50 Best Italian Restaurants near Jamesburg

“Had a luncheon after a funeral for 30 people and they were great! Prices extremely reasonable, food was excellent, service was excellent and their portions were double the size of most restaurants. Everyone was given containers to bring their left-over food home. Everyone remarked how excellent the food was and luncheon even included dessert which was delicious. I would recommend this place to everyone!“

“Beautiful restaurant. Everything we've eaten has been delicious. Menu has great options. It's a little on the expensive side but makes up for it by being BYOB. The wait staff is very attentive and you never feel like it's too short or too long for you food. It was our second time there and won't be our last!“

“Food is excellent, and it is consistently excellent, over many years. From the breads to the fico appetizer to the pasta and chicken mains (haven't had meats or seafood), I've always been satisfied. The staff is very good. Do wear or bring something warm because the room can feel cool. Do make reservations earlier than the day of, at least on the weekends.“

“The food at Carrabas is delicious and extremely comforting!The chicken soup always hits the spot and you can never go wrong with getting the Rigatoni Martino or the Chicken MarsalaThe staff is always super friendly and always accommodating for our food allergies! Thank you for always being one of our go to spots!Dietary restrictions: Gluten allergy and nut allergy“

“Starting with the name Italian Touch you can feel the reminisce of Italy throughout this establishment although not too flashy this location makes you want to dress business casual. The service is Unexpectedly 5 star and the energy is stupendous.Ok on to the food.My wife and I had the pleasure to getting to know one of the cooks trying out their personal favorites and I can easily see what the hype is about.Each slice bring farm to table flavors with a brick oven crust.I must say the flavor is what you expect when you desire that flavor.Food is an art and a science and they nailed both.Excellent experience here. Will be back.Sorry no pictures this time.“

“Went with 5 adults and 2 kids. Spent around $750 (tip included).Dinner was great but waitress forgot to bring appetizer before dinner.Manager asked if we still wanted it so we said sure why not.He still told the waitress to charge us for the appetizers even though they messed up. Small detail but comes across as a bit tacky given their reputation cost of dining here..“

“EDIT: I am not as angry now and you acknowledged your mistake but every day is a tryout homie sorry I called you the b word.Showed up early to pickup my order let them know what I was there for, watch the balding guy take my sunny d ($30 pizza) box it and set on the cold granite countertop for 10+ minutes while they made the rest of my order. $30 pie literally ice cold before it got to my car. Livid and wish I could swear on here.“

“This was our 3rd time dinning and the place was very busy for a Thursday at 7 pm. The service was not as great as our last couple of visits. The food was excellent my only complaint would be the clams casino were a little small. My date enjoyed the soup and both of our entrees were great. We will be back soon.“

“Slice has quickly become our preferred destination. We appreciate every aspect of this establishment, particularly our support for family-run businesses due to their commitment to quality, consistency, and fair pricing. Frank makes the whole experience a very comfortable environment. Looking forward to visiting again, Frank!“

“Finally able to get the five couples together. I requested a round table but was told they only accommodated up to six at their round. Was seated in a back room at a long table that ended up being perfect!!! Easy conversation. No one felt excluded as sometimes a long table can We did the primo family style Fried calamari Stuffed mushrooms Zucchini fritte Caesar salad Antipasto salad Bolognese Vodka pastas Chicken limone Veal saltimbocca Eggplant parmigiana And a sampling of desserts Mini canolis Mini eclairs Lemon bars Rainbow cookies The meal was amazing. Everything was delicious!!“

“The best tacos!! Keep it up always and you will never lack customers!! The delicious tacos al pastor and enchilada not to mention with their fresh and finely chopped onion their fresh cilantro the super fresh cucumbers, radishes, lemons that's how it should be! Just a little less fat but they are “

“Tomato Pies Italian Kitchen offers a decent dining experience with its cozy ambiance and Italian-inspired dishes. The menu selection is varied, but some dishes fell short of expectations in terms of flavor and execution. While the service was friendly.Additionally, the portion sizes seemed inconsistent, with some dishes being overly generous while others felt lacking. Overall, Tomato Pies has potential, but there are areas that could be improved to elevate the dining experience.“

