50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sugar Creek

“The pizza was exceptionally impressive. The service was prompt and efficient, and the quality of the food was excellent. The restaurant was clean and well-maintained, which is greatly appreciated. Although it is a new establishment, I am optimistic that it will maintain its current high standards.“

“WONDERFUL pizza, FANTASTIC crust, flavor is everything and pie is HUUUUGE. New favorite pizza ❤️❤️“

“We LOVE Milwaukee Deli to the point where we knew we had to have it as a late night snack at our wedding! We worked out a catering order with Jon who was so great at assisting us and making sure what we ordered showed up at our venue at the requested time! We didn't have to worry about a thing on the day and just got the glorious news from our venue coordinator that the pizza had arrived! Our guests DEVOURED this pizza. Thanks again to Jon and Milwaukee Deli for helping to make our special day even better!“

“My daughter had a healing appointment next door and I stopped in to get a salad real quick before her appointment. The gentleman offered to bring my salad to me, next door at the salon, when it was ready. Excellent customer service, way to go above and beyond for your customers!“

“I recommend a build your own pizza and the Nutella gelato! Fast and friendly service with a smile.“

“My friends and I were in town for a week at a conference. Since it was so close to the convention center, we decided to eat there one night. We went back two more times later in the week. The food is amazing and some of the best pizza we’ve ever had. The staff was so hospitable and we loved the outdoor seating area.“

“I took an out-of-town friend here who said he really liked "Fun House" pizza. When the fine people at Tim's learned of his preference, they went the Extra Mile and made his pizza almost entirely out of floor sweepings. He said it was even better than what he was used to!“

“amazing food great people“

“Amazing pizza and wonderful and friendly staff made my experience perfect! I definitely recommend il Lazzarone!“

“Mama Mia! If you liked Pizza Hut in the 90s, you're going to LOVE Simple Simon's. They took what Pizza Hut was doing back then, but then decided to do it slightly more skillfully and with better ingredients. Top notch "chain style" pizza. I prefer here to a lot of the more "fancy" local places like Buffalo State or Tascios or Minsky's personally. Wish the wings were fried and not baked though.“

“We were in town for a baseball tournament and decided to order dinner so we could relax. We ordered online so we don't know how the atmosphere is in store, food was fresh and delicious. Delivery time was good and didn't take long at all. The crust was the best part. We will recommend this restaurant to anyone we know that's in the area for any reason.“

“Good food! Our 3 kids all have very different food preferences, and they all were happy with their dinners. The pizza crust was the right amount of chewy without being doughy, and the pizza itself was loaded with toppings.“

“If your in the Crossroads area, don't skip Lou's Crab Rangoon Pizza at Pizza Shuttle. I opt for no wontons and its always a hit. I always recommend this pizza and at pizza shuttle they value you as a customer and they take pride in serving this area with prices that can't be beat! Keep up the great work!“

“We had an issue with the pricing on our order. Joe the owner of the Gladstone location not only fixed it but resolved it beyond my satisfaction. Great food and fabulous customer service.“

“I had an unforgettable dining experience at Osteria Bianchi in the Northland! Jameson was behind the bar, and I asked him to surprise me with his recommendations. He started me off with a Kanpachi Crudo paired with a crisp Buglioni Muse Lugana 2022—perfect with the dish's pea puree, shoots, and a starter so delicious I wanted every last drop.

Next came the sweet pea agnolotti (sensing a theme?), which was absolutely delicious. The pasta pockets were perfect, filled with robiola, guanciale, and summer truffle. Jameson paired this with a smooth Valmorena Barbera d’Asti 2022.

For the main course, I had the Grilled Hanger Steak, cooked to perfection and served with fingerling potatoes, kale, and a delightful pepper relish. This paired wonderfully with the Bieler Père & Fils - La Jasmine Côtes-du-Rhône Villages 2022, my favorite wine of the night.

