50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Colts Neck

“We had a catered affair from Prima Pizza at our VFW Post. Food was delicious. The fettuccine carbonara was so tasty. Eggplant rollatini was cooked to perfection. Definitely 5 Stars.“

“Amazing food, great portions and quality for price, friendly and personal able staff, quick service, clean and warm atmosphere. Highly recommend. Definitely make reservations“

“My mother and law happen to come across this family owned establishment when we came into town for a doctors appointment. The food was AMAZING. We literally ate every piece of the delectable meal that was cooked for us. Our waitress was a family member who was the kindest person. If we are ever in town again we will definitely be stopping in!“

“BRAVO 👏🏼 I had the balsamic chicken slice & the hot-honey Sicilian! 🔥
Both we're delicious! Fortunately, I had the hot-honey second because it is true to the name, and the flavor stood with me for about 30 minutes afterward.
The bread/crust is absolutely perfect here. It indicates they know what they're doing, and it separates them from other pizza restaurants.“

“I came here because I live close and because of all the glowing reviews. Not sure what the hype is about. The cheese looked fresh and pepperoni was good. The sauce was fairly plain. Rather typical tasting pizza. Also had the bread, which was ok. The menu is a bit sparse and not a lot of topping options.“

“Dined in multiple times already after ordering from their delicious pizza menu one night and absolutely loved it. Great food, great owner and staff. 100% Highly recommend 👌“

“Great food! Lunch portion had me stuffed! I'll be back again!“

“great pizza and welcoming“

“The food is amazing! We had a 4-day, outdoor event and ordered lunch delivery each day from Pies in Poets. Everyone loved the food! Christine helped us choose the variety of items; she was friendly, professional, and knowledgeable about their menu. Delivery was easy. We will be ordering again for our next event!“

“The hubby just brought home the most amazing pie, chicken vodka! It was thin and crispy with Great Vodka Sauce. Highly recommend!“

“Review from carmine the cheesesteak guy I'd give it a solid 9.5 out of 10 one of the best cheese steaks I have had in NJ also one of the biggest cheesesteaks you go to any other pizza place and order one this is gonna be double the size of that it's as big as your whole arm from the top of your shoulder down to the tips of your fingers stacked with meat and cheese it is the best cheese steak in the Howell/Jackson area“

“A must when in Monmouth County. Thin, pastry like crust that has the perfect crisp, antipasta chopped or not, New England clam chowder to rival Boston. It is always busy and filled with both regulars and Bennies, anyone who manages to find this hidden gem along the Route 35 bridge by Belmar, will keep coming back. If you're bold, take their t-shirt challenge and eat an XL Pie to go home with pride.“

“Passing by the area and came across this pizza place was a little sceptical about the place was pleasantly surprised. Ordered the chicken keema pizza and panner tikka and chicken 65 food and Limca( Indian soda) highly recommended with pizza. Everything was fresh and very flavorful definitely coming back here when I’m in the area.“

“Loved it! Best subs around. I'll be back for sure! Can't wait to try the pizza.“

“The pizza is better than the original Staten Island location. I go to Matawan from Staten Island just to get this delicious pizza.“

“Besides the awesome food they have the best service of anywhere. We often travel over an hour to go there.“

“Food very good, best grandma pizza“

“Had a awesome experience and the lasagna was good“

“Been going here for years. Delicious food. A Hazlet institution!!“

“That’s is amazing pizza,very delicious! Thank you guys!!!“

“Delicious pizza and delicious Philly cheese steaks!“

“Amazing food will go back“

“We love this place and order seriously like once a week! We have never had a bad meal! Staff is always nice on the phone or in person when picking up. Delivery time is always reasonable also.“

“This place is absolutely amazing! We came in here at almost 11 at night, and they were extremely polite and personable, not to mention the food was absolutely outstanding. If you're nearby, try it out. if you're not nearby, travel, the food is just that good

Parking: aren't a lot of spots, very small strip mall“

“Everyone is so nice and friendly in here. Love their pizza, penne vodka, chicken parm roll and chicken parm dinners have all been great!!“

“The food is outstanding! The owners are the warmest and kindest people! The restaurant is professional, serving high quality food and reasonably priced! Love me some Pat d’s! Shout out to the exceptional counter help!“

