48 Best Italian Restaurants near Lambertville

“We came in with a large group of 8, and a difficult one at that. We had 1 lactose intolerant, 2 gluten intolerant, 1 vegetarian, and my mother — who requests so many menu modifications that she’s basically creating her own dishes.

Tavola Rustica accommodated all of us, and served us the most delicious meal we could ask for. The service was friendly, patient, and extremely helpful. My cousin claimed her gluten-free La Romana was the best pizza she had ever had. My husband and I shared the polpette meatball appetizer, and a Miranda pizza — the combination of egg, truffle, and mozzarella was unexpected and unbelievable. Could not recommend this place enough. We’ll be back as soon as we can. On top of that, BYOB, have fun. ??

Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free pasta was so good, we had to confirm it was gluten-free. Cauliflower pizza crust was also great. Most restaurants make this too soft but this was crispy and delicious.“

“We had reservations to T54 at 6pm for a party of 5 on a Friday night. Greeted by the hostess we were seated promptly. The decor and vibe is vibrant and the atmosphere was lively. The 12 seated bar appeared to have a local following, (always a good sign). By 7pm the restaurant and patio seats were all taken. The waiter Anthony was professional and knowledgeable in describing the dish that I ordered which was the grilled branzino because the menu had a very brief description. My appetizer was the grilled octopus which transported me back to Greece, it was served with an arugula salad dressed with a fennel citrus, almonds, and capers. The service was impeccable, clearing our table and changing our silverware after having our appetizers, which is what a high end restaurant does. I chose the grilled branzino which was grilled to perfection, the fish flaky and sweet, it was stuffed with cherry tomatoes, zucchini, and black olives, surrounded in a hollandaise sauce and capers, served with a side of watercress salad dress in a lemon vinegarette, a wonderful accompaniment to the branzino. Sharing our dessert order, I topped the evening off with a bombolini, made to order and still warm with a light dusting of sugar and a small bowl of chocolate sauce, yummy. If I didn’t live in Oregon, I would also become a regular and enjoy the same dinner every Friday night or any night of the week because it is that good!“

“Very nice atmosphere and tasty food. Will def be back!“

“We always select from the Daily Specials menu. Dinie had the steak & I ordered the Grilled Chicken Kabob with rice and Greek Salsa. Both entrees came with a salad too. Delicious!“

“Delicious food and reasonable price“

“We recently celebrated my brother-in-law’s birthday here and we were all very impressed. Delicious food, excellent service, great atmosphere—what else could you ask for? Looking forward to my next visit!“

“They've done a great job creating outdoor ambiance but you will hear some planes from Mercer Airport. Hardly an issue when compared to the overall experience and indoor dining is terrific as well. Their chicken cacciatore is beyond compare - moist, tender chicken in a sauce you want to eat with a spoon. Hubby loves their chicken and veal parmesan. Tablemates agree on all counts. Service is always great as well. You can't go wrong.“

“Great place nice people excellent chefs . Highly recommended“

“The food here is excellent, without a doubt never had a bad meal. We recently had a small wedding here (50 people) and not only was the food great, but so was the staff and location. From booking to the date itself, everything was smooth and professional. The staff was on top and attentive to everything without being pushy or in the way. The place is always clean and has a nice atmosphere to boot. Highly recommend.“

“Piccolo Trattoria in Newtown accommodated about 30 more people than we originally planned for about 30 minutes ahead of schedule without even batting an eye. We just showed up, and they rallied their staff, set extra tables, hustled to take orders, and our meal was served hot and delicious. Highly recommend Piccolo- we’ll be customers for life.“

“Delicious food, great service and nice ambience!“

“Cannot recommend Cattani enough. There are not enough adjectives to describe how delicious the food is. As great as the regular menu is, the weekly specials are even better. I could go on and and on, but I know you aren’t reading past this. Just go and see for yourself. I’ll guarantee, not only will you will agree, but you will come back and bring friends to turn them on to the deliciousness.“

“Food was delicious! Server, Andrea, was awesome!!“

“The best restaurant in New Hope (the food). Luv this place. Luv the staff. Luv the food. Me and the Mrs have been here since they were Main St.“

“The best brick oven pie we ever had“

“This place is a hidden gem . We were there the other night with 5 people and everyone loved the food they ordered. We have been there a couple of times since it changed ownership and it’s great. It seems to be empty except on the weekends and I have no idea why. Maybe because it’s a few miles out of town. It’s more than worth the drive in my opinion !“

“Food and service was great .“

“Always great food and excellent service highly recommended! Never a bad meal love the sweet and sour calamari !!!“

“The Best around , will recommend to everyone. Authentic Italian , soups, meals the best. Pete Szwandrak“

“excellent food, service and a beautiful restaurant.“

“I would like to start off by saying hello to the Favoroso family I miss and love you guys. This is a little restraunt with on certain days amazing dishes and if you want a special dish and they have everything to make it consider the meal made for you. I was a cook for sometime there and Joe Fred, and myself did amazing cooking and everything was made to order and the owners made you feel like you were part of the family. If you go to the restaurant in the summer try to go in the evening hours and I recommend the back patio near the water fountain I have not seen any of my cousins in months and I have no doubt that they are doing well ( let me say I hope everything's going good and everyone is in good spirits and health). I gave the rating of 4 stars for food service and atmosphere because my last visit was at the level of this because it was crowded but not tightly packed and I enjoyed the family reunion kinda. If you want a great Italian meal with the feel of being in Italy I would recommend Visiting Villa Vito's you won't be disappointed.“