“For a mom n pop pizzeria, Carmela's sure is one of the best NY style pizzas that I've had. We ordered a large size cheese pizza, along with some garlic knots/bread. The pizza came out hot n ready from the oven. The cheese was just stretching away and the sauce was robust. The dough itself tasted very good. We sprinkled some red crush peppers and garlic seasoning/powder. Mmmmm more and more garlic. And more garlic. And wait....even more garlic. The garlic knots were delicious. They were heated warmAnd I asked them to lace it with extra garlic oil. A perfect combination of both items. There's a few tables inside and it's a simple looking pizzeria. They do offer pizza by the slices also.“

“Food was 11/10 ❗️Order 4 different dishes yesterday all of them tasted amazing! Ordered so much that I dropped my garlic bread on my way to the car. Went back inside and without hesitation the manager made me a fresh batch. Very hardworking people who care about our community. Great environment to bring to your friends and family for quality food.“

“We had a 730 reservation got there 10 minutes early we got seated right on time. The food was excellent The service could have been better. We had to ask for everything at least twice and waited a while before it came. Overall it was very good and I will be back.“

“Was traveling home from Virginia to Maine and happened to stay at a hotel right down the street. So glad we chose this place . The owner and his wife were amazing people and made us feel like we had been going there for years . We will be stopping here every time we are in the area . For the experience alone . Thanks guys appreciate great food and amazing service“

“The food was very good and we had a toddler with us and the staff was very good with her.l and couldn't be nicer. The atmosphere is happy and not too loud but enough noise that the baby did not bother anybody. It is a go-to place for us and it is a byob (bonus).“

“My husband and I go on a regular basis. They always treat us so special. We even have our own little table always waiting for us! The food and specials are phenomenal along with the superb service we always get. It truly feels like family!“

“Tony's Open Kitchen is a great Italian addition to the neighborhood. I recently went to dinner her with a group of 10. Everyone enjoyed their food. The pasta entrees were a hit and the Regolare Pizza was great (ohh.. that sauce). The service was fast and efficient. I ordered then eggplant parmigiana, which was awesome and a plentiful portion size. I liked the fact that it was not deep fried, but instead lightly battered and baked. The accompanying vegetables were all so flavorful and delicious. The complimentary bread was hot, fresh and tasty out of the oven. It's a BYOB, so that's a plus. I look forward to going back and trying some of the other entrees. Note: They charge 3% for using a credit card and will only do up to 3 credit cards per table. That created a bit of an issue with 10 people, since not everyone had cash on hand.“

“This is a great place for dinner! The restaurant is so pretty, so clean and the food is delicious! The meatball appetizer is a must try. The pork chop with rice pilaf and the rigatoni bolognese are perfectly portioned, shareable and full of flavor! Never once reached for the salt and pepper.I love the family feel you get the second you walk through the doors. There are photos of the owners and their kids are on the wall and they are all on the floor, serving customers with a smile. You can definitely tell it’s a place filled with love, a passion for food and most importantly, family. Would definitely recommend to anyone!“

“I’m so happy we finally made it here! After months of reading the positive reviews, my son recommended that we come for dinner! Everything was prepared fresh, portions were plentiful, service was attentive and presentation was appealing. We will definitely be back!! Highly recommend!“

“This is a great place to go eat at because of the nice wall paintings they have and just the vibe is so homey and welcoming. take out is great too. i have had the pizza, the tacos, the sopes, and let me tell you you cannot go wrong with anything on their menu. it’s just too good. now if i really wanna put my food reviewer cap on i have to say there is one thing that is off, and that is the prices. the amount of food that you get for the price is crazy. they make sure that you are full and have left overs ?‍? love it keep doing what you’re doing ??Kid-friendliness: great place to bring kids“

