What are you looking for?

Pizza Restaurants in Winterville

4.9 - 56 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

4125 Old Tar Rd # L, Winterville
(252) 751-0411

Papa Johns Pizza

Hands down, one of if not the best in Eastern Carolina. I am a NY snob when it comes to pizza! The sauce and the cheese is where it starts. The dough is ... More reviews

4.2 - 93 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

781 W Fire Tower Rd, Winterville
(252) 214-7426

Papa Johns Pizza

Awesome cheese=steak and pizza. Nice dine-in, great staff.We were big fans of the Washington location until they closed in the patio and made it not dog-... More reviews

4 - 134 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 12AM

701 W Fire Tower Rd Unit A, Winterville
(252) 321-7555

Papa Johns Pizza

5 toping pizza large me & my wife enjoyed she eat half l eat half ,we miss a large at least eight toppings at Sam's club hour too late. More reviews

3.8 - 166 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

740 W Fire Tower Rd Suite #115, Winterville
(252) 689-6330

Papa Johns Pizza

Staff was awful. Was seated in the back with a bunch of other families, really loud. Asked to move to a quiet spot. Dirty restaurant overall. Ordered a $... More reviews

3.7 - 119 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

4328 Winterville Pkwy, Winterville
(252) 353-0006

Papa Johns Pizza

Drive up and while I waited an eternity for the person in front of me at the drive thru to get their one pizza I noticed this location has a health code ... More reviews

2.9 - 97 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 10PM

675 W Fire Tower Rd, Winterville
(252) 353-5300

Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza was just ok. The wings were soft and mushy. Barely edible. Too many employees with big hair and no hair nets. More reviews

View on map