Home
NJ
Princeton
Italian Restaurants

13 Best Italian Restaurants in Princeton

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Italian Restaurants in Princeton.

Showing 13 of 13 restaurants

Italian · $$
1 Metro North

4.5 Superb 520 Reviews

378 Alexander Street, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Butterfish & Crab Meat Francaise
- Stuffed Shrimp Scampi
- Parmesan Truffle Fries
- Sesame Tuna Teriyaki
“We went to dine with this rag tag restaurant and the experience was awful. The waitress had no teeth and asked my son for his? At first we thought “hey maybe they are joking” then all of a sudden. They lady grabbed his front bicuspid. Needless to say - at that point we were concerned. Because we had a long day we were still hungry. So we stuck around. The next thing you know. The toothless individual brought another toothless friend and tried to get my tooth as well. At that point. We know. Time to get out of here. We were cooked. Unlike the food at this gross place.”
Menu Order
Italian · $
2 Pastiamo Pasta bar and Cafe’

4.3 Superb 133 Reviews

301 North Harrison Street, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Gnocchi with Pesto Sauce
- Rigatoni Gluten Free
- Spaghetti Ragu
- Broccoli Rabe
“Last night was our first time at Pastiamo's and our experience was fantastic from start to finish! The food was absolutely delicious -- Burrata, Gnocchi Pesto, Penne with Walnut Sauce and Rigatoni Ragu were especially everyone's favorites. The staff was polite, attentive, and so patient, even when we stayed past closing time. Thank you, Francesca and team for making our night so special. I highly recommend this restaurant, and our family will definitely be back!”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
3 Lucy's Kitchen and Market

4.3 Superb 119 Reviews

830 State Road Suite 3, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“Good job! It really tastes good, and the service attitude is also very good.”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
4 La Mezzaluna

4.1 Good 487 Reviews

25 Witherspoon Street, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Risotto Al Pesto with Chicken Wild Mushrooms Green Peas Grape Tomatoes and a Touch of Cream
- Molten Chocolate Cake Rendition w Black Cherry Gelato
- Seasonal Fruit Flambé' over House Made Gelato
- Hazelnut and Walnut Encrusted Rack of Lamb
“Great food! Excellent service.”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
5 Laurea

4.0 Good 268 Reviews

102 Carnegie Center Drive, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Multi-Grain Belgian Waffle
- Pan Seared Scallops
- Buffalo Mozzarella
- Antipasto Salad
“Great service, amazing cuisine!”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
6 Alfonso's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.5 Superb 174 Reviews

1225 State Road, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Spaghetti Carbonara and Vodka Rigatoni Slice
- Half Large Garden Veggie Pizza
- Large Penne Vodka Pizza
- Sicilian with the Works
“They are the very best around! Never miss. Great for catering too. Get a slice, get a sandwich, a pie or a dinner, it's always great. I love the owners!”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
7 Conte's Pizza

4.3 Superb 424 Reviews

339 Witherspoon Street, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Pepperoni Pizza and Plain Pizza
- Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza
- Large Pepperoni Pizza
- Anchovy and Onion Pie
“Contes pizza is one the best in the Mercer/Bucks county area. I give it a 8.99. Service was fantastic, the people are friendly and pleasant. I highly recommend going to Contes. I know we’re going back.”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
8 D'Angelo Italian Market

4.3 Superb 222 Reviews

35 Spring Street, Princeton
- Delivery
“This place is AMAZING!! We stumbled on it and went back multiple times for everything from pizza and sandwiches and black and white cookies and Italian desserts, to full dinner entrees of chicken and meatballs and gnocchi and penne and ravioli and fresh bread and salads! Don’t miss out on this place. Everything was absolutely delicious and freshly made daily. The customer service is unmatched too.”
Menu Order
Mediterranean · $$
9 Mediterra Restaurant & Taverna

4.2 Good 752 Reviews

29 Hulfish Street, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- NY Strip Steak Roasted Broccoli Roasted Garlic Whipped Potato Spanish Steak Sauce & Pebre
- Gnocchi with Pistachio Pesto
- Flourless Chocolate Cake
- Paella Clásica for Two
“Great friendly staff who make fantastic tasty mixed drinks and serve delicious food.”
Menu Order
Cafe · $$
10 Teresa's Pizza | Wine Bar

4.2 Good 433 Reviews

23 Palmer Square East, Princeton
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Flourless Chocolate Torte
- Mezze Rigatoni Balsamico
- Fresh Mozzarella Pizza
- Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina
“Food , service , ambiance was wonderful .”
Menu
Italian · $
11 Princeton Pizza Star

3.7 Good 211 Reviews

301 North Harrison Street Suite 19, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- Slice of Cheese Pizza
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
- Grilled Chicken
“Delicious Sicilian. The big, greasy slice of sweet sausage was good, too, but I wish I'd opted for a plain cheese to get a better sense of their style. Friendly staff. I overheard the cashier talking with another customer and apparently the place is under new management. With a Stewart's Root Beer plus a credit card fee, the total came to over $15. I went during lunch on 7/14/25 and it was only a little busy. #YouWannaPizzaMe?”
Menu Order
Pizza Delivery · $
12 Valentino's Pizzeria & Trattoria

3.9 Good 44 Reviews

110 Rockingham Row, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“They have the BEST fresh made Minestrone soup i've ever had. I judge other restaurants quality by comparing to Valentino's. It takes a moment to heat up....as they include more fresh vegetables at time of ordering. Unbelievable! Oh, and their salad bar I also find impressive.Can't comment on pizza.”
Menu Order
Bagel shop · $
13 The Bagel Nook

3.8 Good 242 Reviews

301 North Harrison Street, Princeton
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Everything Bagel and Cream Cheese
- Pork Roll & Egg Sandwich
- Cookie Monster Overload
- Cannoli Donut Overload
“Specifically sought out a local bagel shop while in town and chose this one based on the incredible and colorful options. It did not disappoint! Chatted with Greg and he was very patient and sweet- he took good care of us and we'll definitely come back when we're in town again. Bagels were chewy and flavorful- would definitely recommended! Thank you, Greg, and thank you, Bagel Nook!”
Menu Order