“Dusal's Italian Restaurant is a long-standing favorite, and it's easy to see why. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, making it hard to go wrong with any choice. One standout dish is the Grilled Chicken Special sub, which is packed with flavor and a perfect choice for a hearty meal. Another must-try is the penne pasta with grilled chicken and vodka sauce, a dish that is sure to satisfy any pasta lover's cravings.What sets Dusal's apart is its commitment to providing high-quality food at reasonable prices. It's the perfect spot for a family dinner or a casual meal with friends. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make dining at Dusal's a truly enjoyable experience.Overall, Dusal's Italian Restaurant is a solid choice for anyone looking for delicious Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting setting. With its excellent food and affordable prices, it's no wonder Dusal's has been a favorite for so many years.“

“It's a nice family style Italian restaurant that accommodates a large party for dinner. My kids enjoy it and run to the bakery area to choose their favorite dessert. The service was always great and we never waited long to be seated or served.“

“I was looking to have a small lunch after my son's communion and pretty much every place I contacted was like "4 hours and $80/pp" which is more money and time than I wanted. On a recommendation I contacted Pasquales Brick Oven on Ryders in Milltown and for MUCH less they gave us their side room for 30 people and it was FANTASTIC! It's BYO so we brought some beer and wine and they set up wine glasses and gave us more delicious food than I can even say-everyone went home with dinner for a few nights! Service was impeccable and I would recommend anyone having an intimate party check it out.“

“3/1/24 I read about Via Sposito having multiple restaurants serving family style dishes and their Pizza ovens are wood and coal fired so we went to the one in Old Bridge, NJ. Our gracious host Dolores is an Sposito who we had the pleasure to talk with.We started with Zuppa di Mussels,which was delicious and the sauce to dip the mussels in was so sweet yummy.Just look at the pictures before and after.Then my wife ordered the huge Pork Chop with mixed vegetables and potatoes, my wife couldn't finish her meal.I ordered a Margarita Pizza with homemade mozzarella and pecorino romano cheese and fresh basil with extra virgin olive oil. On top I added real sliced sweet sausage,outstanding pizza,will definitely order it again together with outstanding service see the before and after pictures. Well worth the trip.“

“So I just moved to the area. For the most part pizza is awesome. They just have to let it actually cook. I don’t like non- crispy pizza. Other than that pizza is A1.When we first went for take out. I didn’t have such a great experience. However this last time for delivery changed that.“

“Quite possibly the best pizza place in Jersey. Great nuanced taste – for example, the crust has this perfect texture – made extremely fresh with obviously quality ingredients. AND the people who work there are really cool and friendly. AND the prices are reasonable. It's a treat that I'm happy to go out of my way for (I don't live close by).“

“Although we have never dined in the restaurant, we have been to several private parties and just love the way they do things. Family style appetizers, pasta, salad and great choices. This last time we had steak, which we were apprehensive about but even that was tender and cooked perfectly.Parking: Plenty and easily accessible“

“The most amazing pizza and Italian dishes you will ever eat! Super fresh and always delicious! The owners are the sweetest and truly make you feel special every time you visit. We’ve been customers since they were located in the Meyers parking lot, however, we’ve moved in the last few years and are unable to get our fix of Bella La Pizzeria greatness since. We travel over 3 hours for the best pizza and meals because the food is that delicious! I’m sitting here in heaven this evening enjoying a slice of their perfect pizza. Yummmm!!!…….“

“I love the pizza from Cranbury Pizza. Moved to Jersey from Chicago over a decade ago. Pizza has always been my favorite. I loved Chicago pizza. Have tried many a pizza on the East Coast since then. It was not until I found Cranbury Pizza that I said, “Ahh….I think I can do this”. I would go for a slice of pizza and a salad, after taking singing lessons across the street, and then when dating my (now) husband, Mike. I don’t take the lessons anymore, and we’ve moved about thirty to forty minutes from the restaurant. After two years of being disappointed the pizza places around where we are, I asked my husband (on my birthday) to get me a cheese pizza from Cranbury Pizza. When he went to pick it up, the guy was so nice, he offered my husband an additional pizza, no charge! It was later in the evening, and the person who ordered it didn’t pick it up. When he got home with it, I was delighted to find that it was a second cheese pizza (my favorite). YUM. Let me tell you, I was HAPPY and thankful. It’s the only pizza I eat now. Even Michael believes it’s worth the commute.When I did eat at the restaurant, the staff was always amiable. Never had anything but great food and a great time. Love Cranbury Pizza!“

