Goodfella's

$$ • Pizza, Italian, Bars

Hours today·

Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM More

About Goodfella's

Goodfella's is a highly-recommended spot that consistently delights its customers. The restaurant is known for its perfect pies, including the vodka pie and the prosciutto, arugula, and truffle oil pie, which are a MUST try. The menu also offers a range of delicious dishes, such as fresh and flavorful food served in generous portions. The staff provides excellent service, making guests feel well-cared for. Many guests praise the casual and welcoming atmosphere and the friendly service that makes visits enjoyable. The restaurant offers great prices and value, with the Owner bringing an after dinner cordial like a gentleman. With its fresh and delicious food, friendly staff, and inviting ambiance, Goodfella's remains a top choice for a satisfying meal.

Menu

Add a Menu
Goodfella's Menu
Goodfella's Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Goodfella's
Goodfella's
View All Photos

Goodfella's Reviews

4.6
418 ratings
5
82%
4
3%
3
4%
2
2%
1
9%
Food
4.6
Atmosphere
4.6
Service
4.6

Share your opinion about Goodfella's

I have been coming here since I was a baby. Place has been cranking out perfect pies since the early 90s. My dad use to manage this place on the weekends back then. His partner in the NYPD started it with his brother. These two pies are a MUST try. They are the OG's of the vodka pie, often imitated but never duplicated. This prosciutto, arugula, and truffle oil pie is to die for. Don't skip one of the most slept on pizzerias on the island.
Love the new digs, a great dining experience... the food is as good as it ever was at Hylan and Seaview.
Their specialty pizzas are amazing, although expensive.

Read All Reviews(418)

Hours

Monday 11:30AM - 10PM
Tuesday 11:30AM - 10PM
Wednesday 11:30AM - 10PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 10PM
Friday 11:30AM - 11PM
Saturday 11:30AM - 11PM
Sunday 11:30AM - 10PM
Updated on:
Reserve a table