers, best pulled pork nachos in town!“

“Great food and service! Pizza, burgers, and steak night are my favorites! Great service and friendly atmosphere. Music, trivia, and other fun activities!“

“Our waiter, Mike, was personable and quick. The food was good and hot. Loved the cream the chef added to the Manhattan clam chowder.“

“The Pizza is fantastic!! Service could be much better. They used to have salsa packets for your Taco pizza. I guess not anymore. The young man behind the counter said all they have is diced tomatoes?? Place was packed and only one cashier. Oh well. Enjoy.“

“Good food, good service. We often go to Tony's for breakfast before errands.“

“My first time trying Imo’s pizza with my family. I got the Taste of St. Louis, with a sausage pizza. Pizza was 10/10. Provel bites 10/10. Toasted raviolis 10/10. Great service from the guy working around 6:45-7 on 9/6. He definitely takes pride in his work and cares about the food he’s giving out. 10/10 would recommend. Thank you for the STL experience!!“

“We went to the new location in Wildwood on Father’s Day, with some friends, and it was refreshing watching the children playing games, and families together. This place is going to be a great success in Wildwood. Congratulations, we certainly enjoyed ourselves yesterday.“

“Delicious food and excellent Customer Service. 5*****“

“Crafty always has tasty in house brews to try and fresh brick oven food I love that they are dog friendly and the staff are easy to talk to.
I enjoy going in the late afternoon/ early evening and enjoying a bit of quiet on the patio with a late lunch!!“

“I had excellent service from the manager Ryan. There was an issue with a previous pizza order and he was so kind about the whole thing and gave me a credit. Just now used my credit to get 2 pizzas and he remembered me (4 weeks later) and was so very kind. Not sure who was working there 2 years ago when another customer had such a terrible experience, but this manager cares and we will keep going back. The pizza was GREAT.“

“We came and Darryl assisted us with our party we were planning, he was amazing! He answered any questions I had about the menu and catering. He was very patient and polite. Thanks for making our party amazing. We recommend 10/10 every time! Food was PHONOMINAL! Can't wait til our next event! Thanks Candicci's“

“Imos is our Sunday night date night in. The quality lately has been hit or miss. Tonight we finally called to same something and the young lady who handled the complaint politely and professionally listened and offered a solution to satisfy the complaint. Thank you!“

“We have loved the chesterfield locations for years and the new O’Fallon didn’t disappoint!! The atmosphere wasn’t as neat as Chesterfield, but the food and service were amazing!! I highly recommend you try them!“

“I had lunch at Halftime yesterday and the food was wonderful. The special of the day was a Smashburger, homemade chips and a salad. I also shared some southwest chicken rolls as an appetizer. The southwest chicken rolls are always great, but I really loved the Smashburger and homemade chips. The chips had a really tasty seasoning on them. Apparently, this meal was a special only and not on the everyday menu, but it should be. Everything was delicious and our server was great.“

“5 star food and service!!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Love Cecil Whittakers pizza.“

“On July 12, got two orders of the hot honey chicken tender sandwich. They were overcooked and were hard and dried out. The last time I had them, they were cooked just right and very tender. Lately, I feel it is hit or miss.“

“Great Gluten Free Pizza and loved the salads . Why did you guys remove yourself from Doordash??? We ordered from there all the time because we live in st Peter’s .“

“Great food and staff! Very attentive“