“These were actually surprisingly good. The full sub is huge, turkey was fresh, mayo tasted good.. no complaints with that one. The oil and vin made the bread on the other sandwich mushy quick, so eat fast. I'd compared these to tastee. It's not an Italian salumeria with the best quality meat the world has to offer, but it's world's better than subway and jimmy johns.“

“Expensive, but you get what you pay for. This place is a great date atmosphere! The menu is large and diverse options are available, including the Stage left steakhouse portion. The Buratta appetizer was by far the best buratta I have had to date. Drinks were good and reasonably strong, proportionate to the price. Will definitely be back!“

“First time eating here, it is a quaint little place. I wasn't expecting live music but it was a welcome ambiance. Food was great, portions were very good. I got the chicken francese, my favorite go and got two large chicken breasts. Our waitress was young and didn't know the answer to a couple of the questions from our party but knew who to ask and quickly got back to us, so credit to her. The dessert cannoli was one of the best I've ever had. I would definitely come back.Parking: Small limited lot on parking, maybe 8-10 spaces, otherwise it is street parking.“

“As someone born and raised in New Jersey, I can tell you I’ve tried about a million different slices of pizza. What I’ve found is there are 2 types of pizza: good pizza, and fast pizza. Occasionally, you’ll come across a place who has managed to craft a perfect 50/50 split. Though rare, it is possible. I moved to this area about 3 years ago, and I have tried nearly every pizza joint in a 10 mile radius.When Nana’s came along, I was skeptical, as I had found a regular spot with decent enough pizza and was pretty happy. But one fateful night, we switched it up and tried Nana’s. I can tell you: I will be ordering Nana’s for as long as I am within an hour driving distance. Whether it’s pickup or delivery, our pizza has always been fresh and just crispy enough. The garlic knots are light and fluffy with plenty of garlic. The sauce is to die for. The wings are never burnt, and the ratio of breading to meat is a healthy one. Everything we have ever ordered from Nana’s has been a grand slam. It just works out they’re a 5 min walk for me, too! (Though most days we order delivery any way because we’re Mets fans and we can’t risk missing out on a single minute of them losing)Love you Nana’s! Keep being crispy ?“

“The most amazing pizza and Italian dishes you will ever eat! Super fresh and always delicious! The owners are the sweetest and truly make you feel special every time you visit. We’ve been customers since they were located in the Meyers parking lot, however, we’ve moved in the last few years and are unable to get our fix of Bella La Pizzeria greatness since. We travel over 3 hours for the best pizza and meals because the food is that delicious! I’m sitting here in heaven this evening enjoying a slice of their perfect pizza. Yummmm!!!…….“

“I live in the general area and drive by here all the time and when it pops up in GrubHub, I always want to try it but are usually ordering another kind of cuisine. However, this evening we finally did try it...and the only thing we are upset about is that we didn't try this place much sooner! ? We ordered a plain pie with extra cheese...big hot! Hot, fresh, and delicious with a lovely sauce. The buffalo wings were very tasty! We also ordered the grilled steak salad, which was fresh and flavorful, and the shrimp alla vodka...awesome vodka sauce! We will definitely be ordering again!“

“I don’t know that it’s the best New York style pizza place, but it’s my favorite. We stop every time we visit my wife’s family because I always want white pizza and ordering one in Florida is like picking up sushi at a gas station.The employees are top notch, and I know they go out of their way to take care of my MIL and make things special/fresh for her.Vegetarian options: Veggie and plain options availableKid-friendliness: Kids love pizza!Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty of space in the shop if you’re in a chair“

“The staff is extremely kind and pretty quick. The atmosphere is relaxing and oddly nostalgic. The food is simple but it works so perfectly. The food is also cheap and affordable. If you have a bike, you can bring it inside for safe keeping. If you want a simple, good slice of pizza for cheap in a relaxed small pizza place, it's a must visit.“

“I saw this place and stopped in. It was very clean and had a good parking lot size. The restaurant inside is rather cozy and the pizza was fantastic! I ordered I think a shrimp scampi slice and it was really big and very filling. I would definitely go back here again, the people were also very nice.Parking: They have at least 10 spots in the front shared with a barber shop and a ravioli place, and then tons more parking in the back.“

