50 Best Sandwich Shops near Carteret

1 Subway

3.3 Good 73 Reviews

101 Roosevelt Avenue Apt A, Carteret

• Take-Out
• Delivery

2 Subway

3.2 Average 60 Reviews

1365 Roosevelt Avenue, Carteret

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I came to pickup a sub here at 5:40 pm on 10/19/24 and the service was astonishing. The worker was a guy with a beard and I haven’t been at any other fast food place with the same service he provided. He was very pleasant and cheerful. Food was great as well. Recommend.”

3 George's Union Subs

4.9 Superb 248 Reviews

641 Chestnut Street, Union · 7.9 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Stopped in Saturday for the first time. We had to incredibly good subs and Potato salad. The owner is very nice, the place is immaculate and we will definitely be back!”

4 The Sandwich Shop Staten Island

4.6 Superb 175 Reviews

61 Giffords Lane, Staten Island · 4.42 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The cheese steaks are amazing”

5 Anthony's Paninoteca

4.7 Superb 167 Reviews

3994 Amboy Road, Staten Island · 4.49 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Delicious authentic Italian food”

6 Quik Food Deli

5.0 Superb 79 Reviews

745 Poole Avenue, Hazlet · 10.14 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Simply the best subs, sandwiches and more. Everybody here is awesome. Wish I could give more than 5 Stars!”

7 Big Wally's Subs

4.8 Superb 107 Reviews

3322 Washington Rd, Parlin · 8.35 miles

• Take-Out

“Absolutely amazing and delicious better than any Jersey mikes or subway”

8 Mr Subs

4.4 Superb 325 Reviews

1831 Paterson Street, Rahway · 2.69 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I can not explain how good the sandwich is that I get. But the service from the staff is next level i travel from Linden to this store. They know me and treat me like family. Always friendly they go the extra mile. Know what I want. I can not express how good this place is. I recommend it to all my friends and family. Worth the trip and the quantity is top notch”

9 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.4 Superb 280 Reviews

899 B St Georges Avenue, Woodbridge · 3.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Good and fast service good food”

10 Mike's Giant Size Submarine Sandwiches

4.8 Superb 82 Reviews

103 W Front St, Keyport · 9.81 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“When you are 1000 of miles away and you still can taste the sandwich, it is good. When you return to visit, you make sure you have cash, and this is the first stop always. And maybe another before you leave.”

11 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.6 Superb 109 Reviews

1491 Forest Avenue, Staten Island · 5.83 miles

• Delivery

“the food was amazing as always but the cashier kept loudly talking about how his job is boring, that there’s nobody to serve and i know how annoying food service is from experience but it made me uncomfortable to hear him complaining so vocally about it while serving us, like at least wait till we’re gone dude 😭”

12 Northside Kitchen Tex Mex

4.7 Superb 85 Reviews

760 Prospect St, Westfield · 8.98 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Super service and delicious food. We are lucky to have you in our neighborhood and Westfield! The picnic tables are even better especially when the weather is so nice. Gracias! 5 stars!”

13 Mr. Sub of Union

4.5 Superb 138 Reviews

406 Chestnut Street, Union · 7.45 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent sub being the best prices in the area.”

14 Sub Stop Delicatessen

4.5 Superb 109 Reviews

913 North Wood Avenue, Roselle · 5.25 miles

• Take-Out

“Quick fast and order is correct every time even with phone orders 40.00 to 50.00 for2 whole subs 1 tuna and 1 blt but u won't go hungry it was so big I was full after a half of it everything tasted really fresh. I've come many times here nice polite”

15 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.5 Superb 98 Reviews

311 NJ-35, Cliffwood · 9.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I stopped into the Cliffwood location yesterday, and it had been years since I’d been to Jersey Mike’s. The three guys working were all incredibly friendly, helpful, and had such great personalities. My friend and I actually left talking about how positive the whole experience was. The sandwiches were delicious, and the customer service really stood out. It’s refreshing to receive service like that these days. We’ll definitely be back!”

16 Filoncino Cafe - Eltingville

4.3 Superb 206 Reviews

4569 Amboy Road, Staten Island · 4.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They have amazing vegetarian and vegan options on both the food menu and within the bakery. Everything is so so so good!”

17 Harry's Deli

4.8 Superb 53 Reviews

238 Broadway, Bayonne · 7.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Good Luck Harry! Store is bright & clean. Harry is a real nice guy. Very respectful, & down right honest. He takes pride in his business!”

