50 Best Burger Restaurants near Mahwah

“*Edit to the below review - the owner reached out to us after we left our review, and apologized for our experience. We did decide to give them another try, and we did get a good pizza this time. We appreciate the time he took to speak with us.

As a family of native New Yorkers, we'd like to think we all know good pizza here at our house. We've been all over for good pizza, but this place has always been our at home go-to place to order from. Our grandparents ordered here for years before we moved locally and started ordering ourselves about three years ago - at least 6 or 7 years of happy customers between both families. The last 4 or 5 times we've ordered here we've been pretty disappointed - but today we received the order that officially has gotten us to the point where we will no longer be ordering or picking up food here anymore. Tonight's dinner was officially a waste of money. The peppers and onions were raw on a 1/2 sausage peppers and onions 1/2 extra cheese pie. We asked for it to be cooked well done, which we have plenty of times before, and the pizza had to be cooked in our oven so that the dough could finish cooking. The whole thing was a big, sloppy mess when we opened the cover. This place used to be great quality food - every single time. I get that times are tough and things are expensive, and things can't always be perfect. There's been a serious decline going on though, and tonight was kinda the last straw for our family.“

“My experience was fantastic! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm welcome, the young lady was incredibly friendly and helpful, making the whole experience even better. The ice cream itself was smooth, creamy and tasty. The overall experience, makes it the kind of place that makes you want to come back again.“

“good service, people are friendly“

“Food is delicious and the service friendly. Recommend!“

“Only BK my husband will go to. I think they make everything fresh when u order. Ask yourself, when was the last time you got extremely Hot fries. Their breakfast sandwiches are the freshest fast food ones you can get. Fluffy eggs at BK, yup at this location it's possible.“

“Great french fries and great chicken sandwich and your burgers are good too and your sauce great job Matt a good job on your cookies“

“Popped in after our son’s soccer game. All our meals were fresh and exactly how we wanted! The food was delicious and prices were spot on. Thank you, Paul. We will absolutely be back.“

“The atmosphere is awesome! The food was soooo good!!! What made it even more amazing was our server Briana!!! I couldn’t decide what to try and she recommended the spicy buffalo chix sandwich with sweet potato fries! She was on point with that recommendation!! I’m a foodie so definitely coming back!!“

“We hosted a surprise 60th birthday party this past weekend and it couldn’t have been more perfect. From the first call to set it up to the moment we walked out the door, the staff made sure it was such a great experience. The people who work there are so attentive and kind. The managers Bryan and Kelly were so helpful in planning our party and Ivan is a rockstar. He took care of our party of 20 and made sure we had everything we needed. We never had to look for him, he was always checking on us and providing excellent service. He truly is so great at what he does. We had a sit down lunch in their cottage room which was so nicely decorated. the space was perfect. We felt like we were in our own restaurant. It was cozy but spacious and they were so accommodating with how we wanted it set up. We were able to bring balloons and decorations and the staff even helped us set up. They had a curtain up in the doorway so we were able to really surprise the guest of honor. Our lunch was delicious. We chose to do the seated option with 3 shareable apps and we picked a menu of 4 main meals from their party menu. Most of us ordered the shepherds pie and it was some of the best we had ever had. The presentation was cute. It came in a skillet which was served on a board with Irish soda bread. It was so delicious. The show stopper was the shareable Irish egg rolls. We couldn’t stop talking about them. The drinks were really good and the bar staff was really attentive to the party. The kids ordered from the long kids menu and they really enjoyed theirs as well. The pricing was very reasonable and worth every penny. We were able to bring our own cake and they cut it up and served it for us which was so nice. I can’t thank them enough for how special they made this experience. Everyone in our party had such an amazing time. The staff here are incredible. I would absolutely consider them for your next party.“

“Amazing and tasty food!! Great service and great prices! High quality meats and chicken, all halal, with proper certificates!“

“Great food and friendly team“

“los mejores beger que e peovado en us“

“Great food and service! we had lobster rolls and shared an order of clay strip and fries! was as good as being down the shore. in the past we have had burgers sitting outside with our dogs. the owner would always bring a big bowl of water for them. oh and delicious hand scooped milk shakes! go you won't be sorry.“

