50 Best Sandwich Shops near West Orange

“I was trying to place an order online for catering for a birthday, and was having trouble with the website. I called the store, spoke to Amy who was lovely. Super kind, friendly, and professional. When I picked up the order Matt & Eric assisted me and were super kind. Thank you to the amazing staff here, we had a great experience :) - The staff at OMA“

“Staff was bubbly and friendly. They made my hoagie just right and wrapped it very nicely!! Will definitely go back!!“

“Staff is terrific and the food is great for a franchise. Purchased from this location for years and worked at one for a decade. This locale's owners does a great job in upkeep and consistency. Bread is nearly always the same quality and baked the same. (Which I love when I order herb and cheese) not wheelchair accessible for the record.“

“Roast beef and cheese sub is excellent .we order at least once a week .“

“Everything on the menu is delicious! The service is fast and staff is amazing. My children love their empanadas! It’s cozy, welcoming and relaxing ambiance…“

“My goal is to eat every sandwich on the menu, and so far, I'm now nine incredible sandwiches in. Each and every single one has been amazing in their own ways. The quality, service, and uniqueness is unmatched and greatly appreciated and I'll continue to go there often. Thank you Dutch's!“

“Stopped in 90min before closing, around 5pm. First off, everything on the menu sounded really good and my wife were kind of torn... The owner literally immediately engaged us and was like "tell me what you're feelin?" - this gentleman steered us to sandwich paradise ?

We decided to split a large classic Italian sub with a couple changes and ended up with a 12" sub (but I'd bet someone it was more like 14") with ham, salami, pepperoni, and provolone. Added lettuce/tom/oil/vinegar/mayo with salt n pepper and some oregano. The cost was $17.05 ($8.50 all in with tax each if splitting) and this bad boy was plenty for the two of us!

They *only* use Boars Head meats/cheeses and let me tell you, it absolutely SHOWED!! High quality ingredients result in a high quality product and this was no exception! It was the absolute best f***ing sandwich either of us have had in a long time! This guy was a true artisan and master of his craft!

Stop in and get an Italian sub and I promise that not only will you not be disappointed but you'll be amazed and enjoy the best sandwich you've had in recent memory!

We plan on going back again real soon to try the Philly cheese steak, get another Italian sub and try the Mac salad which also looked amazing. Will update this review or post another one when we do!

EDIT: Went back the following morning and got a Taylor ham egg and cheese sandwich. ????

EDIT 2: Went back for the 3rd day in a row, SHOCKER dudes cheese steak is also ?

EDIT 3: 11/1/2024 - New special on Friday called " Philly Cheesesteak Fridays" - $5 for a cheesesteak and $7.50 for cheesesteak with fries and a soda! Just picked up 2 of them for me and the Mrs.! Guess what? AWESOME AS USUAL AND LIKE EVERYTHING ELSE!“

“Wonderful establishment and excellent customer service from Team Member Shaheen… Very clean and you get your order as fast as you order it. Most fast food workers don’t notice that they are providing positive experiences with polite customer service but this one always makes my day. I’ve been going to this subway for a while now and it’s one of the good ones!“

“Good Luck Harry! Store is bright & clean. Harry is a real nice guy. Very respectful, & down right honest. He takes pride in his business!“

“Everything they make is amazing. The sandwiches are bountiful. Fresh ingredients. My fav place“

“Holy crap the sandwich was good it was bursting with flavor and everything in between. The guy helping me gave me 70 free bags of chips and free cookies, of course. My life has been changed forever. The sandwich was so good, for a second I thought my dad returned.“

“Excellent sub being the best prices in the area.“

“The Business and Leadership Academy recently ordered catering from Jersey Mike’s in West Caldwell. Our order was personally delivered by Mr. Gartland, General Manager. The students were able to meet him and learn about Jersey Mike’s. The “Lunch Boxes” were delicious. The quality of the sandwiches was SUBperb! The catering was well thought out and everything that we needed was included.“

“Our order was ready and waiting with everything we asked for and needed. The subs were delicious all around, with a good balance of meat / cheese / bread / toppings. We liked having all the options for online orders. Parking was easy and service was friendly.“

