“This was my first time to this location. This interior is small but does have table stop seating for eight on one side (two tales of four) and two regular tables that seat a total of eight on the other side. My previous experiences were limited to Newark Airport in 2016 and 2017. My order then to bring home was the #6 Roast Beef and Provolone and the #13 The Original Italian Provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni. I had a very favorable opinion of the #6 however, not so much of the #13 which was 88% bread and lettuce. However, since then I have heard good things about Jersey Mike’s so I decided to try it again after all the years passed. Our order included the #6 #6 Roast Beef and Provolone ($10.45 - regular), a #13 - ($10.25 - regular) and a #13 - The Original Italian Provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni ($10.25 regular with extra meat $2.15 = $12.40). Note the Regular size is 8”. What I Liked: - The cheese and meat are sliced to order. There is something about this process that shouts-out, “my product tastes great”! - The extra meat option is a great value - They reduced the size of the roll which is a good thing. The larger roll, while adding unnecessary volume, masked the taste of the proteins. You can also reduce roll consumption by getting the extra meat rather than the Giant submarine (16”). - The #13 Original Italian was very good. The slices were thin, which I like, but not transparent thin which was my previous experience. - The #6 Roast Beef was a solid performer. In the past the roast beef was roasted in-house and it tasted the same this time so I assume they still do it on premise. A winner for sure in flavor and not over salted. What I Did Not Like: - They forgot to put the “the juice” on one sandwich I have to say this visit took my previous submerged review of Jersey Mike’s and see it as they used to say, it’s a Sub Above (the competition).“
“This place is very good. Both regular employees (the lady and the guy) always make the subs really well with ample fillings. With everything going up in prices, this is still one place worth the extra amount. The lady specially is good with customer service. The owner should feel very thankful to have them both working and serving in these crazy times.“
“Hidden in plain sight. There's no way you'd think a random small deli in a strip mall would make sandwiches this good. You'd be thinking wrong. The epic sandwich board has a ton of options, each one sounds better than the next. The Turkey BLT and Cranberry Walnut chicken sandwiches were both great. It's not what I would call a romantic cozy spot, but that's not what I'm looking for in a sandwich deli. I'm looking forward to coming back and trying more. I can only imagine how popular they could be in a more prominent location.“
“My first time getting food here and it was rockin! I found them on grub hub. I'm always looking for a good chicken cutlet sandwich, and they deliver here ( had a #10). They don't skimp on the sandwich, use fresh ingredients, and the bread was soft and delicious. The fries were also top tier. I'll definitely be back, found my new spot for sandwiches. Only thing I would prob change was to use balsamic glaze instead of vinaigrette, but the sandwich was so good I didn't care.“
“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️I recently visited Jersey Mike's and had an outstanding experience! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by the staff, especially Matt, who went above and beyond to ensure I had a fantastic meal. The sandwiches were fresh, delicious, and made exactly to my liking. The atmosphere was clean and inviting, and the service was prompt and friendly. I'll definitely be returning, thanks to Matt and the entire team at Jersey Mike's for providing top-notch service and scrumptious sandwiches!“
“The food here is sooo delicious!! Tried it tonight with my husband and we highly recommend it. The sandwich bread is perfect (usually my husband is super picky about that) and they’re super generous with the portions. We got the Oreo milkshake too and omg it was so yummy. Try it!! 10/10. The staff was also extremely friendly and helpful.“
“I am originally from Massachusetts, where we have great "subs". I looked for a place that would give me the "sub" I have been craving. Usually, I would have to wait until I went home for a visit. Sandwiches Unlimited is fresh and delicious, and they make it just the way you like it! The staff is always courteous and friendly. Make sure you stop in!“
“Our most frequented Jersey Mike's Subs. Located in between all our sports practice/game locations, this has become our go to for a quick meal. The staff here are friendly and they assemble sandwiches accurately and quickly. We order from the app a lot and every time our order is ready to pick up early. Tip: park in the back. The front parking is usually full.Parking: Lots of parking in the back. They have a back entry“
“Absolutely awesome little deli. I love the comic book decorations. They always have great music playing.House made smoked brisket is phenomenal. It makes it hard to try other sandwiches. I finally broke my trend and tried the Ranchero. It did not disappoint!Every sandwich is made with the utmost care and love. It's hard to explain, but it makes a difference.“
