9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Rahway

“easily the best pizza in Rahway. Elizabeth Michelino is great too“

“I order pizza from here at least once a week and it never disappoints. The pizza is delicious, fresh, and not greasy, which I really appreciate. On top of that, the delivery guy is always so nice and friendly. Amazing food and great service!“

“Best pizza around for the thin crust lovers. Excellent vodka sauce and a great House Salad /dressing“

“Il Forno was a very pleasant surprise. The lunch specials exceeded my expectations. The food and the service was very good. I would recommend this restaurant to my friends.“

“I was very impressed by how clean and fast-paced the environment is, and I appreciated not having to wait long to receive my order. Additionally, the food was absolutely delicious and very affordable, which is especially appreciated during these times.

Thank you for providing such great food and excellent service.“

“I feel like this pizza place is a few things away from being really amazing but I'm not even sure they will review this email to improve which is kind of unfortunate. On this trip I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and the grandma pie. The buffalo chicken was good, the deep dish was half baked which I liked. The chicken was cooked just right and the crust was pillowy, flaky, and a good crunch on it. The cheeses you could tell were premium. I think what was missing from the pizza however was blue cheese and some sort of seasoning to make it pop. The buffalo was present, not too much heat, but one or both of the two aforementioned ingredients were missing to bring it over the top to make it great. The grandma pie on the other hand was thin crust and the seasoning was very apparent upon tasting more so than the buffalo. The olive oil, sauce, cheese, and garlic/parmesan on top set it apart as being really good. I liked the grandma pie and would recommend that to anyone. I do want to mention, I placed my order 30 minutes before arrival. After arriving, I noticed that the system being used to receive order was delayed so my order wasn't received until arrival. This was surprising because I just assumed by conversation but it wasn't explicitly stated to me. This brings me to my other point, communication is really important for customers. If something happened with my order it would be great to give the opportunity to inform the customer to let them know if they would still like to proceed with the order, provide their money back, or just acknowledge that something happened and offer a beverage or something or a slice from the shelf while they wait due to the delay. It's really the little things like that can really bring more business and transparency. I didn't mind it because I wasn't in a rush but others may not be. Communication I really think is key to keep customers. Just providing a suggestion and no harm intended. I just hope someone views this in time before it happens again.“

“Never heard of this place and didn’t know they were at their place. Got a slice and I’ll tell you I love thin pizza. This pizza was delicious. I would rate this pizza a 7.7. Great everyday pizza.“

“Nice little place. Whenever Im in Rahway passing thru I always stop.“

“Best wings south of Lake Placid. They are jumbo and reasonably priced. The Buffalo and honey barbecue are delicious.

Kid-friendliness: It is a very kid friendly restaurant.

Wheelchair accessibility: Restaurant is wheelchair accessible“