28 Best Bakeries near Butler

“Beautiful custom cookies for an engagement party! Everyone loved them and SO DELICIOUS! Definitely ordering cookies for the bridal shower next year!! 5 stars!“

“I used to come here all the time in college, circa '98, '99. I haven't been there in quite a few years, but decided to stop with my son the other day. I ordered a Taylor Ham and cheese on a toasted plain bagel and he had a plain bagel with cream cheese. It was the best I've had in years!! Now my son is asking me everyday to take a ride up there. Glad to see the quality remains the same! We'll be back........frequently! The Howard Stern on an Everything Bagel was my go to in college. I'm sure it's still amazing.“

“Love, Love, Love Magpie Bakery! Should have posted this a couple of weeks ago to let everyone know what an absolutely beautiful job they did with the delicious Woodland Creatures 1/2 sheet cake for my daughter’s baby shower! Wow! It was so moist and tasty, received so many compliments from the ladies. And you know we ladies love our cakes! The decorator created an over-the-top adorable woodland creatures design. Even the gluten free cupcakes were tasty and gorgeous. Kudos to the entire staff and owner. Everyone was so helpful and lovely. Would highly recommend this bakery when you want the best! Thank you to everyone there.“

“I ordered a 70th birthday cake for my mom and it was amazing. The cake was moist and very fresh. My mom said it made her whole day!“

“Just started ordering from Anthony & Sons all the way from Northeastern PA and couldn't be happier with the selection and fantastic service. Excited to incorporate their breads and rolls into our menu.“

“Pastry -5
Bakery -5
Food -5
Leonardo da Vinci's distant relative is creating fresh and delicious miracles
accompanied with great Italian coffee.
No need to get on a flight to Milano, right here in the Garden State.
Ciao“

“The best bagel and breakfast spot in the state! Their food is amazing and so is the service.“

“What a wonderful, wonderful place! I am so happy I found this gem in Boonton. The food was delicious! I especially loved the guava pastries and the chicken pastelitos, everything tasted homemade and fresh. Best of all, the staff is outstanding! So happy to have found this spot!“

“Have not had the pleasure of visiting this store in person but I’ve ordered from the dough palace twice and bought different flavors of the pro-dough. My boyfriend and I eat this and feel like everything in the world is going to go our way that’s how freaking delicious it is. It’s light and fluffy, sweet but not extremely sweet, and added protein in there gives it a great texture. I’m going to keep ordering from here over and over again!“

“I drive past hot bagel every day for the past couple of years and never knew it was there. Stopped in on Tuesday, got an everything bagel with olive cream cheese, and by far the best bagel I’ve ever had. Today I stopped and got a ham, egg and cheese, and again best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had. You now have a very happy new customer.“

“The best local ice cream & ice cream cakes!! They can customize your ice cream cake too. Friendly people!! We love going there with our family and friends!!🍦🎂“

“Every item I purchase at this bakery is sensational. I have bought cookies for little ones and adults, cakes for friends and family and everyone loves them. The staff is friendly and very helpful when deciding sizes of cakes and selections for various functions . You will always be satisfied as this bakery does it right! Debra Eckert -Casha“

“Hands down, the best in this area for edibles. Don’t even look anywhere else! Live this store and the slushy’s, off the charts good!“

“If you have not tried Nothing Bundt Cakes yet you have to. Have heard about them for months and finally tried today...OMG...worth it!!! Find the location nearest you and give taste...you will love!!! They even give instructions on the website for when to eat after purchase and how to store extra if not finished that day.“

“Honestly though. I don't like cookies or brownies or cupcakes a whole lot they have to be real good for me to actually want one. I make sure anytime I go near one of these that I grab as many sugar cookies as I can and I end up eating 6 that day lol no regrets.“

“OMG, Dominic is the Best so kind & helpful! His Gluten free line is amazing and different. From the Chic Pea Pasta that our daugther loves to the Rice Pasta to the Gluten free breadcrumbs yummy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The cookies & desserts are to die for! The bread is so tasty nothing like in the store. Our daugther was diagnosed with Celiac disease in Jan. We where besides ourselves trying ot find a fresh line of Pasta and bread products that she would not only love but accept. Bravo to Sogni Dolci for making the best Gluten free Products! Five stars from the FINN Family! BRAVO!!!!!!!“

“Just recently raised my review from 3 to 4 stars. The cookies and mini pastries are spectacular. Will have to work my way through the cakes next. Might up it to five stars. The macarons were a bit less crisp than my wife would have liked, but I blame that on the humidity and transport (I took too long enjoying the sunshine, nothing against the bakery), otherwise they were wonderful.“

“Omg ! Love Crumble cookies I am definately a fan.
Today I ordered and added my birthday cookie and never received my order. The doordash girl took the box of four cookies and handed my son my small birthday box.
I contacted the store and o.m.g the action to redeliver taken on this was fast and amazing!“

“This is one of my favorite food places. The bakery goods are fantastic. Bagels are made on premises and if you get lucky, you can get them fresh out of the oven.

Though not high end dining, this restaurant checks the boxes. Food is excellent. Staff is friendly and helpful. It is not fair to rate the atmosphere on the same plane as the other two. It’s not fancy but quite functional. Especially since it’s usually utilized as a take out place. Most of the time, I’m passing through. I phone in my order and pick it up shortly after. BTW, the tuna and chicken salads are to die for. Maybe the best I’ve ever had. The egg salad is no slouch either.“

“Such a lovely authentic Italian bakery! I got the bombolone and a cold brew, and everything was so light, fresh, and delicious. The bombolone was absolutely perfect, and the coffee paired with it so well. The staff was also really helpful and nice. Definitely a spot I’d come back to!“

“Love this place the food the service the atmosphere!“

“Undeniably the best bagels in town, and the muffins are amazing too. Just make sure to check your order before you leave. Something has been missing from mine about 80% of the time (usually the muffin, to be specific).

Also, the employee with the bright red buzz cut kept giving my toddler and me really uncomfortable, hostile looks. Whatever the reason, no customer, especially a kid, should be made to feel unwelcome. I won’t feel comfortable bringing my kids back while this person is working. I hope management can address it, because if it happens again, I’ll have to take it further and may stop coming altogether.“

“The best!“

“I love this bagel place. My family (my dad especially) has ordered here for years, since I was a child! I continue to go. Such a convenient location. The employees are so lovely! It gets busy, but it’s ok. I love the flavored coffee!!!! It’s great.“

“Best Crumb Buns and Meltaways.
Great local bakery, has a bit of everything, Love the crumb buns, by 2 dozen and ship to my family living in Florida, they love em. Meltaway Rings are huge and delicious. I buy them all the time, also bring to parties, and gatherings everyone loves em.“

“Nice and cozy atmosphere with good quality baked goods and coffee“

“Very friendly people also very good food and it's a good place to learn how to make bagels“