“Delicious food, enjoyed the Calimari Fritta, Mussels, Mushroom Soup, Wheat Garlic Bread and a Lobster Seafood over pasta. Highly recommended. The service is very good and personal. The atmosphere is very quaint. BYOB. Absolutely worth the trip.“

“Stopped for lunch, food was very good , bartender/waiter was friendly and covered all our needs. It has a warm, comfortable atmosphere.“

“Joe's serves delicious pizza, soup, pasta, and everything else on their menu; the food is amazing, and the service is wonderful. Their cheesesteaks surpass those of Pat's and Geno's, making them the best in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. This family-owned business is truly one of the best. Thank you for the wonderful meals!“

“Joe and Benny are amazing. The food is always fresh and delicious. Service always with a smile everybody’s warm and welcoming. We love this place. It’s our go to.“

“went to Marinelli's for the first time on 2/14. the meals were excellent! Brucsetta appetizer so tasty, enough for 4 people! service excellent and friendly! prices very fair for nice quality meals. we will.be back soon!“

“All .. salad pizza is my favorite“

“There’s a reason this place has been around forever. Whenever I’m in town visiting my parents , it’s a must for me. Grandma Sicilian pie, Brooklyn style and classic pizza always consistently good. Never had anything disappointing here. Been ordering from and going here since I was a kid in the 80s. Phone orders and delivery drivers always very helpful and patient with my now senior parents.“

“My husband and I came to eat here on our trip to Peddlers village. We will say absolutely amazing food and service! Our waitress Melinda was just as wonderful! She was a sweetheart and probably the quickest and most attentive waitress we ever had! We would give 10 stars if we could!“

“First time there with my sister and my wife... I will DEFINITELY return to sample something else on the menu... The mussels and linguini in white sauce was PERFECT!!“

“Great friendly staff and inviting atmosphere…“

“Had dinner here tonight. My husband and I agree that it was one of the best dinners we have had in a very long time. Service was amazing. Even the hostess was walking around helping! Also the banana cream pie was unbelievable!!!“

“great pizza, the staff ware amazingly helpful“

“Rose and Joe run a top notch bakery. All of their stuff is fresh and delicious. If you want bread get there early though! It sells out quick! ❤️“

“We absolutely love La Stalla. Paulie and the staff are wonderful, courteous and go above and beyond. We love their prepared food, especially the sandwiches (to die for), and their imported products are a slice of Italy 💗. My husband and I always recommend La Stalla! The freshness, taste and family like atmosphere of thisItalian market can’t be beat!“

“Absolutely wonderful! I ordered Mamma’s Tomato Sauce with pasta and it hit the spot! Tasty and amazing!! Couldn’t recommend more and I will definitely order again or stop in next time!“

“Tremendo servicio, con buena presentación sus platos, sobor incomparable y sobre todo buena carisma con los clientes... Me agrado este lugar.“

“This review is LONG overdue. Me and my family have been going here since they opened. I've become very friendly with the owners. Both are nice guys. Great food, great atmosphere, 5/5 stars. I'm actually calling to order right now.“

“I finally visited Sinatras after countless recommendations, and while the pizza was certainly good, it didn't quite live up to the hype. The restaurant itself is a delightful homage to Frank Sinatra, with his iconic photos adorning the walls. The staff was friendly and the menu offered a variety of mixed pies, making it easy to please different palates.

The cheese was flavorful but a bit too oily for my taste, and the sauce was decent. The dough and crust was ok but not thin and crispy. The pizza itself earned a 7.5 out of 10.“

“I think this Primo is under new ownership. They are doing a really good job IMO.“

“Love their food one problem they always deliver to my house on a Sunday I called up ordering for delivery the guy told me that they don’t deliver to my area Told him your boss told me you do he asked his boss he then said oh well we’re backed up so why don’t you order from the Hillsboro one the Hillsboro one is further away from me then Flemington location I will give them another shot because I like their food but I’m making it clear I’m unhappy with their staff and the way I was treated when all I wanted was a pizza Sunday night“

“We were in the area for a Rutgers football game. We had 35 for dinner and went with a party package menu! Everything was great from start to finish! The staff was amazing and the food delicious! Will definitely be back! Thank you Chimney Rock Inn!“

“Having been to a lot of the pizza places in the area we found Yardley Pizza to be very good. Green pepper and onion pizza is thin with a nice crust, eggplant parmigiana and chicken parmigiana are both tasty and large in portion. Salads are fresh.
Keep in mind - no alcohol is served.
Service was a little slow but not a problem.“

“Their pizza is simply the best what with so many choices in the Newtown/Wrightstown area. Perfect combination of cheese and sauce on an incredible tasty crust. Lots of choices out there, and they are my favorite.“

“The pizza was excellent and they were able to repair it very quickly. In all it took about 10 minutes. The price was reasonable the ingredients were fresh I have no complaints. I was expecting a little more after my friend raved about how amazing they were but it was still good.“

“Got 6 pizzas from gabbys for a bounce city birthday party. My son has a severe egg allergy and they promised to mark a pie and take extra care with it. He was able to eat it without any issue and we all enjoyed the pizza a lot. Thank you Gabby’s!“

“Ordered take out for the first time since Covid! Everything was hot, fresh, and delicious! Kudos to them for maintaining a great level of excellence.“

“I have ordered Franco’s Tomato Pie catering for years now, almost every occasion where we have lots of people over, because everyone absolutely loves their food! We haven’t had anything that was less than amazing from here. We have also ordered a variety of foods, and everything was delicious and fresh. They have great prices and are reliable! Would definitely recommend!“