18 Subway

4.7 Superb 58 Reviews

1351 Forest Ave Forest L, Staten Island · 5.95 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“normally don’t write reviews for chain restaurants, but this subway in particular stands out because of the customer service they provide one employee stands out always he’s so friendly and even if im not in subway he makes it a point to say hi - so shout out to you niro”

20 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.2 Good 279 Reviews

901 Bayonne Crossing Way, Bayonne · 8.53 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just as good as a Blimpie...”

21 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.2 Good 272 Reviews

349 Lake Ave Suite115, Metuchen · 7.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just want to give a shout out to Michael Who let me come in before the store opened as a contractor to come in and get lunch because I forgot mine. I can’t thank him enough for making my Friday/morning for him to go out of the way and I want him to be recognised for that. THANK YOU MIKE for a great start to my weekend.”

22 Hawthorne Deli & Grill

4.4 Superb 102 Reviews

563 Hawthorne Avenue, Newark · 9.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First time here and new to the area. I had no wait time. Smoke turkey and provolone sub was perfection. Soft fresh roll and all the veggies and meat was freshly sliced. I asked for specific items and they made it exactly like I asked. Now the guy working that day can use some people skills (greet people, smile, saying thank you) but he did make an amazing hoagie. Someone just please tell him it’s ok to smile at paying customers 😁 The establishment has street parking, wide sidewalks and easy to see awning. Inside needs some cleaning, paint and new tiles. Nothing much to look more welcoming but the food is amazing, still. No inside dining or bathroom. Some seats while you wait. I also love the clear glass to see your sandwich being made. That’s so classic! Will be back because summer is definitely for nice chilled subs. They have hot food too!”

23 Subworks

4.7 Superb 53 Reviews

976 Inman Avenue Suite 3, Edison · 6.7 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love this place! It's an Edison favorite. I've been coming here for a few years and this place keeps that old school deli spirit alive while incorporating some modern twists. They serve traditional sandwiches and even have some Indian-infused sandwiches like the Chicken Tikka Cheesesteak, which is an absolute banger! I've referred my friends to this place, one of whom is from PA, and he loves coming here every time he comes to Edison. Jay, Parth and Raj always provide excellent customer service and treat you like family. You can never go wrong with a sub from Subworks. Make sure you support local businesses. Places like these add some joy to the community.”

24 American Melts

4.6 Superb 63 Reviews

515 Springfield Rd, Kenilworth · 8.33 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Fantastic little spot with amazing food. It's a great foodie spot, and who doesn't love a tasty grilled cheese! Very plentiful with vegetarian options. It's a very small spot in a parking lot next to a park with trails and a small pond. Gentlemen, listen up. On a nIce day, this is a perfect spot to bring your partner for a date. You'll thank me later 😉 Kid-friendliness: Park right next doot”

25 K&A SANDWICH CITY

4.7 Superb 52 Reviews

1805 Forest Avenue, Staten Island · 5.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love the turkey sandwichs at this place!! Also love the fact that this is one of the only places on the island that has Zabiha Halal turkey sandwich’s and they do not sell alcohol! Great deli for your daily needs!! 10/10 on the food, no notes!”

26 Ronnies on Forest

4.9 Superb 38 Reviews

432 Forest Avenue Suite 2640, Staten Island · 7.5 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“5 stars for the two 3-foot sandwiches: chicken parm and corned beef ; the Cole Slaw; and roasted vegetable Hero we ordered for March 5th Saint Patrick’s Parade Party we threw. Everyone asked where we got the sandwiches. Only crumbs were left on the platters at the end of the day.”

27 &grain

4.3 Superb 107 Reviews

700 North Avenue, Garwood · 7.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I recommend all sandwiches but my favorite one is the chicken Caesar ciabatta sandwich. A salad but sandwich style. It’s so good it’s a must get. Workers there are friendly. I come here often for the corn muffins there the best I’ve ever had.”

28 Subs & Co.

4.2 Good 167 Reviews

511 Avenel Street, Avenel · 3.35 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I tried a hot sub for the first time at Subs & Co and it was mouth watering. The bread was nice and fresh and the cheese pulls did not miss. The staff were really nice and i got my food in less then 10 minutes. I definitely recommend this place and i will be going back there.”