“They have the BEST salads and they give you A LOT for your money! The roast beef is SO FRESH! Best SANDWICHES ALSO.. If you're looking for a great SALAD and or sandwich! This is THE PLACE for sure !! Also, they come pretty quick ! Love it“
“I have been patronizing this Subway several times a week for the past six months.Constantly a good experienceThe staff is alway’s very friendly and easy to deal with.All of my orders are made accurately and promptlyThe vegetables and toppings are always very fresh… Which is important to meI often order a turkey club with no cheese and a lot of toppings….Red wine vinegar on the sideThis is not only very healthy but very good if you are watching your weight.“
“Rode the train to Denville. Stopped in for a quick bagel. Had a plain bagel with a Chive/Bacon cream cheese. The bagel was flavorful, with a nice texture. It was served hot & fresh. The service was quick, and friendly. I sat there to eat in a relaxing atmosphere. It was my first time there, but I definitely will return again.Parking: Strip mall parking. Plenty of spaces.Wheelchair accessibility: The entrance to the business would be fine for a wheelchair to navigate.“
“It’s not often I leave reviews but I left this place today feeling very taken care of by the staff. From start to finish everyone was very nice, patient, friendly, and outgoing. Even through the busy rush staff stayed calm while maintaining amazing customer service. Every jersey mikes location has great food but the service here was top tier. Will be back because of it!“
“My coworker suggested this place for lunch as he used to visit the previous owners a lot. The food is incredible! I got the chicken salad sandwich highly recommended. For the price you cannot beat it. They load the sandwich up! Will definitely be back “
“The guys who work here are the best of the best. Friendly staff, great service and should an order ever get messed up....they always make good on it. Jersey Mike's is undoubtedly one of the best and most consistent sandwich places in existence, and this store is definitely the best one I've been to. Keep up the great work gang!“
“Best little hometown deli! If you need a quick breakfast sandwich lunch or snack this is the place to stop in while getting your gas tank filled at the BP next door! Can’t beat their prices for the quality and portion of food you receive. They are very friendly when you walk in and always remember you when you return! They’re a small mom and pop deli that should most definitely be patroned. A favorite of ours is the bacon egg and cheese sandwich for breakfast. School kids also love this deli as they all stop in after school for a mid afternoon snack and sometimes morning breakfast. A fantastic on the go breakfast/lunch/snack/coffee/drink to go! Play the lottery here too!“
“Came in to grab a birthday cake and the woman behind the bakery counter was super helpful, kind and knowledgeable about their selections. She came to the front of the counter to help and explain the flavors of each type of cake and had great handwriting for the additional "happy birthday" lettering.“
“Sam's Bagels is a hidden gem that I stumbled upon. The variety of bagels they offer is impressive, and every single one I've tried has been nothing short of delicious. Whether you prefer classic flavors or more unique combinations, Sam's Bagels has something to satisfy every palate.What truly sets this place apart is the warm and welcoming atmosphere created by the staff and, of course, Sam himself. The team is always friendly, ready to greet you with a smile, and they genuinely care about making your experience enjoyable.As for Sam, he is a true bagel connoisseur and takes pride in his craft. He's often seen engaging with customers, ensuring that everyone is happy with their orders. It's evident that he puts his heart into each bagel, and that passion shines through in the taste.I love visiting Sam's Bagels not just for the incredible bagels but also for the sense of community that they foster. It's a place where you can relax, savor your bagel, and chat with other patrons as if you're all old friends.If you're a bagel lover like me and appreciate great service, I can't recommend Sam's Bagels enough. The combination of outstanding bagels and the warmth of the staff, especially Sam, makes it a must-visit spot for anyone looking to start their day with a smile.“
“The food was very good. Sloppy joes are absolutely phenomenal. Ruben was amazing. Subs were completely on par. The rye used for the sloppy joes and Reubens was soft and flavorful and not overbearing. The sub rolls were quite soft which made for a pleasant surprise. Personally I don't like rolls that are too hard or crusty that obliterate the roof of your mouth. The bread here is exceptional.Owners were so pleasant and thoughtful. Catered to my many requests because I wanted to try a little bit of everything. They make mini sandwiches here as well so it makes it easy to sample a lot. Despite living in the area for longer than the 42 years that this shop has existed in its current location, this was my first time visiting.I would strongly recommend this place. The sloppy joes are without fail the best I have had. The atmosphere is that of a little sub shop on any main Street in Jersey and is appealing in that regard. Once again, the owners and the food is the draw here and I will make this a regular stop!“