“Got a triple stacked cheeseburger. The smashed beef had incredible crust and perfect beef to cheese ratio. By far one of the best burgers I've had in a while. Washed it down with a coffee milk shake which complimented it perfectly. Simple but great meal. 10/10!“

“You have become my newest addiction. Your food (the chicken is my favorite!!) is so tasty and fresh. Your staff is friendly and professional. We will seeing alot of each other, lol. Thank you!!!“

“Awesome service.. great food! Never have to wait long“

“loved it.. 💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓“

“This place is awesome! The burgers and chicken sandwiches are off the charts amazing. Then, we tried the pizza and that is terrific as well. The staff is very nice and helpful and the restaurant is really clean and comfortable. Our family and friends are so excited that Wayback is now in Emerson! I can’t wait to go back!“

“Awesome food!! The Staff is very pleasant!! Very clean!! I give it *****!!!“

“Have gone here many times and have not been disappointed. The food is excellent as well as the Service and drinks. Bring your friends and family for a great time and great food!!!“

“So yeah, this is a restaurant in a grocery store, but that doesn't mean they cheap out on their offerings. I've been here a few times and I've been very happy with my food. Besides the Burgers being tasty and the Tuscan fries being Excellent, the advantage of eating here is that you have every beverage available in the store and also the option of getting the Wegman's buffet for sides and such. An excellent lunch stop!“

“Took my 12 year old son for the first time. He said it was the best hot dog he ever had and thanked me for bringing him.“

“Amazing food, shakes, and people! I was in town for business and went both nights I was there - Rafael remembered I was going to come back the second night and went out of his way for me! And the Loaded Fries are unbelievably yummy!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Absolutely amazing experience!
This hotdog place isn’t just about great food—it’s about the people behind it. The owner is very, nice — truly one of the kindest and most genuine people you’ll ever meet. You can feel the care and love in everything they do, from the perfectly cooked hotdogs to the welcoming atmosphere. The service makes you feel like family, and the food is always fresh, flavorful, and served with a smile. Highly recommend stopping by—you’ll leave full and happy every single time! 🌭💛“

“Very good food,especially the burgers ! Good atmosphere and great service.“

“We used to walk there from the house over 50 years ago. Pick up a dozen Dilly Bars (I think they call them Buster bars now). I always knew the staff because we grew up together. So much more than memories !“

“Went to Dog house yesterday. Found out the chef left. 😩 Food definately proved it. used to Love the cheesecake sandwich, but not today. Way too much Wostishire that overpowered the sandwich and steak sliced too thick. Very disappointed! And the very young bartender was very disappointing also. only 6 people there and not very responsive or knowledgeable!“

“They now have computers in their hands with gets the food to you faster“

“When I got there, they had one person working the front counter register as well as the drive thru so it took a while to get service. Afterwards, I found out that one of the workers, that would have been at the front, was helping a person outside getting their car started.Things have improved both at the drive thru and inside.“

“I haven’t been to The Barn since my kids were young, but we visited Abma’s farm today for the hayride with my daughter and granddaughter and stopped at The Barn for dinner after. What a delight! The staff were so welcoming and child-friendly. I have never been anywhere as child-friendly in Bergen County. Their outside seating area is perfect for families with young children in tow. Thank you for a wonderful dining experience.“

“We ordered pizza on Easter Sunday for dinner. The food tasted really good and the employees were super nice 👍🏼 I would highly recommend this restaurant!“

“The $5 meal deal is the best thing a fast food restaurant can offer these days! First visit to this Burger King. Served quickly in the restaurant even though the order taker was also working in the drive thru. The food was good enough. The nuggets for the meal were a little tough (need to clean the oiil would be my guess). There were a few customers eating their food in the the lobby. The lobby eating area could have been a little cleaner- a sweep and mop, wiping the tables and soda machine down could make it better. Overall, I would return.“

“We had charlea as our server and she was THE BEST SERVER EVER. We went late for half apps and it was fantastic especially since it was late and we went as a group of 8. She had great energy and was so nice and funny to us. This had to be one of the funniest and best experiences at a restaurant I've ever had (charlea WAS FANTASTIC)!“

“Our Christmas tradition is to serve a succulent tenderloin as the main course. Sadly, our local butcher shop closed recently, leaving me in search of a quality replacement. Luckily, I discovered Westwood Prime Meats! Their tenderloin was absolutely incredible - so tender and flavorful that our guests raved about it all night. If you're looking for a truly special piece of meat to impress your guests, I wholeheartedly recommend Westwood Prime Meats.“

“The white castle that's been here for decades went through a remodel during covid times.

