50 Best Italian Restaurants near Pennington

“Our food was delicious! Stuffed shrimp and veal with mushrooms in a frangelica cream sauce.“

“One of Pennington’s hidden gems! This adorable place may be located in a shopping center but don’t worry about that! The atmosphere is just perfect inside! The staff is friendly and inviting! Jen is amazing! The food is delicious and the drinks are just perfect! The spritzes are my favorite but there is something for everyone! Don’t miss out on the meat and cheese boards! They are a must try! Perfect for a date, girls outing or just an afternoon out! Can’t wait to go back!!!“

“Visiting from out of town and this restaurant was recommended to me. I ordered the chicken francese with linguine. It was divine. The chicken was so good it felt like it was melting in my mouth. I highly recommend this place to eat. Especially this dish.“

“Amazing Pizza and Pasta. I took my family there a while back and we've been going there ever since. Service is great and dessert is fabulous. Great for a gals night! Wine selection is top tier as well. Congrats to Mr.Procaccini and his team! Open a restaurant up near spring lake!“

“Just tried Marco's pizza for the first time and it was absolutely delicious! The crust was perfect, not too salty like some we've had in the area. The cheese was just right and I appreciated the sliced, rather than chopped, onions. We'll definitely be ordering from Marco's again! Thank you!“

“We eat there often and are never disappointed. The food is delicious and the service is very professional. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming. Additionally, I had a catered affair there for Chrismas Eve and it was wonderful. There were 19 people who are still raving about the food and service...which is so rewarding on a night that the restaurant was crowded with many groups celebrating.“

“I grew up in the area and this is my go to place when I am back in the area. I stop every single time.“

“Excellent“

“Wow! The food is excellent, the roasted peppers were amazing rivaling my wife’s and Mother’s! The fettuccine with spinach and shrimp was amazing. The taste of the spinach was amazing as if it was sautéed in garlic and oil before being added to the dish. I can’t say enough about this restaurant! Glad I finally found it!“

“Excellent food served with gracious hospitality. Definitely a night to be remembered!“

“We went to dine with this rag tag restaurant and the experience was awful. The waitress had no teeth and asked my son for his? At first we thought “hey maybe they are joking” then all of a sudden. They lady grabbed his front bicuspid. Needless to say - at that point we were concerned. Because we had a long day we were still hungry. So we stuck around. The next thing you know. The toothless individual brought another toothless friend and tried to get my tooth as well. At that point. We know. Time to get out of here. We were cooked. Unlike the food at this gross place.“

“We always enjoy our meal when dining at Tre Fratelli and the staff has always gone above and beyond for several group dinners I’ve either attended or organized here. This past weekend was no exception. Sabrina, along with the young man and young lady who worked along side Sabrina, were excellent! Very attentive and professional for a family dinner consisting of 18 people, ranging in age from 23 to 94 yrs old. Everyone was pleased with the atmosphere of the dining room, service and food. Highly recommend, whether it’s a dinner for 2; a large family:group dinner or a special event such as a shower.“

“Great local spot that consistently delivers. Their vodka rigatoni is a standout & is rich, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The seasonal specials are always worth trying as well. The location is convenient, the service is genuinely friendly, and everything feels welcoming and well run. An added bonus is the small market on site, which makes it easy to grab take-home items and enjoy their food later. A great place for both a quick bite and stocking up on quality prepared foods.“

“excellent menu. food is soooo good! atmosphere awesome, staff excellent. our favorite local spot for almost 30 years!!!“

“Had a group of 16 and the food was amazing! Best cheesesteak I’ve had in years. Portion sizes were generous and the pasta dishes were getting rave reviews. Highly recommend checking this place out if you haven’t been here. Will be my go to spot whenever I’m in town.“

“Robert and his staff made my son's 35th Birthday Celebration very special. We had 30 people for dinner at Leonardo's on October 24, 2025, all of them were very pleased with the food, service and atmosphere for my sons 35th Birthday Celebration. Our menu consisted of Penne Marinara, Farfalle Vodka, Chicken Parmesan and a Caesar Salad. All would recommend Leonardo's when dining due to the taste and the service of the staff at Leonardo's. The pasta just melted in mouth and could taste the chesses, or the sauces on the pasta. There was more than enough food for all. The Caesar Salad was a blend of crisp, creamy, tangy and savory favors working together to achieve a satisfying balance. All in All the evening was perfect, and I will be coming back to Leonardo's for future celebrations.“

“Wow! What a perfect meal for my Italian friend and I. Service was excellent and the food was absolutely delicious! We got the Broccoli Rabe Sausage app and the Mussels and Clams Fra Diablo. She got a pan fried Soft Crab special and I got my favorite Eggplant Parmesan. We took dessert home but are too full to eat it. Highly recommend! Great vibes inside and BYOB.“

