“The food is absolutely amazing! We literally just celebrated our mother's birthday in the banquet room. A party of 75 guests and I couldn't have asked for better service! Very attentive staff and very accommodating owners Brian is an absolute star!! Thanks to all the staff it was a wonderful experience.Vegetarian options: There are vegetarian options but you can ask them to alter a dish to make it meatless or with no cheese etc. They are wonderful and aim to please. I am very pleased with how they took care of the family of4 vegetarian / vegan“
“Drove up last week with my friend from Philly who makes pizza for a living. We were excited to finally be there since we have known about the spot for years, but when we got there, we were told we couldn't eat there and it was takeout only. That was news to us. We don't live in the area and had nowhere to eat takeout... There were a bunch of empty tables and no other customers, but were told that we couldn't eat there. It felt ridiculous to get this response and was a real bummer. Leaving 3 stars to be polite and not look like I'm just angry.Reply -We drove up to this location because I live closer to noth Jersey. We were going to an event nearby after, and anyway, we just wanted to go to the original spot! Im just saying I wish I knew we wouldn't be able to eat there. We would have just made different plans, OR we could have just sat down for 10 mins and ate at the empty table!! Maybe it's more complicated than that idk. I'll leave 4 stars as a gesture that I'm just being honest about my experience. Thank you.“
“While browsing the net for neighborhood pizza I came across Valentinos and decided to give it a try. My son was treating (finally) so we ordered a regular pie and one with bacon and pepperoni. They did not disappoint. The staff was friendly and the food was great. I enjoyed it so much that I went back the next day to buy a sicilian for my lady. Good job. I'll be a regular customer from now on.“
“The staff was friendly an the pizza was great! Unlike many other pizzas around this area, the crust was cracker-thin, and I really enjoye this. They also accepted my service animal without question. Overall, great experience and I would recommend people check Sun Tavern out.“
“Even if the restaurant looks a bit unusual from the outside right next to the laundromat: don't miss out on a visit! Super friendly, attentive service and absolutely delicious, freshly prepared food! Absolute recommendation! we'd love to come back! Thanks!“