29 Stubby's Deli

4.5 Superb 61 Reviews

1135 Florence Avenue, Union Beach · 9.4 miles

• Delivery

“Getting a quick bite to eat for Breakfast.The usual sandwich of toasted hard roll, 2 fried eggs, jalapeno peppers with salt - pepper - ketchup.Spotted this bottle of hot sauce on Stubby's Condiment Shelf and since I like Hot Sauce gave it a try.It added a nice taste to the sandwich.”

30 Sub House 85

4.5 Superb 60 Reviews

85 East Cherry Street, Rahway · 3.16 miles

• Delivery

“10/10! Found this gem on DoorDash. The Fries are crispy and shoe string like love! The Mac salad is too fire it’s absolutely delicious. And my sub (I’m a plain Jane girly) just good old ham, cheese, s&p, mayo, o&v just how I like it definitely will be ordering from here again. Next on my list is the cheesesteak”

31 Harbor Eats

4.3 Superb 91 Reviews

1000 Richmond Terrace, Staten Island · 7.95 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Some of my visits to the Harbor may last most of a day and it's great to be able to grab something to eat/drink on the grounds. 🙂”

32 Ronnie's Sandwich Shoppe

4.5 Superb 51 Reviews

2300 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island · 6.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I just wanted to take a moment to thank you and let you know how wonderful everything was. We had 60 people at our senior gathering here in Brick, New Jersey, and the compliments kept coming all day—especially about the corned beef, cabbage and the soda bread. Everything was absolutely perfect, and we had more than enough food for all our guests. We truly appreciate your attention to detail and for checking in with us. It meant a lot. We spend quite a bit of time in Staten Island visiting our grandchildren, and you came highly recommended to us—but I can honestly say this was the best recommendation we’ve ever received. Worth the trip !! Coming from a family of butchers and caterers, that’s a very big compliment! Thank you again. We will absolutely be using you for future events. Warm regards, Anthony”

33 Sloppy subs

4.6 Superb 39 Reviews

116 N Wood Ave, Linden · 3.99 miles

• Delivery

“very polite good customer service and The Sloppy Sub was awesome definitely a spot i will be coming back 🥪”

34 Mike's Place

4.2 Good 82 Reviews

330 Monroe Avenue, Kenilworth · 8.07 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Exxxcellent food, including ample portion size, all for very reasonable cost!”

35 Subway

4.1 Good 87 Reviews

4348B Amboy Road, Staten Island · 4.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“5 stars! I come here all the time, and the staff knows me by name, which always makes the experience feel welcoming and personal. Everyone is so friendly, the service is consistently great, and the store is always clean. I think I need to go get another sub already!”

36 Just Subs

4.2 Good 55 Reviews

68 Main St, Woodbridge · 3.1 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I went to Just Subs to place an order for a gathering involving a large number of people. I had reviewed the menu and had come up with a figure of $300.00, which by my calculations would provide enough subs, salads and sides for all involved. Probably with some left over. Joe the owner and his employee Desire questioned me about the number of people I wished to serve, and at that point told me that I was ordering too much food! Upon Joe's advice, I ordered a menu which came to a final total of $215.00! Everything was delicious, and there was some left over, just as Joe supposed there would be. It was a nice, professional gesture on his part, and a good way to treat a customer.”

37 Dave and Charlie's

4.2 Good 51 Reviews

538 Broadway, Bayonne · 8.42 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Their tuna salad is excellent. Best Tuna Melt around.”

38 Tommy's Italian Sausage & Hot Dogs

4.1 Good 69 Reviews

900 2nd Ave, Elizabeth · 5.79 miles

• Take-Out

“the hour n something minute trip is well worth it! I got myself a pizza bag to keep my food hot for the trip home! I'll make a few calls for orders for friends on my way home! The whole ensemble is perfect! nice n juicy peppers, onions and enough potatoes for that little side snack, a little extra grease to make the bread just right, not dry and dogs cooked to perfection! when you make the trip be sure to call friends to take their order! you know they're homesick and sure could use a great memory!”

39 Subway

4.0 Good 111 Reviews

224 Elizabeth Avenue, Elizabeth · 5.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I been to subway alots of time first time i go to the online Elizabeth Ave and I ask for italian sub the 2 girls working there look at each other like what what is this guy talking about well finally my italian sub they whant it to put roast beef fist and last I go there again”

40 Hylan Deli

4.8 Superb 15 Reviews

6778 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island · 4.82 miles

• Delivery

“John and his family are amazing ❤️ his staff member John is also the best , very hard worker . Food is great and Deli is absolutely spotless . Honestly nothing to say bad or disappointing about this Deli . They also have a variety of snacks ,drinks that are gluten free allergy friendly for myself and my daughter that most large box stores don't even carry .”

