12 Best Italian Restaurants near Newmarket

“Great food & service Love Panz!“

“Cornicello is truly one of those hidden gems - staff is incredibly friendly and extremely helpful. Food is superb !! Love the layout of tables - all by the windows with river views. Warm friendly community atmosphere (not stuffy). My daughter and I love this restaurant and have made this our special meeting place. Bravissimo Cornicello !!“

“Their Sweet Chicken Curry Sub is to die for! So yummy!“

“Staying in the area and honestly there's a lot of places I could have gotten food. Sofias stood out to me with their homemade pasta and the reviews were positive. Well... Let me tell you. They absolutely will not let you down. Great pasta, incredibly fresh homemade bread, large portions and the sauce is rich with a perfect consistency.
I ordered takeout and they took the time to cling wrap the entire container, which was above and beyond and very much appreciated.
The hostess was extremely friendly and welcoming. In fact, my only regret was not dining in. The place was immaculately clean and very spacious. Truthfully, it smelled like my grandma's house. She was 100% Italian and it really brought back some memories. Looking forward to going back. I might even stock up on their food prep containers.“

“we have been going there for years. I always get the 6" pizza and a salad . very good.Highly recomend it!“

“We were there, this weekend. The food and the service was incredible!“

“Love the food. I was disappointed that we were told we couldn’t sit in a booth. She said the booths were All reserved. We had a toddler who does so much better in a booth. I honestly considered walking out. We ate and left and only 2 parties came in and used the booth leaving approximately 95 percent of the booths open.“

“We ordered for a memorial service. Food was delicious!“

“excellently prepared dishes consistently on every visit .very precisioned managed even when crowded ,clean,friendly, fast efficient service i like that they keep checking back on you during your great dining experience.also, excellent portions, definitely worth the drive that keeps me coming back.... And yes,they have takeout, take it home and take all the credit!! apps. fried calamari ,diavlo entree: prime rib patty melt 12/15/24“

“Had an amazing time today! Food awesome and service was fantastic. The new chef is wonderful! Highly recommend!!“

“The best!“

“Large steak and cheese is NOT dry at all and has almost twice the steak of wildcat pizza.... I have switched. 15 year local of Durham.“