Sandwich Shops near Bernardsville

“This particular Jersey Mike's has the best bread I've ever gotten from a JM. The staff was super friendly and kind. Corporate needs to copy and paste this location! The only complaint is that you need to find a way to show the sign better from the road. Was worth hunting this spot out! 6 out of 5 stars!“

“They did an excellent job catering our family Christmas party. Ordering was easy and food was ready and hot at the agreed upon pickup time. Best of all everything was delicious.“

“Fresh, delicious a very friendly atmosphere! Just what we needed in this area. Can’t wait to tell the family!“

“Everything is so fresh and everything taste wonderful. Staff is absolutely fantastic. Very nice and friendly.“

“I kept seeing the “Let Mike Have His Way” trend all over TikTok, so I walked in and said, “Giant number 13, and go ahead, let Mike have his way with my sub.”

And honestly? Best decision I’ve made all week.

The sandwich I got felt like it was made by someone who really knows what they’re doing. The flavors, the textures, the layering—it all worked together so perfectly. The bread was warm and soft, packed with fresh, flavorful meats, crisp veggies, and just the right amount of juice. I didn’t even know what I was getting into, but every bite had me thinking, “This is exactly how a sub should taste.”

Letting Mike have his way took all the pressure off ordering and turned the whole experience into a fun surprise—and somehow it still ended up being one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had. You can tell there’s real skill behind the counter.“

“Food is always a 10/10 however have noticed the pickup process has slipped lately. The last few times I ordered for pickup via DoorDash I have had to wait 10-30 minutes after arriving at the estimated time for pickup. I understand it's only an estimate but a continual 10+ min delay is frustrating and estimates need to be updated to accurately reflect the turnaround time required during peak hours.“

“Best Reuben sandwich I ever had in my life. Highly recommend trying it“

“I have NEVER, IN ALL THE YEARS I've been there had even one bad sub. Ever! Best Subs around...blows away all those "chain" sub places.“

“Best sub sandwiches. Friendly staff!“

“Best little hometown deli! If you need a quick breakfast sandwich lunch or snack this is the place to stop in while getting your gas tank filled at the BP next door! Can’t beat their prices for the quality and portion of food you receive. They are very friendly when you walk in and always remember you when you return! They’re a small mom and pop deli that should most definitely be patroned. A favorite of ours is the bacon egg and cheese sandwich for breakfast. School kids also love this deli as they all stop in after school for a mid afternoon snack and sometimes morning breakfast. A fantastic on the go breakfast/lunch/snack/coffee/drink to go! Play the lottery here too!“

“Big THANK YOU to Jersey Mike’s Subs for supporting healthcare workers!“

“This place is awesome! The lady at the front was so nice and made sure we ordered what we wanted.There were A LOT of people around the line and they seemed to have no idea how to watch where they’re going.The food was definitely good. The fries were amazing (very well cooked) and I LOVED the ranch. The cheesesteak was also top-notch. The buffalo chicken cheesesteak was great but not out-of-this-world the best I’ve ever had. Overall we’d probably go again.

Parking: THIS LOCATION IS IN A MALL. During busy times there may be parking but it’ll be a little further back in the lot.“

“Such a friendly and welcoming place, the food is AMAZING as well as the costumer service. I’ve been helped by Kim many times she always makes sure the place is clean and sanitary as well as the rest of the staff! This is a wonderful place at eat and the sandwiches are so filling!“