Long gone is the window to see them cooking the sliders and the bench tables.

Now it's cut and dry interior of tables and chairs and window seats with a large space in the middle where additional tables could have been placed.

They sell merch: tshirts and caps and some other items.

The menu has expanded a bit more, so you have beef, chicken, fish, impossible to choose from.

#craver“

“Best burgers plus many other menu items . Almost want to keep it a secret, but they are so nice, I want them to be successful! Been there many times, consistently excellent.“

“Wish I had more time to discect their Pizza. Was in town for National Hot Dog Day and snuck in a slice in between. Wish I went with the Garlic Knot slice now, but the regular slice was speaking to me. It was a very good slice that had good harmony. I like more sauce, but it did the trick. Was one of the better fill you belly slices I have had. The workers were friendly and place was clean. Cool art work on the walls. I will definitely be goinv back soon. Nice surprise pizzeria.“

“Great burgers!!!! and fries, enjoyed very much. recommend to all“

“Quick, fast, efficient and clean. oh and burgers and fries are amazing! You go here enough and they will recognize you and learn your name.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options. Dedicated fryer for fries and no bun options, lettuce wrap or bowl.“

“I recently hosted a 50th birthday dinner at Tavern @ Iron Horse and could not have been more satisfied with the experience. The general manager, Jackie Russ, was an absolute standout. She went above and beyond to ensure our evening was perfect, from coordinating the menu to making sure every detail was exactly as we had envisioned. Her professionalism and welcoming demeanor set the tone for the entire night.The food was absolutely delicious. I chose chicken milenase, pork chop and hanger steak for the dinner selections. I have been receiving rave reviews from our guests. The service was impeccable, with our server being both attentive and friendly without ever being intrusive.Thanks to the incredible team, and especially Jackie Russ, our 50th birthday celebration was a seamless and memorable event. We highly recommend Tavern @ Iron Horse for any special occasion.“

“This Place is awesome. I went and asked if they would make a special blizzard my daughter say on TikTok. They said sure. Do you know what’s in it? We looked it up and they made it. They always go above and beyond Thank you for being awesome people.“

“Great food in a comfy, friendly atmosphere! If you LOVE a good dog “All the Way”,Mc Cobbs is a MUST!“

“Been going there since I moved to the area in the mid ‘80s. The food is great and the value is outstanding. Nice large portions. Only thing better than the food is the staff. They are friendly and fast! Always a fun day out whether you’re having a family dinner or just watching a game on one of the many TVs. The owner Ray truly has found a winning formula. Can’t wait till my next visit!!!“

“I come from Pennsylvania an hour and 40 mins away just to get some cars! Lol. I love love loveeeeee the wraps with chicken, Philly steak, mozzarella cheese sticks, French fries with cheese sauce is to die for!! Highly recommend to anyone in the area. Delicious!“

“Very good :)“

“Excellent spot for family and friends to meet and dine as well as viewing sports on TV“

“Super friendly staff and the blizzards and other treats are always on point. If there's a line they always keep things moving quickly and everything always comes out without any issues. The quality is also great and I always look forward to coming to this DQ location.

Dietary restrictions: Non diary dilly bar available“

“I was near Goffle Grill last night so I had to stop by and visit Tony the owner. Of course the food was great. I wish I lived closer I probably be there several times a week. They have a pretty big menu and it's never disappointed.Nice people, good food, please support them.“

“I have to say I was pleasantly surprised when upon entering this establishment. I haven't really had good experiences with trying new icecream places. But not only was this locations Dairy Queen clean the icecream was beyond my expectations 😋👍 I will post 2 pictures that I took while at the store. I ate a simple vanilla cone with Rainbow 🌈 sprinkles. My best friend and I loved it! We will definitely be back. Thank you for our great experience 👍“