To finish, I enjoyed an Olive Oil Cake with pistachio sauce and homemade sherbet, all complimented by a fresh espresso. I can’t stop thinking about this incredible meal and the perfect pairings Jameson selected. Hats off to owners and chefs Kelly and Josh Bianchi for creating this fantastic new spot in Kansas City!“

“Great local shop for pizza!“

“Great staff and food😎👍“

“I love mod!! The crispy burnt edges are my favorite part!!

I make the same pizza every time.

Diamond's delight (my own combo)

White sauce, garlic rub
Pep, grilled chicken, bacon,mild sausage
Roasted red pepper, tomatoes, spinach, arugula, artichoke,mushrooms
Mozzarella and Asiago, salt pep and oregano. Pesto drizzle finish!! 10/10.“

“Best place in KC! You won’t regret going“

“Great ambiance! Former gas station. The wait staff was super! We stopped in before a show at KC Rep. we each had a slice and shared a salad. The salad was yummy! The pizza slices were HUGE! The pizza was not our jam. The crust was too thick for our taste. The toppings were super. Good sauce. We'd be happy to go back and have a sandwich.“

“Wise Guy in KC is a must-visit! The pizza is a perfect blend of crispy crust and rich toppings, while the vodka pasta is creamy and flavorful. Friendly service and cozy atmosphere make it a top spot for Italian cuisine. PROTIP: paid parking lot next to the joint.“

“This is seriously good pizza! The flavors, the crust, the ladies that run it. All amazing!“

“Great service“

“Great service and good atmosphere, they have great pizzas imo but yesterday I ordered a Philly steak sandwich and it was not prepared well, the other ppl I was with had a couple of issues with their meals as well, albeit small issues but I have to deduct a star.Fantastic wait staff though.“

“Great St. Louis Style crust and toasted ravioli...oh and the lunch buffet with the salad bar is amazing.“

“Visited for the first time with a friend and cannot wait to come back! The bartender, Molly, was super friendly and very knowledgeable about all the wines!“

“Good food, great people, best pizza from Kauffman to Kansas!“

“Had heard a lot about this place and finally got to try it. Grinders definitely lives up to the hype. Had my brother from Philly in town and he loved the steak sandwich. Service was terrific and what a cool vibe the place has. Parking can be a bit tricky but don’t let that stop you from trying them out.“

“I really enjoy the staff, I have sent several employees here for lunch ?“

“My favorite place! Highly recommend, very clean, fresh and staff is awesome“

“great food, but we walked in and sat at the bar. then was told we had to get up and walk back to the front to order anything. 1st strike. then after going through that useless and time consuming exercise in futility (they had a card machine at the bar which I then was rang up on later for another drink, doesn't making everyone wait in line to order take more time? yes, it does. ), sat down back at the bar , and only wine and sangria? maybe you all should try and be a real bar too, it's not hard to make some whiskey drinks and have beers . 2nd strike. But the food is good.“

“Excellent Italian food! Good service. Everybody that I ever dealt with that works there has always been kind and professional! I am a born and raised Italian from New York City... and this place is as close to home as I can get for Italian food!!!“

“The employees are always polite, professional, and quick to help walk-ins. We frequent them at least once a week and I can't rave enough about this location. We don't even order the mainstream chains anymore. I won't get pizza from anywhere else.
P. S. The XLNY is the best NY style pizza available from any major pizza restaurants.“

“This place is awesome!! Not only is the piza, breadsticks and cheesy bread amazing! The beer was cold and cold glasses!! Denise and Kelly where nothing short of the absolute best!! We had a baby shower in the back area and they helped us and took some pics for us of the whole group! Thank you so much you helped my daughter's baby shower be nothing short of THE BEST!! Thank you again for your hospitality and amazing food! What a jewel in this community!“

“I’m a fan of Marcos and order the same pizza every time. What Surprises me is that depending on the day that I order is the amount of toppings that I get. For example on Fridays the ham pepperoni and old pepperoni is at a minimum. Now if I order tomorrow I will get a substancial amount of toppings. I have no idea why this happened but for 2 bucks per topping I want to see more than two old world pepperoni per slice. I love the pizza toppings and crust. I enjoy the sandwiches and the chicken wings. Please put more than two pepperonis per slice on Fridays. Thank you kindly.“

“Always fast and friendly! Great to have an easy place to get food everyone will love, fits everyone's dietary restrictions, and is very affordable.