“As regulars at Trevi, we can't say enough about how accommodating the staff is! They always make us feel welcome and go above and beyond to ensure we have a great experience. Their penne vodka is out of this world, and the pizza is simply fantastic! Whether you’re dining in or ordering out, you won’t be disappointed. We highly recommend Trevi to everyone—it's a must-visit!“

“Everything at Anthony’s is fantastic, especially the owner. He literally makes each batch of soup fresh! His specialty pizzas are incredible. His donuts are sweet like his mom. It’s always a pleasure to give our business to him.“

“Best pizza and service!!! Amazing wings, salad, everything!!!“

“As a born-and-raised Brooklyn girl, I have pretty high standards for pizza. Naples Pizzeria exceeded my expectations and I met my new favorite pizza: the cheesesteak pizza! Yum! The chicken cutlet is amazing and the Chicken Fusaro hero has become a go-to for my son and my husband and my daughter loves the chicken vodka park hero. The indoor renovations are a great improvement and it’s nice to have the option to eat at the picnic tables outside, too. The staff is also super friendly making it a great experience!“

“Best pizza I've ever had! Lived in Manhaattan near all the 5 star rated spots and it blows them all away. And only $12 for a large pizza Mon-Wed. I sound like a ad but I'm not. Just a huge fan“

“fine dinning with a kick!!! great enviroment and staff!!“

“Food is delicious!! You can tell it’s made in house and fresh. Excellent customer service!“

“bacon chicken ranch every bit had meat best pizza I ever had“

“Had a Stromboli that was great ! Great service & the staff was great ! Looking forward to going to there new place in eatontown next to earth treasures !“

“Thank you for preparing the delicious food for our son's High School graduation party last Saturday. The food was fantastic and received many compliments!“

“Food is always excellent. When I left Brooklyn I didn’t think I would ever have pizza again. Thanks to Mangia I get pizza twice a week.“

“great selection - everything was delicious“

“The best of the best in Howell and surrounding areas. I’ve been coming here 10 years and monthly never a bad meal“

“Food is always so yummy here!“

“Great experience at Villa the other night. Food and service were very, very good. Owner Alberto and his wife were so gracious and hospitable. Great local spot. Going back soon. 🍕🍝“

“Amazing food and prices! We use mateos for our catering and Friday night dinners!! They never disappoint and have loved each dish more than the last. Highly recommend!!“

“A great little hidden gem. They are not trying to be something other than a great pizza place with excellent food. It's also refreshing how much care they put into their salads for those that don't want only pizza.
Knowing that they want to get it right the first time is terrific. Knowing that if something is wrong, they WILL make it right is amazing.

I can't wait to come back.“

“excelente comida muy recomendable“

“Detroit still pizza is really good, great customer service“

“We spent the day at Capelli Sports complex for a lacrosse showcase. At the end of the event we had a long drive ahead. We ordered 3 pizzas to take with us on our drive. Everyone was so accommodating and made sure our delicious pizza was ready as soon as we we heading out! Thankful for the wonderful folks that work there and the great pizza!“

“Delicious food & great staff. I actually have a problem. a new addiction. I'm seeking help. No really. Delicioussssss stuff. 😍“

“Great pizza! Time to get El Presidente there to do a review!“

“I come to Romeo's pizza atleast 4-5 times a week for not just the great Italian cuisine, but also because the owners, workers and cooks are hardworking and extremely well mannered. Everything I've ordered here over the years has been much better than any other place in the are! I highly recommend ! Old school pizzeria at it's finest!“

“I normally don't leave reviews. But holy I've never had wings like this the seasoning in them is so refreshing and just makes you want to go for another. The fries aswell are pretty good classic fries that you can't go wrong with. I don't have a picture of the pizza because my family ate all of it beforehand. With that being said the pizza has a nice crispy texture to it and im not normally a big fan of cheese but it was surprisingly good my only thing that I found ok was the sauce but that's just my preference you may like it. If you are worried about a bad atmosphere and service fear not the workers are great and always have a smile on their face the woman at the register was very nice. Overall excellent pizza spot“