19 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Bern

“We’ve been eating at Gina’s for YEARS! It’s a family favorite!!“

“Absolutely love this little place !!“

“The best pizza around!!!!“

“The chef at Beartown recently accommodated a very specific food request for a child's birthday and it was wonderful. It was the only request my kiddo made for his birthday and we were so fortunate he was willing to help make it happen. Thank you for the wonderful meal and gentle attention you and your workers provided.“

“Excellent service and food is wonderful! Highly recommend!“

“The wings are great and the salad bar is ok but need some work. The service is terrible and they are always short staff. The staff give you the impression that they don’t care if you dine with them or not. Sometimes the food is over cooked or under cooked. Just not the place I grew up loving to eat at.

Vegetarian options: Not much but a few options

Wheelchair accessibility: The have a wheelchair accessible ramp to get in restaurant“

“It's domino's at the end of the day but I will say this location tries its best. We've had multiple order mishaps and the manager is always quick to try and correct the order by either remaking it entirely or including extras like drinks or deserts. All in all they've earned our loyalty and the customer service is top notch“

“Amazing customer service at this specific location on mlk Blvd in New Bern nc. It's my 2nd time having trouble (my fault both times;I ordered online and made a mistake) They took care of it immediately, no questions asked. I prefer this location over the one on Neuse Blvd (I've been there once ) Even though I live 3 minutes away from the one on Neuse I rather drive 10 minutes to this location because of their customer service. Thanks guys! Keep up the good work!“

“Fastest delivery in town. My last 3 orders have been in my hand within 15 mins of completing my online order! Driver even brought a dipping sauce (random choice) when they saw I didn’t select one with my order. That spoke volumes to me… even the driver wants me to get my moneys worth. PayPal and ApplePay option is outstanding too.“

“Very clean, good atmosphere and the food & service was amazing.“

“Best pizza my wife and I have had in NC. great customer service. If you know pizza you know the crust is what makes it. it was fluffy, light, crunchy and so flavorful. The wings were very tasty as well. A little on the small side for wings but for under 10 dollars for a dozen is unheard of now for them. very good wing tho. will be bringing the kids here next time.“

“Pizza is good, chicken parm sub is great. My only issue is white pizza is supposed to have broccoli, at least it does everywhere else in the country. New Bern and havelock Mario’s both do not put broccoli on it.“

“I've only had my food delivered. However, I've seen the actual restaurant. It's quite large with ample seating. I'm from NYC, and the pizza is the closest I've found to home.

Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, veggie subs, pasta“

“If you order from app for pickup, it gives you a food ready time and starts a count down, it’s not sync with the restaurant. In best case scenario add 10 mins to apps ready time, cause if you pull to drive up window and another customer pulls behind you, you will be asked to pull back around to window. All, with not giving you a timeline other than your order is still in the oven. Domino’s app is synced with store, at least when there app says your order is ready. It is ready. With today’s technology, Pizza Hut could do better.. Its not like their pizza is off hook, all these chains with the conveyor ovens are, all about the same in taste and quality.

Parking: Strip mall, plenty of parking in lot but not at front door, also has a drive thru“

“I'm from Chicago and I miss Chicago pizza terribly.
I've lived in MA, CT and now NC and have not found ANY pizza that I could even like, let alone continue to order from.
I just had to say, while it's still not Chicago pizza, this particular restaurant does not disappoint.
When I ask for extra sauce and extra cheese, they give me exactly that! The pizza is very good and I do order on a regular basis.
I've learned to make my own, somewhat comparable to what I grew up on but when I'm feeling lazy, Papa John's on Glenburnie is it!!!
Thank you! ?“

“Great food & super people! Love their food. And it's always nice & clean. I eat there frequently.“

“Today, we had a birthday get-together for my uncle Gerald 90 birthday. Believe they over 50 in attendance. Audrey and her coworker, who I don't remember his name, were assigned to us. Their uniforms were spot on so neat and professional looking.They both worked together as a team, making sure all our needs were met and always with a smile. Our party was truly blessed to have both of them there for us. They are both a huge asset to the success of your restaurant.“

“Amazing atmosphere,service and excellent pizza. It was our first time dining here and we will definitely be back.“

“Couple times I ordered a salad & it wasn't as good as the first. The greens sometimes were brownish & wilted. Otherwise, the service was good. Love their oatmeal raisin cookies.

Parking: Most of the time, I park up front.“