The City Creamery

$ • Ice Cream

Hours today·

About The City Creamery

The City Creamery is a beloved spot for delicious handmade on site ice cream in West Yellowstone. This is a walk-up counter that is convenient to walk over to, right in the middle of town with plenty of parking. The friendly staff serve a variety of unique flavors, including the highly-recommended huckleberry ice cream and Mint Chocolate Chip. The quality of the ice cream was excellent, and customers can tell it is made with love and wonderful ingredients.

Visitors can enjoy their treats at the walk-up counter or in the charming patio area. The staff are efficient, patient, and friendly, enhancing the experience. With flavors like Huckleberry w/ Honey & Lavender, Cowboy Coffee, and Butter Pecan, there is something for everyone. Although it may be a bit pricey, the large scoops and crispy waffle cones make it worth the visit. Customers have noted that the milkshakes might need improvement, but the overall service is fast. The owners are super friendly; notably, Joe was really kind, explained the process of making salted caramel, and showed the fresh ingredients. For those exploring Yellowstone National Park, The City Creamery is the perfect spot to satisfy a sweet tooth with delicious homemade ice cream.

Menu

Add a Menu
The City Creamery Menu
The City Creamery Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
The City Creamery
The City Creamery
View All Photos

The City Creamery Reviews

4.2
240 ratings
5
70%
4
6%
3
5%
2
7%
1
12%
Food
4.4
Atmosphere
4.5
Service
4.6

Share your opinion about The City Creamery

Huge shoutout to The City Creamery in Cave Creek. We went on Monday and asked if they had licorice ice cream and they didn’t at the moment so the wonderful lady took my name and number said she would call me when they had some. She called me yesterday afternoon and today we made the trek to Cave Creek to get some wonderful ice cream and also bought two pints of licorice to bring home! They give military discounts too which is amazing because we all love a good business that...read full review
Fresh, delicious, homemade ice cream-this is the best ice cream I have ever tasted! You’ve got to go get ice cream at The City Creamery, it’s the BEST!
This place is so good, got the huckleberry and it was amazing. The people working also very kind.

Read All Reviews(240)

Hours

Monday 12 - 9PM
Tuesday 12 - 9PM
Wednesday 12 - 9PM
Thursday 12 - 9PM
Friday 12 - 9PM
Saturday 12 - 9PM
Sunday 12 - 9PM
Updated on: