6 Best Italian Restaurants near Amherst

“One of our go to restaurants! We celebrate all our family birthdays here and love it! Food is delicious and have never had a meal we didn't love. Always get the fried mozzarella triangles. They are the best. Service is always outstanding no matter who we get. 5+stars from us!“

“I don't give anyone 5 stars but this place was that good. The food was fresh and made while we waited, no microwave here. The bartender knew what she was doing and made fabulous drinks. The service was impeccable and the music in the background was so good you want to sing along which one of the waitresses would occasionally do. Fantastic experience, great food and drinks. Sorry we waited so long to try it.“

“Do you love a good meatball sub? I do. And I love love love Marc’s. The meatballs are beyond compare. Seriously awesome.The waiting time can vary, so order ahead if you can. Sometimes Marc needs to make more meatballs, or whatever, and there can be a bit of a delay.Insider tip: Their large subs are ginormous, so be sure you know how big they are before you order one!“

“Wish I had tried this place a decade ago! Absolutely blown away. From the outside area you wouldn't expect such a gem hidden right there. Linen tablecloths, quiet, candle light, its the cute spot from the movies and with really delicious food!“

“Great Food. We order often (every week) and never have had ANY issues.Call ahead 30-40 minutes, as they get busy and it's fresh food!!!They also have great yummy little treats in the back fridge that are always worth looking!!!!!Bon Appé“

“Wow! If I could give 10 stars I would. Hands down best pizza I’ve had! I absolutely loved walking into Gustos and seeing the huge pizza oven right there. It was a cozy yet modern atmosphere. With such a cute little store! I got the margherita pizza and four cheese. The cheese is so delicious. You can just tell it’s quality made. To top it off we had some of their homemade gelato! The strawberry tastes just like fresh strawberries. All of this wrapped up with the kindest people I’ve had the pleasure of interacting with.“