50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carteret

“I ordered garlic cheese bread and lamb cheese bread and chicken achari pizza and Mediterranean combo twist and everything was on point.only disappointment was they didn't have halal wings or at least not yet I was looking fwd for mango habanero wings .the guy said they coming soon.“

“I'm a pizza fanatic. I am from Ohio and have to travel to NJ for work now, my first trip to NJ tried Riunitis.

I kid you not, after having it one time I went back every single night until I flew home Friday morning. I'll admit I tried one other place on Uber eats due to laziness, and instead of eating my fresh new food I heated up a couple day old slices from this place.

I even tried to smuggle the red sauce back on the plain (got denied).

Idk what they put in that margarita red sauce, but I'm a customer for life. Fresh and great ingredients.

If you want to know my order, I always get the margarita pizza.“

“Lucia's pizza is by far the best pizza I have ever eaten. Everything is fresh, and cannot be duplicated. The taste is unbelievable and it is something you must try to know what pizza should taste like!!!“

“This place is awesome, Carteret is a very peaceful city this place provides distraction and fun for a while in the quietest city in all of New Jersey and I love that, I love my quiet city and some fun on a Friday night ♥️come to karaoke Thursdays ?☀️?“

“We ordered a grilled chicken ceaser salad along with our pizza. they must have stored the salad in the pizza warming bag, because the lettuce was cooked. when we complained that our salad was hot and soggy, they basically told us they didn't care. Sucks to be us.“

“Highly recommend their pizza, burgers, wings, chicken, gyro platters, gyro sauce, sandwiches, beef patties, and everything they make does not disappoint. GOD BLESS THEM ALL With abundant bounty in this world and eternally.“

“Highly recommend their pizza, burgers, wings, chicken, gyro platters, gyro sauce, sandwiches, beef patties, and everything they make does not disappoint. GOD BLESS THEM ALL With abundant bounty in this world and eternally.“

“I had the chicken parm entree and penne vodka. Both were exceptional. Also tried the calamari app and fries. The calamari is fresh and crispy. It’s hard to find good not chewy, rubbery calamari. The fries are very good as well. Crispy outside, and soft inside. Definitely will be back!“

“outstanding experience, hot and delicious food“

“Been coming to this spot since I was 3! I was a bit apprehensive when I heard they had switched owners, and would be offering more than just pizza and would no longer just be cash only. However, the quality and customer service has never changed, they are just as warm and welcoming as usual. As long as I’m an Elizabeth resident, I’ll never stop coming here! Period!“

“The pizza and dessert were delicious and the service was even better. Highly recommend visiting if you are in the area!“

“Usually pick up pizza to go never disappointed in the quality and service.“

“Best pizza on island“

“Went here all the time after school with my friends. All of us would order a slice and mama delio would come out with an extra slice and maybe some garlic knots. She always made sure we were fed even if we couldn’t afford it. Love this place, haven’t been in awhile.“

“I've eaten at this place probably a dozen times and their pies never disappoint, great classic New York style pizza, but the last visit the plain cheese pizza was kinda dry and bland, was very surprised
I will eat there again I expect someone just had a slack moment making that particular pie“

“Literally the BEST pizza we ever had!!! Sangria was absolutely DELICIOUS!!! Service was spot on!!! Will definitely be back and will definitely bring friends! Best of luck Kim and Dominic!!“

“Homemade pasta and wood fired pizza.“

“Not only a great place for lunch or dinner but also we had a repose luncheon there yesterday. 25 people and absolutely. everyone was extremely satisfied. I highly recommend it !!“

“I needed some real Italian food so I did my due diligence and came here! They did not disappoint! I ordered a chicken parm and 2 cheesesteaks. When I got home and opened both sandwiches immediately your hit with quality ingredients and the taste OMG! Both sandwiches hit the spot LITERALLY! NO HESITATION GO NOW IMMEDIATELY if you’re in the mood for good made to order fresh quality PIZZA, SANDWICHES AND PASTA!“

“Best Pizza in my own price segment preference, best than freshslice, papajohns, domino's. Friendly for student's pocket. must go place.“

“i just ordered from here and the gentleman scotty who answered and took my order was extremely kind and professional. the food has always been wonderful and the restaurant is brand new clean and has a great atmosphere that is felt even through the phone. thankyou again scotty my family appreciates knowing we can eat somewhere where people care.“

“One of the best pizza places on Staten Island . Food is always fresh and delicious .“

“I wanted thank Nola's for the delicious pizza and generous donation. Nola's went above and beyond to donate to Jonathan Dayton High School's Volleyball Dig pink fundraiser. We asked for a pizza donation and Nola's opened their doors on their day off to prepare pizzas for the event. Thank you Marc and staff for coming in on your day off to support such a great cause and group of girls.“

“Casa Ninos Delicious $10 Lunch Special and Excellent Serving By Sergio. Would definitely recommend“

“Some of the best pizza we’ve ever had, anywhere ! All the food at Italian Touch is delicious, but I have to say, the Buffalo Chicken Slice here is my absolute favorite. Pizza is amongst the best in Staten Island for sure. staff are quick and friendly without being intrusive. Highly recommended“

