13 Best Italian Restaurants in Cape May

“Excellent service from Athena. Really good food. Still BYOB but now have Meadowcroft wines. Very nice wine very reasonably priced.“

“My husband and I come to Cape May every year for our anniversary we have our favorite places that we love to visit this was our first visit to Pacino's bistro and we went back the night after to pick up again!!! The food was phenomenal and the wait staff were very hard working and friendly!!! I am server myself and this not an easy job but they were excellent. The ambiance in restaurant made the experience that much better. Cannot say enough good things about this establishment!“

“Great food, great time, and great service! Shannon is an awesome hostess. Definitely will be coming back!“

“Always go when in Cape May…fabulous food“

“First time rating here at this BYOB and was pleasantly suprised with the quality of the food. We had Tortellini Alfredo and Lasagna for our main courses and the were both outstanding. We ate outside since the weather was so nice.
We will go back and try different mains next time.
Very affordable, especilly since they are a BYOB.“

“My daughter and I were really looking forward to having dinner there but were disappointed. Our reservation was handled poorly not to mention rudely. I indicated outdoor seating when I called, then also asked for outdoor seating when we arrived but were initially given an indoor table. I understand these things happen. But, the real disappointment was the lamb. One of the chops was so tough, my knife couldn't cut it nor could I chew it.“

“Excellent pizza! I have been in cape may a lot this is the best pizza I have found! My family’s go to for pizza!“

“New air conditioning makes this laundry mat much eiser to handle in the summer. Just got 2 new over sized washers to do extra large quilts or your animals bedding. Cheaper then any other laundry mats in area and staff is even friendlier then other laundry mats. I hate going to laundry mat but staff makes it more pleasant.“

“I ordered a veggie burger & sweet potato fries, pretty much my go-to at a pizza place. It was tasty but better than anywhere else because of the experience. I saw you give away food to someone in need, I saw you show compassion & kindness. I will support this business in the future! “On the way to Cape May” ❤️“

“Delicious gelato! It made me feel as if I were visiting Italy again!“

“Staying in Cape May for 5 weeks had my first cheese steak & I picked up a good one had it tonite ( 7/7/2025 being a Philly guy I know my steaks very good I highly recommend their sandwiches.“

“Great people! Very cooperative when my bank locked my card (for my security) and the woman with the beautiful eyes wanted to make sure my young daughter ate either way. Thank you for being so kind to us. The food was excellent. Wish I could leave 6 stars.“

“Solid, well-balanced pizza with a slightly crispy, perfectly chewy crust—I actually found the crust was my favorite part, which says more about the dough than the toppings. We ordered a little before 5pm and it was ready in about 15 minutes. I also ordered buffalo wings just for a bit of variety, and while I appreciate they came un-sauced to keep them crispy, they were pretty basic pizza shop wings that came with a sad, warm packet of Ken's Blue Cheese dressing (I'm not sure where the extra side of blue cheese I paid .50 for ended up). All-in-all, not bad for being on the mall and within close walking distance.“