10 Best Bakeries near Nags Head

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Bakeries near Nags Head.

Showing 10 of 10 restaurants

  • Almost Heaven Bakery OBX 3033 South Croatan Highway, Nags Head Bakery · $

    1 Almost Heaven Bakery OBX

    4.8 Superb 118 Reviews

    3033 South Croatan Highway, Nags Head

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Strawberry Cupcakes
    • Beach Themed Cake
    • Key Lime Cake
    • Birthday Cake

    “My beautiful friend ordered a surprise cake for me, for my birthday. I wish I could add a photo to my review because it is gorgeous. My friend told me it was fun talking with the lady she ordered from. The cake is one of the best I’ve had, and I love cake ❤️ Thank you”

  • Cookies and Cream 106 East Finch Street, Nags Head Ice Cream Shop · $

    2 Cookies and Cream

    4.9 Superb 234 Reviews

    106 East Finch Street, Nags Head

    Customers’ favorites

    • Royale Cookie with Ice Cream
    • White Chocolate Macadamia
    • Black Raspberry
    • Cookies & Cream

    “Stopped for the ice cream fell in love with the cookies. The ice cream is from a NC creamery and I recommend the Lemon Crunch 🍋 But the cookies are a blessing for your taste buds. I got the coconut cookie and my husband raved about the white chocolate macadamia. I wish we had tried this sooner... but it's 10 miles down the beach 😆”

  • Proof Bakery 402 South Croatan Highway, Kill Devil Hills Bakery · $

    3 Proof Bakery

    4.8 Superb 237 Reviews

    402 South Croatan Highway, Kill Devil Hills · 4.2 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Breakfast Sandwich Sausage Egg and Cheese with Lettuce Tomato and Spicy Mayo
    • Boston Cream Berliner Donut and Chocolate Croissant
    • Boston Cream Donut and Chocolate Croissant
    • Honey Bun Pecan Roll Apple Cheese Danish

    “What can I say..well let's start here. The owner is a friend of mine I've know for a few years now. And to say he is a baker does not do him justice. He is well knowledged in what he is doing. And to step into his bakery is well...PROOF. He takes his business seriously to say the least. Professional is key word here. So if you are looking to find the finest homemade Delectables to take home and enjoy and share look no further. There are many fine upstanding bakeries here on the Outer Banks. Do not let this one slip through your fingers or tastebuds.”

  • Mia's Bake Shop & Tea Room 109 Sir Walter Raleigh Street Unit 101, Manteo Recommended Bakery · $$

    4 Mia's Bake Shop & Tea Room

    4.9 Superb 107 Reviews

    109 Sir Walter Raleigh Street Unit 101, Manteo · 4.2 miles

    Customers’ favorites

    • Coffee Cake
    • Key Lime Pie

    “Lovely shop with delicious scones and tea. Perfect place for a bridal shower, a birthday tea party, or a quiet stop with a friend. Definitely going back!”

  • Pionono Bakery Manteo Bakery · $

    5 Pionono Bakery

    4.6 Superb 40 Reviews

    Manteo · 4.66 miles

    Customers’ favorites

    • Carrot Cake

    “so good!!!! I had never tried peruvian baked items before but once I did , I have returned every time I'm in manteo.”

  • Brown Suga Cupcakery Old Nc Hwy 345, Manteo Bakery · $

    6 Brown Suga Cupcakery

    5.0 Superb 5 Reviews

    Old Nc Hwy 345, Manteo · 4.76 miles

    • Delivery

    “Cupcakes are delicious and fresh. Owner is very professional and responsive. She takes great pride in her work and it shows through the look and taste of her desserts. You won’t be disappointed.”

  • Johanna’s Events and Catering 1064 Old Wharf Road, Wanchese Caterers · $$

    7 Johanna’s Events and Catering

    4.9 Superb 133 Reviews

    1064 Old Wharf Road, Wanchese · 8.13 miles

    • Delivery

    “Johanna’s Catering is absolutely incredible. Easy 5 stars all around. We booked them for both our rehearsal dinner and our brunch the morning after our wedding, and they exceeded expectations at both events. The staff is amazing, the customer service is top-notch, and the food… absolutely outstanding. Every detail was handled with such care, and their team went above and beyond. Everyone was SO nice!! Our guests are still raving about how delicious everything was! If you’re looking for a catering team that is talented, professional, and a joy to work with, Johanna’s Catering is the one.”