Dietary restrictions: We never have any issues with the gluten free crust. The crust less bowls are great too but pricier.“

“Pretty damn good pizza. Our waitress was friendly. The one dying downside I had to it was the cream cheese n pesto dip. It was good but it was so gooey with what appeared to be mozzarella that it was hard to eat. Overall very good we will come back“

“Always have a great experience here. Food is great and the service of the bartenders and kitchen staff are top notch! Owner Brandi is the best so friendly and staff love working for her!! You can tell by there greeting when you walk in!! Thanks Brandi, Tiffany and Jose for a great evening“

“We eat pizza from Marco’s quite a bit and each experience has been positive! The customer service is wonderful and it’s easy to order online as well as over the phone. The pizza is always fresh and tasty.



Parking: This location is near Price Chopper and several other businesses so they share a large parking lot. Sometimes it can be quite crowded but you’ll find a space and it’s just a short walk. You can also opt in for curbside pickup and pull right up.“

“I never expected to find such a gem scrolling for breakfast on google. Their breakfast menu brings a beautiful blend of culinary fine dining with home style comfort food. The owners are so kind and genuine quick to strike up a conversation. And their house made chai tea is absolutely to die for, I will definitely be back time and time again for that alone. I can’t wait to come back and try their specials!“

“I called tonight and the person hung up when I was in the middle of a conversation there claim was got disconnected couldn't hear me this is the first time they did this I going let it slide this time“

“Great place to just chill!“

“We have gotten Papa Murphy’s salads and pizzas for as long as it has been there on North Oak. Always given excellent friendly service and I feel like I’m part of the family when I walk in there. Their pizzas are second to none because you build them and they just put them together and you bake them at home fresh anyway you want to. Add salad lovers. Their salads are individually made to order and my wife and I usually get one salad and split it with one pizza but if you just wanna make a salad your dinner, it is more than enough quality ingredients to make a meal.. I have tried other pizza places the last one Papa John’s did not have 2/3 of the ingredients on a very simple chicken barbecue pizza. The ingredients did not even come to Within 2 1/2 to 3 inches of the edge of the pizza very little chicken, will never eat there again. From now on, it’s Papa Murphy’s. Always.❤️“

“It has been a long time since I had a Godfather's pizza, and I was not disappointed. The staff were friendly and greeted me when I walked up to the counter. I had to only wait fifteen minutes for my pizza to be prepared. The whole surface was covered with meat and cheese. I ordered a meatlovers pizza. It was hot and gooey just like I remembered. My college memories flooded back as I ate a slice. It was a wonderful trip down memory lane. The restaurant was furnished in wood and created a homey atmosphere with all the decor. This place is so much better than what the carryout pizza joints can offer. This location also offers a pizza buffet on Sunday from 12:00-2:00.“

“Great customer service. I was greeted as soon as I entered along with a smile. I think now days people forget the power of a simple smile or a hello so it's nice when you run into an employee who makes sure you have a positive experience!“

“best pool tournaments around and the nicest staff ever! 10 out of 10“

“Right on the beautiful historic downtown Independence Missouri Square is one of my favorites in the KC Metro.

Went back today after a few years and my order was wrong... charged me for something I didn't order, also ice machine was out but the Diet Coke was cold.“

“My daughter wanted pizza for friday night dinner. I don't have great pizza options here (i thought) so i chose one I'd never tried before and it did not disappoint. I will choose this from now on instead of the others. My daughter gives it a 10/10.
I recommend Pizza of any kind.“

“Fantastic experience ordering boxed lunches for a large group at my work. Tasty sandwiches, easy process, and quick pickup!“

“We had a fantastic experience at Old Chicago! We ordered a large pizza with light sauce and three drinks, and our server went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. They were incredibly kind and attentive, always keeping our drinks full and checking in to ensure we had everything we needed. The level of service truly made our visit special. It was clear the staff did everything they could to ensure we had a great dining experience. We’ll definitely be coming back!“