12 Best Ice Cream Shops in Nags Head

“This is the best froyo I have ever had I would do anything for this place to be where I’m from in Buffalo I’ve only been on my trip for 3 days and I’ve already had 3 bowls If this was around me all the time I would be morbidly obese thank you surf and spoon for the wonderful experience I will be coming here everyday for the rest of my trip“

“Stopped for the ice cream fell in love with the cookies. The ice cream is from a NC creamery and I recommend the Lemon Crunch 🍋 But the cookies are a blessing for your taste buds. I got the coconut cookie and my husband raved about the white chocolate macadamia. I wish we had tried this sooner... but it's 10 miles down the beach 😆“

“Great ice cream, tasted just like the label claimed it would. Didn't taste like blended juice. Fair prices and awesome selection of indoor and outdoor seating. Ice cream didn't melt. And everyone there has the iPhone 17 pro. Nice hats!“

“Lots of flavors, big portions, close to the beach, indoor and outdoor seating, plenty of parking, friendly staff, and a merch room. The only thing not to like was the prices. 5 single scoop orders, throw in 2 waffle cones, 2 squirts of whip cream, 1 sprinkle topping, 1 peanut topping 1 chocolate syrup topping = $41 before tip. Average order $8.20.“

“Absolutely recommend! Can’t meet nicer staff or owners! This stuff tastes amazing!“

“The LOBSTER ROLL is the BEST!!! Ignore any comment about price or size....it is WORTH IT! So delicious and the roll compliments the flavors so well! It's the first stop when we roll into town on vacation! So much love and good food from this shop! Perfectly situated on the Beach Road...don't let the small business fool ya!! They pack an amazing punch!“

“Best ice cream I’ve ever had! Wish we could take it all home! ❤️ While here we tried Choco Loco (if you love chocolate this is the one for you), Banana Pudding (delicious), peach (incredible!), Coco Loco (so good!). Everything is made fresh - and they are so welcoming! Highly recommend.“

“First time visitors to Booty Treats Ice Cream in Nags Head. We have for several years in a row, ice creamed at a shop on the south end of Virginia Dare Trail. After stopping there, we were not happy with the service or the serving sizes for the price. So we decided to try Booty Treats north location. What a difference! Decent pricing. Fast service (13 in our group and had our ice cream within minutes of ordering). Pricing was about 20% less than the other shop, serving sizes were larger and the ice cream was way better. We have a new ice cream stop when we visit the Banks. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Amazing ice cream & candy, every kind of homemade chocolate-covered whatever & fudge you can imagine, a completely empty shop at 8pm, and great customer service and recommendations. Came for the coconut caramel chocolate s'mores, stayed for the ice cream; came back for the homemade peanut butter cups.“

“We had dessert there last night and it was fantastic! Great ice cream and milkshakes. 😍😍“

“I’ve been coming to the Outer Banks for 30 years. I remember getting the best burger on the OBX at this restaurant. Apparently they have stopped serving food. That is not the issue. I called up to ask if they no longer serve burgers, and was told “this isn’t McDonald’s”. I don’t appreciate being spoken to that way from a worker of a restaurant I want to spend my money at. If they can’t train their staff to have better customer service, I cannot imagine how poorly they treat customers at the restaurant. Very disappointed.“

“I have been vacationing here in Nags Head for the past 9 years. We LOVE the Outer Banks area. So laid back and relaxing. My husband & I actually own 6 weeks in a villa from Mid February to End of March to escape the Winter snow of upstate NY. One of my MUST VISITS is this Sugar Planet! I love the variety of candies that you can mix by the scoop fulls of my favorites. They also have nostalgic candies and some I’ve never even heard of before. Don’t be fooled by the name 'Sugar Planet'. Clothing, mugs, jewelry, hats, etc. It could almost be your one stop shop for all souvenirs! I’ve been in here 3 times alone in the past two weeks! Michelle was extremely helpful as I was looking for something special to take back for my daughter-in-laws. Together we found the ‘perfect’ items! Thank you Michelle. Today there was a young man training at the checkout, Carlos, was very kind and polite. I do love this Southern Hospitality!“