11 Best Italian Restaurants in Hillsborough

“We had an absolutely incredible dining experience at Cafe Piazza! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with incredibly warm and welcoming service that set the tone for the entire evening.
The food was outstanding—everything tasted exceptionally fresh and bursting with flavor. We started with the burrata and cheese board, which was the perfect opening act. For our main courses, the Pasta alla Nonna and the pappardelle with shrimp and lump crab were both executed flawlessly. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients in every bite.
What made the night even more special was the owner, Antonio. He was incredibly personable and attentive, checking in on us throughout the night to ensure everything was perfect. That kind of genuine hospitality is rare and made us feel right at home.
If you are looking for phenomenal Italian food and top-notch service, this is it. We will definitely be back soon!“

“My third time here , tonight I had the lamb shank fantastic service is top notch it’s a small place so kind of tight but I’m planning on being a regular“

“We had a group of 8 and we all had some really nice meals. We were in Princeton area for a horse show and we really enjoyed our time here. We will be back“

“Thank you so much for making my daughters Sweet 16 so beautiful!! Everything was perfect! The staff was wonderful and very attentive. I highly recommend them if you need a place to have a party! Great food and service! Again, thank you for everything!!“

“After many friends telling how good AMA is I decided to grab a pie and meatball parm sub to give them a go. My words will not give their food justice but it is delicious. Napoletan done the right way. Not to mention the owner is beyond good people. Greeted me outside while I was waiting for them to open and then offered me an espresso while my food was being prepared. We will most certainly be back.“

“Pleasantly surprised at the tastiness of this half pepperoni pizza we picked up on a moment’s whim as we headed to visit a patient at a nearby rehab center. In fact, it was so delicious I wanted to cry as a pepperoni slice slid off the patient’s lap and hit the floor! We will be back! Give ‘em a try. You won’t be disappointed.“

“These guys are the absolute best“

“Ate in dining room for pizza and pasta. Pizza came out hot and fresh, fried calamari was very good and the chicken francaise was hot, tasty and plentiful. Great for a casual meal whether it’s pizza you crave or a pasta or meat dish. Service was good not overly friendly but they served as expected and checked in on us. Take out seems to be very popular here. Good for kids.“

“We noticed Angelo's when shopping nearby. The pizza was topnotch, and there was a steady stream of "regulars." The service was exceptional.

Dietary restrictions: Great gluten-free pizza. The staff was very knowledgeable about serving gluten-free pizza properly.

Kid-friendliness: Our granddaughter loved her slice and was treated to a lollipop for dessert!“

“This has become our go-to pizza/italian place. It’s not the closest pizza place to us, but it is worth the few minutes extra drive. Highly recommend the penne vodka, and their soups especially the cream of broccoli (and I’m not a broccoli fan)“

“Best pizza in Hillsborough!“