“I'd give them more than 5 stars if I could. My mom had my dad's 85th birthday party at Mimmo's . The owner, Domenico, was incredibly flexible to the different possibilities my mom was interested in. Day of the party, his son Ralph personally took care of the main table where my parents were. ALL the staff was wonderful and attentive. But my parents were treated with incredible respect. The food was amazing!!! Our family kept raving over how delicious everything was. Course after course, one dish after another, just delicious. And the Nutella zeppolis for dessert - WOW, simply decadent. * A small detail - when signing the contract, while I was excited about the Nutella zeppolis, my mom mentioned "eh, she could do without the Nutella". Ralph remembered that and put out trays half with and half without the Nutella. Made EVERYONE happy! Thank you for everything. We'll definitely be back.“

“Amazing! I just found my favorite pizza shop! If you’re looking for traditional jersey pie, you’re going to be disappointed.“

“Me and my co-workers have been coming here for a couple years, about once or twice a week. We've never had a bad meal, everything tastes fresh and delicious. Everything from their pasta dishes, pizza, freshly made salads and sandwiches are amazing. All of the food is fairly priced and its very convenient. These guys go above and beyond to satisfy their customers, keep up the amazing work.“

“Hands down ……Best Pizza in town. I been passing this pizzeria for at least 4 yrs on my way to work and I can say I was missing out on some good yummy ? food. Pizza ? is amazing. Pizza cooked to perfection. Today I had a Buffalo Chicken wrap and some pizza fries OMG it was delicious. Recommend this hidden gem ?. I wish I can give it more then a 10 stars ⭐️.“

“Food was awesome, service awesome, atmosphere great! Will be returning soon that’s for sure!“

“Great food and service. .we went with a group of 10 people and everyone enjoyed their food .we been back many times and even had them do a party for us :)“

“On a trip from Maryland, and stopped in for something sweet. You gotta try the Lemon/blueberry mini bundt cake! Wow! Great restaurant, great food, great guys! Extremely nice and great food. Highly recommend!“

“We're from Chesapeake, Virginia and just came from our 6 hour Liberty and Ellis Island tour. We missed to try the New york pizza in the city that we find a pizza house near our hotel....and we're very happy to find Pizza Paradise! Their beef pepperoni is sooo good!! Their service and warm accomodation was superb! Will surely come back! ?“

“Third time coming back to this spot. Oreo is a down to earth guy. Meanwhile I waited for my food I was chatting it up with him, made me feel so welcome to his shop plus the best part he has classic Nintendo systems all ready for you to play while you waited, brought me back memories. Overall experience great, food amazing (you got to try the chicken parm sub) and service great. Will be back“

“Pizza, Beers always cold, Service always amazing and no one does it better than Jimmy, does so much for community and i love giving back to Jimmy!! everyone is treated like family !!“

“I usually get the meat lovers pizza and I’m able to add extra things on it at no charge, which unlike other places is unusual

Kid-friendliness: My nephew declared that his cheesy pizza was the best cheesy pizza he’d ever had. This was his first time there as a kid on autism spectrum rated the best is high honors.

Wheelchair accessibility: While the doors are not automatic. I do believe that there is plenty of room for a wheelchair to navigate down the line.“

“what an amazing place. came to hear the Openers band the pizza was the best I have had in a long time. The owners were so involved and very nice. I live an hour away. I will be back.“

“Was in town last week and decided to give it a try…very happy I did! The pizza was great and the wings and garlic knots were just as good!“

“We are lucky in New Jersey to have some many great local pizza places, but Gennaro's is a step above most. Their pizza is extremely good, both as slices bought from the counter and as whole pies. It's really as good as pizza gets. In addition to pizza, their sandwiches and meals are great. Their cheesesteaks are excellent, as are chicken dishes, etc. I've never had anything less than an "A" experience at Gennaro's. If you want to take people from out of state to teach them what pizza is supposed to taste like, take them here.“

“Great location great service over phone and in person! The customer is always right ? so glad to be fully outside this year and I tell you people of hill side this is definitely a spot/ location to check out now later or in the very very very very near future! Tell them 5 five star Most sent ? you! Good vibes only ? take care see ya again soon !!“

“The food at Dolce is amazing. The problem is trying to pick a favorite. Penne Vodka, Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp or Shrimp Francese. All equally delicious. Dolce catered our school event last night and everything was perfect. The food was hot, Chicken Parm was so tender, Pasta was cooked perfectly. John and staff are always super friendly. We love Joyce! Highly recommend this restaurant.“

“I LOVE THIS PIZZA PLACE!! I LOVE THE PIZZA THE FOOD AND THE PEOPLE THAT WORK THERE!!! I HAD ASMALL PARTY AT MY HOUSE AND ORDERED 9 PIZZAS! ALL WERE DELIVERED HOT AND MY GUESTS LOVED THEM!! THIS IS THE ONLY PLACE TO ORDER PIZZA! IN THE WOODBRIDGE AREA!“

“It’s the best pizza ever sandwiches & Stromboli salads the pizza is very thin crust great flavor“

“Great grandma slice. Excellent decor friendly staff. Clean, well kept place next to a well known barbershop. Highly recommend this place“

“Best pizza and food around!! Stall is so very courteous“

“Wonderful service and excellent food!! Will definitely return!“

“Delicious food. Great service. Their pizza is excellent.“

“Consistently delicious food. Nothing ever disappoints. They cook the old fashioned way with no shortcuts or cheap ingredients. Highly recommend!“

“Excelente lugar para comer, con una excelente atenciaon a los comensales“