41 Panino Rustico Staten Island

4.0 Good 79 Reviews

2110 Richmond Road, Staten Island · 6.11 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I was visiting friends in NY, and on the day of my return to FL, my girlfriend took me to Panino Rustico, where I met JACK, he was excellent and authentic New Yorker, with accent and all (adorable).. The menu choices are excellent, we had truffle fries, I had the P48 Panini (steak, mozzarella with peppers & onions) and to cap off as a desert, I had the Iced Nutella Latte... All were excellent. I love a Hot Panini and it was perfect, flavors were cheesy perfect. Even the ambiance was charming and the Service was impeccable. I truly cannot say enough. So when you go, say HI to Jack!! The address is 161-16 Cross Bay Blvd., Howard Beach, NY 11414”

42 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.9 Good 176 Reviews

505 North Broad Street, Elizabeth · 6.72 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Who’s ever idea It was to hire a bunch of Spanish ladies ready to work deserves a raise. I’ve been to this location more than once and everytime I go it’s always clean the ladies are very professional and attentive. Constantly move around working. Sandwiches are good as well.”

43 Panino Rustico of Huguenot Express

4.2 Good 32 Reviews

895 Huguenot Avenue, Staten Island · 3.63 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had delivered Breakfast panini and butternut squash soup. Both were hot and delicious and I ordered from them by accident. Still came to me hot. The breakfast panini is giving breakfast sandwiches run for its money. The soup was really nice too. Good consistency and taste”

44 Martin's Sandwich Shop

4.8 Superb 12 Reviews

1135 E Jersey St, Elizabeth · 6.09 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Come to this old fashioned place and you will have the best breakfast- home made style attended personally by the owner. Come and have great coffee and the best is…..the inexpensive price for a lot of food. Try the French toasts, omelettes, chicken parm over spaghetti. You will love it!!!!”

45 Blimpie

3.9 Good 123 Reviews

1178 Morris Avenue, Convenience Corner, Union · 7.53 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I went for dinner and decided to try the Wednesday special menu, and it was a total hit! Everything was fresh, perfectly cooked, and had that classic touch everyone loves. Very worth it for the price. We were taken care of by Tony, who provided us with truly special service from the very beginning”

46 Subway

3.9 Good 106 Reviews

1650 Richmond Avenue, Staten Island · 4.03 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This was my first time coming back to this particular Subway in years. I was very happy with my sandwiches. They were well made and were packaged securely. The person behind the counter was also very pleasant to me upon my arrival. I will be coming back to this Subway because of this positive experience today.”

47 Colleen's Kitchen & Catering

4.5 Superb 14 Reviews

115 S Broadway, South Amboy · 7.07 miles

“Not only is the food good, but the free psychological counseling Carol provides is absolutely priceless! I love this place.”

48 Charleys Cheesesteaks

3.9 Good 91 Reviews

2655 Richmond Ave FC15, Staten Island · 3.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The Charley’s Cheesesteak at the Staten Island Mall consistently provides everything you expect of the frequented chain, with excellent, prompt service,, alongside fresh, hot, and customized meals. I’ve eaten at this particular Charley’s dozens of times, and it’s truly consistent. Importantly, within the Charley’s app you have the ability to earn rewards and it doesn’t take long before you earn them. Sometimes before I order my food, I check if there are any rewards or offers available and very frequently there is. For example, a five dollar discount on a meal, or points toward components of a meal. An additional feature I like a lot about Charley’s Is that the food is served in paper and the restaurant chain uses little if no plastic in a meal, perhaps except for the lid on your soda or other drink but you can request to have no late period keeping the meal healthy and environmentally friendly all around. The line tends to go very fast and your food is served piping hot pretty quick”

49 Subway

3.9 Good 87 Reviews

527 Broadway, Bayonne · 8.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Bavly was amazing! Even though we walked in late & subway was closing in 20 mins the server was very helpful and polite. Subs are always great. The only subway I have been to where the employees are NOT acting as if they are doing a favour on you. Definitely will return! :)”

50 Four Boys Deli

4.0 Good 42 Reviews

14 W Grand St, Elizabeth · 6.19 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I was doing a job out of town and stopped in on a wimb. 100% recommend stopping in if you are in the area. Food is delicious service is fantastic.”