22 Best Ice Cream Shops near Medford Lakes

“Stopped by this nice little shop today and had a great experience. The waffle cone with sprinkles was soooo good with muddy boots ice cream! There was only 1 employee working but she was very nice even while handling a rush of customers with screaming kids. Will definitely go back!“

“So excited we just discovered this place! Not only is the ice cream amazing, the owners were incredibly friendly and welcoming. They recognized that we were first timers and gave us the run down of flavors and everything they offer. They even have merch, created by the owner himself, and it’s awesome! A great addition to Rancocas Woods. We will definietly be regulars!!“

“Ice cream is my favorite dessert ever and I am the most picky there is...this is hands down THE BEST ice cream I have ever had in my entire life and I've had decades worth of homemade ice cream. I went here after having 2 slices of pizza and actually finished my ice cream beyond the point of feeling stuffed because it was THAT good. I'll gladly take the full feeling smiling happily with the leftover flavor lingering in my mouth, reminding me of the eye rolling, slapping the table goodness of this amazingly perfected recipe. Plus, the owner, Vincent, is a treasure to this town and the nicest, most relatable, sweet guy. He only adds the best ingredients, and as many times as people claim that same motto, there's no denying it. You can tell with the texture, the mouth feel, the density, melting speed (nice and slow to the last bite with just enough melt to be soft and easy to eat quickly without getting a brain freeze). There's a reason why there's always a line down the block! I'm not one to ever wait on a line, but for this, I would wait in pouring rain, hail, and even a hurricane. This sounds very exaggerated, but I've never been more excited to discover such a magical place. I can't wait for my next visit (which will most likely be at least twice a week). NO regrets. It doesn't matter what flavor you choose, you'll be in heaven! Even if it's chocolate vanilla or strawberry and you THINK you know what those taste like, you're wrong. Vincent customizes and perfects each recipe to his very own unique flavor. Even the coffee flavor has a homemade marshmallowy taste to it (acting as the cream in the coffee, I'm assuming). Out of this world, and I've never tasted anything like it. Even strawberry cheesecake, which is my least favorite flavor, made me a believer. If it could make me love a flavor I usually despise, then that should tell you something. I will never get ice cream from the grocery store or anywhere else again!! Vincent's for life!“

“THE BEST ICE CREAM PLACE EVER!!! The ice cream is to die for all the flavors are great I've been here over 20 times and always have had a nice experience and never disappointed! I mean come on, an ice cream shop WITH a drive thru? Does it get any better than that?“

“Great place to eat opens at 5am.Food is very good service great customers friendly.Your a local or traveling past stop in and grab a bite or ice cream for you and the family you won't be disappointed.Clean, well lit, many different options to choose from.“

“Jersey corn ice cream? I kept seeing it online and had to try it. It was delicious but a very different flavor. This ice cream shop has regular ice cream and also vegan flavors. The menu is labeled with what flavors are gluten free, soy free, or egg free which makes this ideal for those with dietary restrictions. They also use local ingredients.“

“This is by far the best Rita's around. The staff is so friendly & professional. Everything is always very clean - even in the sticky summer. 5 stars!Dietary restrictions: The Italian ice is vegan. The sugar-free flavors are amazing!“

“This place is outstanding, there is no other way to put it. The water ice is without a doubt the best around. My favorite is the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, it’s a must-try. The manager, Rachel, is as nice and helpful as it gets. She’s hilarious and always puts a smile on the customers faces. Getting Diane’s is always a treat and it’s always clean and great value. Thank you Diane’s! THANK YOU Rachel!“

“The ice cream is actually really good and I had a group of us sample some of the flavors and I would say the only flavor that was kind of nasty was the mint chocolate chip due to its excessive green look. I would also say that all of the Cold cow associates are friendly and likeable for the most part. The atmosphere is cute and reminds me of a side alley ice cream shop in a rustic location but when you look more around it is a pretty unfavorable parking lot for its location. My best friends family is associated with the company and I do have some bias but I am often pretty critical of ice cream.“

