Pizza Restaurants near Supply

“Excellent pizza almost as good as Ct's Pepe's which is where I learned about great pizza. 2 areas of improvement needed. 1) spread sauce and toppings farther out on the crust. 2) Cook the crust longer to get it brown or more cooked instead of soft. Needs crunch.“

“The very best place for pizza, subs and wings in the surrounding area. Very good food & service. Do yourself a favor and check them out and see for yourself!!!!.“

“I went in and grabbed a hot n ready three meat pizza and paid for it, when I was walking to my truck I looked at the sticker which said sell by 4:36 and it was 4:09. The box was barely warm and since they switched from the boxes you could see into there's no way to tell what it looks like til you open the box.
So I got to my truck and opened the box and basically the cheese was completely dried out and the toppings were at the least unappetizing. I want back in which I hate to do and asked for a different pizza. The cashier's and cook both told me they've had issues with the prior cook making way too much food and have had this same problem which they've reported numerous times. Anyways the cook told me to not apologize and he'd happily have me a new pizza in about 6 minutes.
You might ask why 5 stars. Well I don't feel like it's the cooks fault it's not as if those pizzas were out of time and he seemed very disappointed to keep having said issue and was more than happy to make me a fresh one. I appreciate that very much I now regret not giving him a tip so I wanted to make sure to somehow make my appreciation known.“

“Just got a Philly sub sandwich with no meat. Nothing but cheese. Also got a stuff crust pizza that is absolutely the worst pizza ever.“

“Great pizza and wings. Awesome owner and staff. You feel like you are part of an extended family while enjoying delicious food.“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Papa J’s in Shallotte has an amazing staff. They took the time to give us extra care and attention. John, Stephanie, and Chris took great care of us and we’ll be telling everyone what a terrific team John leads. They showed grace, and were an excellent representation of what customer service should be, even under the pressure of a holiday-weekend Saturday night rush. Thank you Papa John’s of Shallotte!“

“Awesome pizza. Awesome spaghetti and meatballs. Awesome stromboli. Haley is the best server hands down. Tastes just like the previously closed Angelos.“

“Food is decent. I personally think the 🍕 is a lil pricey.“