“Quite the oddity...and I'm here for it! Cruising Google maps for lunch the other day and came across this place. Don't be fooled by the pictures: yes, indeed there are guys grilling sandwiches in a shed parked in a landscapers driveway. But the food lives up to the high rating, and I'm glad I stopped by. I got the KC BBQ and it was lovely, produced quickly, with plenty of meat. There are tables in the corner of the lot and plenty of parking. Only thing I would add would be more umbrellas so you don't get stuck sitting in the sun. Thanks.“

“If you miss this place, then you are missing out on life! By far the best Italian sub shop, I've ever had the experience to try. Their subs are slammin!!! Highly recommended and such wonderful staff too!! It's definitely a must go to, and now my favorite sub shop around!!“

“Truly the best Eggplant sandwich I have ever had. SO tasty and SO filling.“

“Super service and delicious food. We are lucky to have you in our neighborhood and Westfield! The picnic tables are even better especially when the weather is so nice. Gracias! 5 stars!“

“Every single thing is delicious. Honestly, Agamie never disappoints. The food is super fresh & the service is exceptional. The staff was so nice to my 6 year old too.“

“Wonderful job catering my daughter’s engagement party yesterday. Food was delicious, delivery was awesome! Thank you so much, everyone enjoyed.“

“Amazing experience, very nice people and place.

Dietary restrictions: There are óptions for everything

Parking: Perfect parking

Kid-friendliness: Very welcoming and kind.

Wheelchair accessibility: there is a ramp in the entrance of the store and plenty of space“

“Everything they make is amazing. The sandwiches are bountiful. Fresh ingredients. My fav place“

“First time eating this sandwich. The choose was the italian. The taste was good, rich with protein, but was not cooked due to a closed grill when i was there.The place is very old fashioned and like other places like subway.If you like and sandwich in a bun with a loy of condimented meat, you will love it.The quality is the high point and the quantity. They really matter to have an giant sandwich.The price, for me is above than other for the experience and quality.“

“Tony Boys has amazing sandwiches but also generous and kind owners who give back to the community and schools. Their salads are good too but their hot sandwiches are phenomenal!“

“They knew who I was as soon as I walked in. They got the order right. The young gentleman that put my subs together gave me extra napkins, menus, and plastic. He was just so friendly and kind. The sandwiches were huge! We had to save one for the next day.

Parking: Parking is right there..you can pull right up to the door..there was no congestion..easy in and out.“

“the sandwiches are phenomenal!! we ordered and picked up for dinner last night and i'm still dreaming of the sandwich i had!“

“I would bring a bus group from the Detroit area every year before the pandemic for tours in the New York area.
I would have to order 56 sandwiches with 3 to 4 different choices.
Our bus wouldn't arrive to our hotel until after 8:00 pm
(after your normal business hours)
Upon our arrival, someone would deliver our lunches that evening for the next day.
I have always appreciated the extra mile that they went for our bus group.
The sandwiches were always delicious.
I look forward to doing business with you in the near future“

“My best friend of over 30 years introduced me to this spot. She passed away in Dec. Of 2022 But I continue to go to Montclair DeliIt's become my favorite place to eat. Their food is amazingly delicious and the service is great. They make you feel like family.“

“Great place owner is pretty cool . I had a reuben and a Italian sandwich. The Italian sandwich was my favorite more than the reuben very fresh. Parking is very hard to find I would recommend calling in advance and placing an order. For two Reuben’s and a Italian sandwich came to $39. I would definitely say give it a try!“

“This store is my go-to after a day of driving and shopping. It is on my way home. I always look forward to seeing the workers with their smiles and pleasantness. Prices are reasonable and the store is clean. Plenty of seating. There is a large parking lot, but sometimes I'm not able to get a spot near the store and have to go to another part of the strip mall. Great location for this store and has been there for a long time.“

“the hour n something minute trip is well worth it! I got myself a pizza bag to keep my food hot for the trip home! I'll make a few calls for orders for friends on my way home! The whole ensemble is perfect! nice n juicy peppers, onions and enough potatoes for that little side snack, a little extra grease to make the bread just right, not dry and dogs cooked to perfection! when you make the trip be sure to call friends to take their order! you know they're homesick and sure could use a great memory!“