“A true gem in Lawrenceville. I highly recommend this place to those who enjoy good food.“

“If I could leave a 10 start review, I would! Definitely exceeded my expectations in customer, food quality and taste, it will definitely beat your mom’s cooking! I also recommend anyone to try out their “tres leches” dessert.“

“Call ahead or dine in. Either is preferred.“

“You will always see this place full of happy returning patrons and we are two of them. Food quality is fresh, tasty and reasonably priced. You have to try their Brick Oven pizzas. If you crave an American cheese hoagie, that is prepared on the best tasting roll in New Jersey, delicious cheese, and crisp lettuce and onions, try one of theirs. The very best that we have ever judged.“

“Food is delicious and we had the best service ever there!!“

“Outstanding food, great atmosphere and attentive staff.“

“Last night was our first time at Pastiamo's and our experience was fantastic from start to finish! The food was absolutely delicious -- Burrata, Gnocchi Pesto, Penne with Walnut Sauce and Rigatoni Ragu were especially everyone's favorites. The staff was polite, attentive, and so patient, even when we stayed past closing time. Thank you, Francesca and team for making our night so special. I highly recommend this restaurant, and our family will definitely be back!“

“Food and service was great .“

“first time eating there and the food was so good. will definitely be going back.“

“August 3, 2024....Just had the most delicious meal in recent memory, the Stuffed Chicken Breast over Spaghetti Puttanesca at Amalfi's in Lawrenceville!!! Outstanding! MUST TRY!!!! If you are fortunate enough to get ANDRES as your server as well, you will have a PERFECT dining experience.“

“We celebrated our 50th wedding anniversary here, and it was a magnificent experience from reservation to dessert! The food is indescribably delicious, and the service is first class. Our guests look forward to returning soon for their own experience. Thank you!!!“

“Great make your own pizza event! Very friendly and accommodating family of owners. Generous portions and surprisingly nice desserts. Highly recommend!“

“Excellent food and service. My new favorite restaurant.“

“Celebrated my wife's birthday last weekend. Food was delicious, service was excellent...we will be back!!“

“excellent food, service and a beautiful restaurant.“

“We recently celebrated my aunt's 85th birthday here, and it couldn't have been better! The food was absolutely delicious, with generous portions, and the staff was excellent from start to finish. Everyone commented on what a wonderful party it was. We couldn't have asked for a better experience and would highly recommend this venue for any special occasion!“

“Pepperoni pizza was delicious. First time stopping in, the slices weren’t selling me but I ordered a plain & a pepperoni and my first bite I was sold I didn’t even have to add garlic!! Will be back“

“First time there with my sister and my wife... I will DEFINITELY return to sample something else on the menu... The mussels and linguini in white sauce was PERFECT!!“

“BEST pizza in town! Friendly staff, great prices, amazing menu!“

“Best customer service pick up or take out! Orders are always correct if not they will make them right. Greet food and price“

“I would give 10 stars if I could they have the best pizza around everything I have tried over the yrs delicious. Great staff and owner I highly recommend trying then you won't be disappointed. Did I mention great prices to thumbs up for me try them I'm sure you'll agree 👍“

“Great food! Excellent service.“

“Thanks for the great dinners. This is definitely my goto Italian take out or dine-in. BYOB is perfect too as I can bring exactly what I want to drink. Capisci! 😎“

“Good job! It really tastes good, and the service attitude is also very good.“

“Best Pizza in The Area!! 🙌“

“Had dinner here tonight. My husband and I agree that it was one of the best dinners we have had in a very long time. Service was amazing. Even the hostess was walking around helping! Also the banana cream pie was unbelievable!!!“

“Friendly service and fantastic pizza. What a variety to pick from! I highly recommend this place. I was in town visiting family and came at my sister's recommendation.“

“Food is good. & Excellent service from Nicole.Good to see people coming back to Tessara’s. A nice menu selection! A good place to check out !“

“This review is LONG overdue. Me and my family have been going here since they opened. I've become very friendly with the owners. Both are nice guys. Great food, great atmosphere, 5/5 stars. I'm actually calling to order right now.“

“Incredibly welcoming staff. Quaint and historic interior. The food is out of this world! Can't wait to get back there again for that Primo sauce!“

“Ordered dinner tonight and 15 minutes later, they brought it out curbside & loaded into my car. Zero contact. The food was fresh, hot and delicious! Thank you!“

“comimos una pizza de clens espinacas y ajos estaban 🤤 😋 👌 exquisita reconmedadicimo“