13 Best Italian Restaurants in Cape May

Iccara Italian Bistro Italian • $$
315 Ocean St #4, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti GF by Request
Pappardelle Della Nonna GF by Request
Homemade Mousse and Whipped Cream
Seafood Scampi GF by Request
Lobster and Squid Ink Pasta
Crab Bisque Market Price
Grilled Octopus Salad GF
Squid Ink Lobster Pasta
Sicilian Calamari
Caprese Salad GF

“Great authentic Italian food! Reasonable priced and great service. We will definitely be back!!“

4.3 Superb189 Reviews
Panico's Bistro Italian • $$
422 Broadway, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Bruschetta and Burrata Appetizers
Spicy Broccoli Rabe and Sausage
Tortellini and Italian Sausage
Fig and Goat Cheese Salad
Three Cheese Chicken
Rigatoni & Meatball
Bourbon Toffee Cake
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parm Strips
Ravioli & Meatball

“Tonight was our first time trying Panico’s. It will definitely not be our last. Everything was delicious. The staff was very friendly and helpful. If you are in Cape May you have to try it. You will not be disappointed.“

4.1 Good307 Reviews
Andrea Trattoria Italiana Italian • $$$
412 Bank St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Scallops with Spinach and Lemon Cream Sauce Appetizer
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Alla Carte Menu
Ziti Alla Vodka
Veal Valdostano
Squid as Food
Caesar Salad
Striped Bass
Scallop App
Bread BYOB

“Great food, great time, and great service! Shannon is an awesome hostess. Definitely will be coming back!“

4.1 Good107 Reviews
Tisha's Fine Dining American • $$
322 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Cape May Scallops with Risotto
New England Clam Chowder
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Cheeseburger and Fries
Cajun Fried Oysters
Seafood Pescatore
Mushroom Risotto
Scallops Risotto
Chicken Pasquale
Scallop Risotto

“The food is absolutely incredible! The service is top notch!“

4.5 Superb394 Reviews
A Ca Mia Ristorante/Bakery Italian • $$
524 Washington St Mall, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Baby New Zealand Rack of Lamb
Shrimp Scampi Romano
Linguine with Clams
5 Cheese Tortellini
Chicken Parmigiano
Ravioli Sampler
Veal Parmigiano
Caesar Salad
Bakery

“Our family has been coming to a ca mia annually for quite a few years, as this place was one of the few more upscale places willing to accomodate my kids when they were younger. (Note: my kids were relatively calm, stay in their seats, and were not interrupting anyone else’s dining experiences.)

Over the years we’ve had the same server often, how he manages to remember is impressive. Service here is always very attentive.

The chicken parm is one of my favorite offerings, other family members speak highly of the scampi. It’s an enjoyable reliably good meal in a great location.“

3.8 Good152 Reviews
Secondo Panicos Italian • $$$
991 Ocean Dr, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Crab and Avocado Bruschetta
Hot Bread with Olive Oil
Scallops and Pasta
Chicken Parmigiano
Oyster Selection
Battered Jersey
Sambuca Scallop
Whole Branzino
Eggplant Pesto
Crispy Salmon

“My daughter and I were really looking forward to having dinner there but were disappointed. Our reservation was handled poorly not to mention rudely. I indicated outdoor seating when I called, then also asked for outdoor seating when we arrived but were initially given an indoor table. I understand these things happen. But, the real disappointment was the lamb. One of the chops was so tough, my knife couldn't cut it nor could I chew it.“

3.8 Good244 Reviews
Blue Moon Pizza Pizza • $
425 Beach Ave #25, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Parm Pizza
Pepperoni Slice
Blue Moon Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Grilled Chicken
Slice of Pizza
Chef's Salad

“Excellent pizza! I have been in cape may a lot this is the best pizza I have found! My family’s go to for pizza!“

4.3 Superb148 Reviews
North Cape May Shopping Center Italian • $
3860 Bayshore Rd, Cape May

“New air conditioning makes this laundry mat much eiser to handle in the summer. Just got 2 new over sized washers to do extra large quilts or your animals bedding. Cheaper then any other laundry mats in area and staff is even friendlier then other laundry mats. I hate going to laundry mat but staff makes it more pleasant.“

4.5 Superb15 Reviews
Mario's Pizza And Italian Eatery Pizza • $
315 Ocean St Unit # 7, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Neapolitan Margherita Pizza
14 Nonnas Focaccia 8 Slices
Large Plain Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
Chicken Parm
lg Stromboli
Cheesesteak

“I ordered a veggie burger & sweet potato fries, pretty much my go-to at a pizza place. It was tasty but better than anywhere else because of the experience. I saw you give away food to someone in need, I saw you show compassion & kindness. I will support this business in the future! “On the way to Cape May” ❤️“

4.2 Good57 Reviews
Cappy's Seaside Pizza & Steaks Pizza • $
1432 Texas Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Little Mike's BBQ Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Freshly Made Cannoli
Pepperoni Pizza
Cappy's Wings
Italian Wrap
Chicken Parm
Cappy Fries
Pizza Steak

“Staying in Cape May for 5 weeks had my first cheese steak & I picked up a good one had it tonite ( 7/7/2025 being a Philly guy I know my steaks very good I highly recommend their sandwiches.“

4.1 Good23 Reviews
Cione Gelato Ice Cream Shop • $
315 Ocean St #10, Cape May

“Delicious gelato! It made me feel as if I were visiting Italy again!“

4.1 Good17 Reviews
Jojo Pizza Pizza • $$
507 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Margherita White Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Plain Pizza Slice
Verde White Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Cheese Fries
Pizza Steak
House Salad
Onion Rings

“PROs - lots of options , quality was good, good service
CONs- parking

Was in Washington street mall and was looking for a place for lunch - for kids and for us .. lucky to spot JOJOs pizza .. ?. Of course we thought it was just a pizzarea … but they had much more than that . Pizza was good. It was big and nicely done . Very good service . Was quick and we got food really fast .

They also had so many other things . We ordered felafel wrap .. and another veggie wrap. Felafel wrap was my favorite . Was really good. We also had milk shakes and drinks . Mostly good . Priced good . Not too expensive : parking is tough .. wanted to give 4 but they deserved 5 stars ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

3.9 Good54 Reviews
Italiano's Pizza Pizza • $
1 Gurney St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Gourmet Pizza Slice

“Great people! Very cooperative when my bank locked my card (for my security) and the woman with the beautiful eyes wanted to make sure my young daughter ate either way. Thank you for being so kind to us. The food was excellent. Wish I could leave 6 stars.“

3.1 Average22 Reviews

You May Also Like