“BEST FOOD AROUND! A++++++“

“This review is a bit overdue, but &grain is the best! We had placed a catering order for our store last week and it was one of the best decisions we could have made. We wanted to do a staff lunch for ourselves, but weren't entirely sure what the best approach would be, so I spoke with John and he suggested a few items that were their most popular, which made it so easy.We got the Chipotle Chicken sandwich, Ham & Brie sandwich, Prime Rib sandwich, and the ABLT sandwich-- all of which were incredible. We also ordered an Apple Salad that was otherworldly. The blend of flavors and textures was sublime and we made short work of it.The star of the show, however, was the crookie. Half chocolate chip cookie, half croissant= all delicious. I don't think I can adequately put into words how incredibly tasty it was, especially when heated a bit.Looking for a biz lunch that will satisfy? Look no further than &grain.“

“I only go very little, unfortunately, I have afractured back and use a wheelchair. The guy at thecheckout counter always opens the door for me, they are all very polite &helpful. Definitely one of the only real sub shops left with good fresh“

“It's Blimpie's! The BB still a classic NJ favorite that I'll take over any Subway sub. I tried a few others as well. It's always slamming. I also recommend the Hoboken. So glad there's still one Blimpie's near my house.“

“The owner wears this huge, welcoming smile. The establishment is clean. The customer service is 5-star. The food is flavor packed and tastes like it's made with LOVE. I past on all fast food burger spots for fresh cut potatoes here at “

“I moved into the area recently and have gone to this location multiple times over the last year two years. Honestly, I’m not sure what it is, not sure who is doing what, but everybody who works behind the counter are some of the friendliest people in food service I’ve ever met! They are genuinely sweet people. Seriously, when you go in there, just strike up a little light conversation. They’re so nice! A pleasure! Every single one I’ve ever encountered behind the counter! Good job!! ☺️“

“Always a great experience at this location, staff are friendly. And I'm in and out quickly. The bathrooms are clean, and there's always good parking. We stop by on our drive from Brooklyn to Pennsylvania and this spot is really conveniently located off of i280. The only friendly suggestion I'd provide for the helpful staff and management is the more junior staff should always ask if someone wants anything else after asking if you want it mikes way (yes I do, and then I want mayo and such). Otherwise, incredible place.

Vegetarian options: Veggie sub“

“Great food, nice selection and daily specials. Nice place, nice people!!!“

“First time here. Great experience. We got there right at 5 pm when they opened on a Saturday. Got table right away. 20 mins later place was packed with long wait. Wait staff was awesome. Annette stopped by our table numerous times and was fun to talk too and welcoming. Shrimp beeps were our favorite. Eggplant was awesome. Garlic pasta and savoy chicken were so tasty. Could not have been more pleased. Great prices too. Old school atmosphere that is fun to experience. But it’s not a place you can linger, you eat and go. Highly recommend for good simple Italian food.“

“Staff is great, it gets busy, I highly suggest ordering ahead. Food is definitely worth the money the salads are filling the sandwiches will out you to sleep. Straight food coma for my household afterwards. Desserts are good and not overly sweet.“

“Best sandwiches ever! I love both the Standard and the Kim. Great curly fries! And, nicest, most civic-minded owners I've met.“

“One of my favorite places to order better than Blimpie sandwiches, Roberto’s, nice and clean. The owner is the worker and the greatest sandwich maker ever I don’t say this about most places but if you’re looking for a great and tasty sandwich, this is the place to go.“

“By FAR the best place to get a sub. Freshly sliced cold cuts, awesome service, and one of the friendliest places around !!“

“Best place ever!!! Customer service is great, the food was delicious and the environment is very well kept. I recommend the vegan panini, peanut butter chocolate energy ball and the chicken empanadas. Thank you for an awesome lunch!!!“

“for is excellent and they also make ecuadorian food also“

“Muy buen servicio y el desayuno muy bueno ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“My weekly, pre-golf Sunday morning coffee and lox spot. We absolutely love everything about this place. Great flagels, fresh coffee, great prices. I heard a fellow customer recently questioning the price of the cream cheese, but I confirmed the cream cheese price has not increased.“

“Modest, sub shack with on-street parking near busy intersection of Clifton. This spot is a hidden gem serving up delicious, fresh, thinly sliced cold cuts and hot hero sandwiches for the locals. The shop is small, and no real dining area, but they put the attention where it belongs--on the subs! The rolls they use are soft and chewy. Onions are shaved, lettuce Shredded, nice size tomato, oil vinegar, and seasonings. Boom! It's perfection. And I don't know what I appreciate more, the smiling service the 2 guys serve up with the food or the outrageously reasonable pricing, but seriously guys, go out and support this little shop 2 doors down from Mr. Cupcake. You won't be disappointed, just thank me later.“