  • Crumbl 5385 North Virginia Dare Trail Ste 4, Southern Shores Bakery · $$

    8 Crumbl

    4.4 Superb 275 Reviews

    5385 North Virginia Dare Trail Ste 4, Southern Shores · 11.15 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • A Variety of That Week's Cookies
    • Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie
    • Aggie Blue Mint Cookie
    • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    “Store and employees are great. Crumbl needs to step up now. Quit changing everything. It has gotten to the point where you have so many ingredients that the cookies are like everything bagels…..everything but the kitchen sink. Then when a cookie is rated good it never gets back in the queue again. Then you took away the milk chocolate chip cookie and the new chocolate chip cookie has a weird flavor. The original chocolate chip cookies were perfect!”

  • Icing on the Cakes 4827 Lunar Drive, Kitty Hawk Bakery · $$

    9 Icing on the Cakes

    4.1 Good 38 Reviews

    4827 Lunar Drive, Kitty Hawk · 10.36 miles

    “Debra was absolutely wonderful to work with! Since I was planning our wedding from out of state, I especially appreciated how easy, accommodating, and communicative she was throughout the entire process. She made everything feel simple and stress-free. I needed a gluten-free wedding cake, and Debra absolutely DELIVERED! The cake was not only beautiful, but incredibly delicious. So many of our guests commented on how amazing it was and said they never would have guessed it was gluten-free. That was especially important to me, and I was so grateful that I didn’t have to sacrifice taste in order to have a cake I could safely enjoy on my wedding day. Our cake was such a hit that we actually couldn't resist eating the slices we had saved for our first anniversary! So, naturally, we are planning to return next year and order another cake just so we can enjoy it again. We are so grateful to Debra for making our wedding cake experience so easy, delicious, and memorable. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a talented, accommodating, and wonderful cake vendor!”

  • Speedway 202 US-64, Manteo Donut Shops

    10 Speedway

    3.4 Good 14 Reviews

    202 US-64, Manteo · 4.62 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    “12/2020 update: The staff at the Manteo Speedway, is at best ,touch & go, there isnt alot of attention to customer service, perhaps the Covid Virus has something to do with that? When I go in, sometimes you see a mask on, but not always, depends on who is working and the time of visit' the front checkout are not always there, ready to wait on you, I've seen more than a few times, coffee or soda breaks, than walking behind counter, not hand sanitizing, which for someone like myself, finds concerning, why? Because I have a compromised immune system, & with being chronically ill" it sometimes makes me wonder why I bother? I have to request my receipt, I'd say everytime but perhaps 2 times in the last year, and having a speedway online/on phone' account..I've had my card not scan or phone, and because of no receipt, not been able to prove & get my earned points.. since noticing this, I pointedly request it, it always is as though I asked for there money.. the friendliness is not as once, occasional bouts of politeness, but I dont work there and probably show better customer service to the staff workers than they do to myself or others, also...it can be disturbing to see workers on frequent smoke breaks, where there seen at corner outside back of building, I've tried contacting the toll free speedway account # to ask for help or assistance..but no answers, and emails haven't been answered for months as well.. and if there is a sign posted saying " points for given items" than you check out & they say "Oops, that was supposed to be down" so in order words.. to bad, I still stop in on occasion, but with less cleanliness done, no rules followed in regards to NC state& County rules in the response to Covid, it's not where I go much anymore, may seem like just one person, but if I feel this way, & others do, well it adds up.. I hope to see what I see as a past favorite store make changes.. if not losing myself & others may add up to loss of profits & the store becoming a convenience store that makes it during the times we are going thru, hope not, but til it changes, get gas outside with credit, avoid inside if possible, unless your lucky enough to know you will never be susceptible to sickness or spreading to your loved ones, lucky you if that's the case.. 10/2017 Joseph, and his staff( ya all know who you are) that I'v come to know, I mean the ones who are still there not just for a couple months ,are Awesome! I have issues walking around and they are always there to lend a hand, answer a question, smile and encourage you when you've had a long day,I actually feel there like 'family " lol, and the "Speed Way ' program is a great way to earn..gas, food, gift cards, whatever you want.. I love the app. to , it's easy to use and updates constant, plus they have the best Gas prices, including the one in Kill Devil Hills, so thanks to ya all. I know you've had a lot of changes this year, but your the Best!”

Bakeries Nearby