“Excellent place and everyone knows it! The line is crazy long in Friday and Saturday nights, so I go during the week and get extras to stock up so I don't have to fight the crowd! Love that they change their flavors and rotate bringing in new ideas. Great quality and service!“

“The best bagel sandwiches in south jersey! I was a bit skeptical when they started doing bagels, but I'm so glad I tried them. They don't skimp on fillings, and the eggs are nicely seasoned. The ice cream is great too. I only wish I could get the bagels year round!“

“This is my favorite place for frozen treats. The staff is friendly, the place is clean, the atmosphere is delightful whether you get take-out or eat your treats at a table. I'm happy they have not closed for the season and I hope that doesn't change. I missed Peachwave all last winter!“

“I came with my grandma and boyfriend last Wednesday, and I was greeted with a smiling face who politely took my order, he was very attentive and he was so polite. This worker was by far the most kind one I have ever seen at any Rita’s location, I believe his name was like Anton or Antonio. He let us know what he recommended, and helped my grandmother pick what she should order. Next time I come in I hope he is working so I can be greeted by his smiling and attentive face again. 10/10 will be back!“

“A perfect Weekend date night consists of Sandwiches and cheese fries from Donkeys followed with a light refreshing Gelato from Leo's! A pleasant cash only little icecream parlor with a lovely variety of flavors and types (i.e gelato, hand dipped, and soft serve) 10/10 recommend for the summer ahead!“

“What a great spot! My kids and I love Brainfreeze! They always have the flavors we love in stock and we never have to wait long. Not only is the staff super friendly but they work fast and efficiently. I highly recommend the moosetracks, açaí bowls and OMG the vanilla soft serve!“

“First time here! Lots of choices. They go by the size of the cup not scoops. We had salted caramel pretzel and cappuccino crunch. With added caramel topping the 2 came up to $17.50. It was very tasty. Portion wise- good- value for the dollar? It’s a locally owned small business that has been there for decades. I felt the value was there to treat yourself to some homemade ice cream! Sure could have gone to shoprite and got 3 1/2 gallons of ice cream and a bottle of caramel but you know it’s not the same. I would come back. So should you. ?“

“We had done a pickup order that was found to be incorrect when I made it home. I called, the manager made it right immediately, brought a new order to me along with some extra treats. It was beyond what they needed to do. The food has been delicious since they opened, and we will continue to be loyal Customers. Thank you for making the extra effort, it is appreciated.“

“Have been coming here for over 20 years and the white chocolate mousse is my absolute favorite I recently moved but my family is still in the area and I visit often this past time my dad gave me two quarts of white chocolate mousse to take home !! Almost done one! Love this place ?“

“This place is like going in a time machine back to a 50s ice cream stand. They even play 50s music over the loud speaker. The cones are big, like dairy lightsabers you could use to fight a lactose intolerant Darth Vader. I probably shouldn't eat so much sugar now that I'm over 50, but it's so good.“

“Children ordered the shark gelati which is the summer's feature gelati. It's a mix of watermelon, dragonfruit and vanilla flavors with vanilla custard and it tastes really good! They were out the shark gummies which was a bummer but the associate asked my kids if they would like gummy bears as a substitute and this was ok with them. My kids ate the entire thing! I had a chocolate custard cone with chocolate jimmies and ended up sharing my dessert with my kids as well! We all enjoyed our trip to Rita's.“

“All Ritas are not the same. This one in Evesham is our fave. Why? Because they have SO many flavors of custard! Nothing wrong with a chocolate vanilla twist - but they have COFFEE custard! With hot fudge! And orange cream, strawberry, banana, cheesecake, peanut butter, peach, cake batter…. Also it has a nice summer vacay vibe with lots of seating and fun music.“

“We tried Daddy O's tonight for the first time tonight since we had a craving for ice cream. The store has froyo, hard ice cream, soft serve, and water ice. I had an Oreo sundae and my fiancé had a vanilla soft serve with sprinkles. I found it odd that the sundae was not mixed and the toppings and sauce were at the bottom and they put soft serve on top. It was very tasty and they gave you a ton of ice cream. The service was very quick and the employees were friendly! We would come back again soon to get ice cream here again!“