4.4
Superb
274 Reviews
1333 North Road Street, Elizabeth City
Customers’ favorites
- Baked Italian Trio
- Cheese Steak Sub
- Hawaiian Calzone
- Hamburger Steak
“🍕 THREE TIMES IN… AND BARLEY’S IS ON POINT AGAIN. SOLD! 🍕 Let me tell you about the pizza nightmare we’ve experienced over the last four years of living in Elizabeth City. 😂 I didn't think to take a picture - we ate it all- boom there you go! We consider ourselves pizza aficionados (yes, we have standards). We like a good sauce, not an obscene amount of cheese, and a crust that can actually fold when you need it to—but also one that, when you hold it by the crust, doesn’t droop like an old man’s eyelid. 😂 Over the past four years, we’ve tried our fair share of pizza places in Elizabeth City, and every one seems to have had something that just didn’t work for us. Too much cheese. Wrong sauce. Soggy crust. You name it. Now, we aren’t the people who bash restaurants or leave negative reviews just because something wasn’t our cup of tea. If we’re going to take the time to say something, it’s because it’s GOOD—and, more importantly, CONSISTENT. And Barley’s? Three visits in, and they’ve delivered every single time. The wings deserve a shout-out too! These aren’t those weakling, baby-chick wings that leave you wondering where the actual chicken went. 😂 They’ve got some meat on them, and the hot flavor has just the right kick. Now, you’re not going to Barley’s for fancy ambiance—and honestly, that’s perfectly fine with us. We like our house. We pick up our food, put on the game, and eat exactly where we want. 🍕🏈 So, without a doubt, we are officially happy to report: WE LOVE BARLEY’S. And to all the other pizza guys out there… 👀 You might want to keep an eye on this one. Barley’s is a silent gem, and word is definitely getting out. 🍕🔥”