18 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Bern

“We’ve been eating at Gina’s for YEARS! It’s a family favorite!!“

“The best pizza, cheese sticks and steak n cheese subs we have had! Been several times love it always stop in whenever we get this way!“

“Absolutely delicious food and friendly servers! There were 6 for lunch. We had chicken & brussell sprouts, strawberry salad, 2 shrimp and fries, and two other entrees. All were delicious and huge servings!“

“This is one of my favorite places to order lunch during my work week. The food is great and my order is always ready when they say it will be!“

“I have eating at Sara's since she opened. He menu is one of the largest if not the largest menu in New Bern. everything I have ever eaten at Sara's is delicious. The meatballs are large and delicious, and I love the marinara sauce. Service is always good with a smile. and I don't know of another restaurant that earned 100% from the NC Health Department.“

“We’re new bern natives and we come to Mario’s often. They are the real deal. My family is from NYC so I feel qualified to say this. My son and I had lunch here today and he said “This is the best pizza of my life.” He literally says this every time we come here. Hot tip: ask for the cordon bleu pizza. It’s incredible.“

“My grandson's birthday was today and he choose his favorite Pizza Hut to eat. After getting my salad I asked the waitress (Zan) if there was like a birthday cake or something I could purchase for him. She wasn't sure but took the time to come up with something. We'll after our meal she took it to a level I couldn't believe. She gathered up the employees and where she got the candle from who knows and dimmed the lights and they all came out to sing for him. The look of surprise on his face was priceless. I want to thank the employees and especially Zan for this beautiful gesture. Thank you so much to all of you!“

“This is by far the Best Domino's Pizza shop. My family and I have never had a bad experience from here. The staff is always smiling, and welcoming when you go inside to get your food. The food has always been hot, and we haven't had an order that was messed up. Keep up the Phenomenal work.“

“We have consistently had great pizza of every kind from this Domino’s. I seriously don’t understand the not 5 star across. We have ordered from them almost weekly for two years. Their pizzas of all types are excellent, crust whether crispy or garlic original is delicious. The brownie bites are gooey and good. Parmesan bread bites are awesome. Salads are good but not a lot to those but it’s not a salad bar so you do get decent portion. Service by driver is always friendly and quick to arrive. My only suggestion is for management to consider adding a cauliflower crust pizza, then we might order twice a week! To me, it’s the best pizza comparable to any great Italian restaurant.“

“I have been unhappy with most of the pizza stores, as a Italian cook I always enhance taste in all my recipes. Tonight I had Big Apple Pizza and it had great flavor. No pizzeria in New Bern can top them, give it a try you won't be disappointed.“

“Not sure the name of the manager but she runs a tight ship. She's awesome, keeps the team motivated, and even deals with crazy customers who come in complaining about the wait with absolute decorum. Plus, I'm pretty sure she dressed up as Link on Halloween so that makes her even cooler. Thank you for a great experience!“

“Lunch at 37th today. It was delicious!!! Service was friendly and prompt. Could not have asked for a better experience. We have been coming to New Bern for a few years now and 37th is one of our go to places. We will be back!“

“Holy cow, this is one of the best almond croissants that I’ve had…and I’ve had a lot. Yesterday’s apple cruffin was delightful as well, and of course the plethora of cookies that we have tried. I would take a photo to add to my review but I already ate said croissant. 10/10 would recommend!“

“Ordered late night delivery on Saturday Nov. 12th of 22. Our order was placed at around midnight close to 1am and arrived on time and fresh and hot. Requested my pizza to be in the shape of a heart and they nailed it! I loved it! It was perfect! It was beautiful AND delicious. Toppings were just as requested as well. Seriously, whoever made this za, you need a raise .😎🍕“

“I'm from Chicago and I miss Chicago pizza terribly.
I've lived in MA, CT and now NC and have not found ANY pizza that I could even like, let alone continue to order from.
I just had to say, while it's still not Chicago pizza, this particular restaurant does not disappoint.
When I ask for extra sauce and extra cheese, they give me exactly that! The pizza is very good and I do order on a regular basis.
I've learned to make my own, somewhat comparable to what I grew up on but when I'm feeling lazy, Papa John's on Glenburnie is it!!!
Thank you! ?“

“The best pizza in town 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“Everything was very delicious and our waiter was great. Give this place a try.“

“We came all the way from Norfolk, Va since our 2 locations shut down years ago and new bern was our closest location . I’ve missed their food so much and it didn’t disappoint ! Our sandwiches and soups were hot and fresh and the customer service was great! The bathrooms were very clean as well as the inside . All supplies for dine in customers were stocked and the dining area was clean. We’ll be coming back soon ! Thanks Schlotzsky’s ❤️“