9 Best Italian Restaurants in Hillsborough

AMA Pizza Pizza • $$
236 S Branch Rd, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Beer Battered Zucchini Blossom
Bruschetta Salumi & Formaggi
Bruschetta Con Pomodorini
Salsiceia E Funghi Pizza
Pesto Pizza with Ricotta
Tagliatelle Bolognese
Linguine Alle Vongole
Eggplant Parmigiana
Italian Cheesecake
Eggplant Meatballs

“After many friends telling how good AMA is I decided to grab a pie and meatball parm sub to give them a go. My words will not give their food justice but it is delicious. Napoletan done the right way. Not to mention the owner is beyond good people. Greeted me outside while I was waiting for them to open and then offered me an espresso while my food was being prepared. We will most certainly be back.“

4.5 Superb174 Reviews
Mama Fanti Italian Kitchen Italian • $$
434 US-206, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Mama Mia Eggplant Rollatini
Nonna Eggplant Parmigiano
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Parmigiana
Classic Tiramisu
Chicken Piccata
Grill Veal Chop
Calamari Fritti
Caesar Salad
Caprese Salad

“My third time here , tonight I had the lamb shank fantastic service is top notch it’s a small place so kind of tight but I’m planning on being a regular“

4.5 Superb126 Reviews
Joe's Pizza & Restaurant Pizza • $
856 US-206, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Brooklyn Pizza Thin Square Sicilian
Joe's Special White Pizza
Brooklyn Pizza Slice
Chicken Parmigiana
Large Plain Pizza
Penne Vodka Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Sicilian Pie Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“We had a group of 8 and we all had some really nice meals. We were in Princeton area for a horse show and we really enjoyed our time here. We will be back“

4.6 Superb68 Reviews
Caffe Piazza Italian • $$
649 US-206, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Zucchini Flowers and Fried Mozzarella
Calamari-Cozze Livornese
Chicken Caesar Salad
Meatball Parmigiana
Calamari Aromatico
Calamari Fritti
Gnocchi Liguria
Chocolate Cake
Stufato Special
Squid as Food

“We went in after 8 so they usually close for dine in after 8 but the owner was nice and we had our food outside but we will go again with reservations.

Vegetarian options: Owner let us know that he can make vegetarian meal in case we want it that way.“

4.4 Superb89 Reviews
Cafe Graziella Italian • $$
390 US-206 #8, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Broccoli Di Rape and Sausage
Rigatoni Amatriciana
Birthday Cake
Tiramisu
Caruso

“Thank you so much for making my daughters Sweet 16 so beautiful!! Everything was perfect! The staff was wonderful and very attentive. I highly recommend them if you need a place to have a party! Great food and service! Again, thank you for everything!!“

3.9 Good34 Reviews
Mariana's Pizzeria & Latin Grill Pizza • $
381 Triangle Rd, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Pizza by the Slice
Chicken Francaise
Alla Vodka
Steak Taco

“These guys are the absolute best“

4.6 Superb38 Reviews
Alfonso's Gourmet Pizza & Pasta Shop Italian • $
411 US-206, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Penne Vodka

“We used them to cater our food for our wedding, and when I say they were perfect, I mean it!! They were professional, easy to use, and delivered everything up for us (in terms of food) while the ceremony was going on. We just set up the racks and sternos beforehand, and they did the rest. I had many people tell us that it was the absolute BEST wedding food they've ever experienced. And the price was unbeatable. Tons of people pay over $200 a plate at their wedding, and we paid less than $15 and we still had left over food!! AND people said it was the best! My uncle doesn't eat penne vodka, but he said he had 3 plates bc it was so good. With the leftovers, we were able to donate it to a homeless shelter. You couldn't ask for a better cater for your wedding food!!“

3.4 Good43 Reviews
Lenny's Pizza and Pasta Pizza • $
378 S Branch Rd, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Thick Crust Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Fresh Mozzarella
Buffalo Chicken
Penne Bolognesa
Sicilian Pizza
Plain Cheese
Cheese Pizza
Cheesesteak
Sandwiches

“I've been popping into Lenny's for the better part of 10 years. The Hillsborough location has never let me down. They have a lot of interesting specialty slices at lunch time that I haven't seen other places (fajita chicken slice, honey mustard chicken).

Be wary of the Flemington location though, not nearly as good.“

4.1 Good64 Reviews
Angelo's Pizzeria Pizza • $
435 Amwell Rd, Hillsborough

Customers` Favorites

Ricotta & Mozzarella Calzone Small
Chicken Tenders
French Fries
Cheese Slice
Garlic Knots
Chicken Soup
Meatballs
Wings

“We noticed Angelo's when shopping nearby. The pizza was topnotch, and there was a steady stream of "regulars." The service was exceptional.

Dietary restrictions: Great gluten-free pizza. The staff was very knowledgeable about serving gluten-free pizza properly.

Kid-friendliness: Our granddaughter loved her slice and was treated to a lollipop for dessert!“

4.1 Good52 Reviews

Taste More Cuisines In Hillsborough

You May Also Like