“1st time ordering a pizza from here and I could kiss the chef. I ordered the special, a large pie with one free topping and you can pay for more toppings if you want and I got pepperoni and fresh garlic, it also came with a 2 litter bottle of soda, I got Barqs root beer which happens to be my favorite root beer. This pizza was so freaking good. They managed to keep the crust crunchy and airy and the bottom firm while having more sauce then most pizzas and the cheese and toppings nicely baked. My friend told me the pepperoni is all beef, and it was DELICIOUS! The pizza had substance while not being sloppy where everything slides off and that takes talent. Washing it down with cold Barqs rootbeer was an added bonus. Just look at the pictures, it's a beautiful pie!“

“Cafe Amici is always my go to for my office and their service is amazing! Food is always solid, I love their penne vodka and all of their chicken options are great, super tender. They are an amazing option for catering and are always on time.“

“Have lived in the area for awhile and have heard good things about Brothers and finally had the chance to try them for lunch. I had a regular slice and a grandmas slice and they were both VERY good. Crisp crust and flavorful sauce. I will be back with the family to try other items.“

“This past Friday we booked the private room at Bello's for a repast. The staff was incredible, the food was delicious, and the prices were reasonable. They were also able to put it all together on such short notice. I highly recommend!“

“Mannino’s is the best, My family is so thrilled we came across them. They have the best Grandma pie. Yesterday we ordered a sausage , onion and roasted pepper pie, it was amazing. This is the best pizzeria in the area. I didn’t think anyone here could make a fantastic pie, but they did. This will definitely be our go to place, no others in the area come close. Keep maki g your delicious food“

“Ordered a large pepperoni and sausage pizza with a side of calamari. The pizza quality never fails and is always tasty with the right amount of sauce, toppings, and cheese. The marinara sauce for the calamari is clearly made from scratch and took me by surprise by how fresh and homemade it tasted.Their staff were also super attentive and helpful in bringing out the food for tables, packing leftovers, bringing utensils, and water.“

“Unbeatable experience with classic atmosphere and incredible dishes- dropped in as I'd wanted to visit for a little while and I am so glad I did. The owner Mr. Vito was incredibly gregarious and folksy and took the time to chat with me- THIS is why I'm outspoken about supporting FAMILY OWNED RESTAURANTS and avoiding franchises- because you can't get the service and care at a franchise place that you get at a family owned restaurant like Francesco Pizza. Digging Milltown with every visit (I work about 20 miles away) and Francesco's reinforced my feelings for the town. Thanks to the entire team- the food was savory and fantastic, my Grandmother was Sicilian so I know what I'm talking about. Adored this place, will be back!Vegetarian options: Everything you could expect for anyone not eating meat: pizza, pasta, salads, etc.Parking: There were plenty of parking spots but just to be sure I asked the boss as I walked in if I was fine and he put me at ease, was a great experience!“

“Stopped here for dinner before a show at the Starland Ballroom. Plenty of parking and a ton of tables. Has an old-school Italian feel to it. Huge menu with a lot of classic dishes. Served warm bread before the meal with the option of olive oil and butter. They had a peach sangria special that was excellent. I tried the lobster raviolis and was pleasantly surprised. These weren’t your typical store bought pre-frozen raviolis. No sir. Fresh made and stuffed with lobster. The chicken Murphy was enough for two people! Amazing. Rest assured, next time I’m at the Starland I will be stopping back here before the show.“

“I've lived five minutes from Dusals my whole life, and also went for pizza as recently as two weeks ago. They have always been consistently great. Their pizza is an excellent example of NJ pizza... thin but not too thin. Delicious cheese, sauce and flavorful crust. Recently I've been more into their Sicilian which is also delicious. And the service has always been super friendly and on point.“

“First time here. Had slice of Sicilian. Not usually a Sicilian guy but it looked really good. It was fantastic! Light & crispy bottom and crust. Fluffy & light middle. Sauce was delicious! Definitely will be back & definitely recommend!“