50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Milltown

“Been going there since the re-opening and everything we have had has been great, the staff and owners are great people If you haven't tried this place it's definitely worth the trip (I think it's better than Mancini's Pizza)“

“Only stopped in because we saw the 2 slice deal with a can of soda about a year ago…that was a great decision! We have also taken advantage of the 2 pies for $24 Sunday-Thursday. Now we are working our way through the menu. Definitely glad we stopped by that day for the 2 slice deal 👍🏻. Rice ball with ricotta, chicken fingers, garlic knot crust pizza - ALL EXCELLENT! The fries were fries, not bad but not what you go there for. If you haven’t tried them yet - do it. I can’t speak for delivery because we aren’t from Milltown and I don’t know how far they go, but while picking up our food we always see several guys running orders out so I’m guessing people don’t have to wait terribly long with that many delivery folks. 10/10 definitely recommend!“

“Absolutely the best pizza around! On top of that, the staff is incredibly kind and welcoming, making every visit a great experience. If you haven’t tried this place yet, you’re seriously missing out. Highly recommend!“

“Excellent food, the owner and staff are extremely friendly! Dusal's is my favorite Italian restaurant!“

“Absolutely outstanding location! I cannot say enough about the quality of service, presentation and preparation.

The order is usually always right and on the rare occasion where something might be amiss, It is taken care of directly.

There are other stores in the area that would do well to come over here and learn how to operate a Dominos.“

“Nice ambience, good menu and great pizza place.“

“Usually pick up pizza to go never disappointed in the quality and service.“

“Homemade pasta and wood fired pizza.“

“Passing by the area and came across this pizza place was a little sceptical about the place was pleasantly surprised. Ordered the chicken keema pizza and panner tikka and chicken 65 food and Limca( Indian soda) highly recommended with pizza. Everything was fresh and very flavorful definitely coming back here when I’m in the area.“

“Stopped in prior to going to a basketball game at St Thomas Aquinas. The pizza was delicious and the owner brought out a free sampling or his penne all vodka. This will be our new go to spot for eat ins and pick ups.“

“Best pizza 😊 really friendly nice place“

“Excellent pizza 🍕 and a abundance of choices to select from - new to the neighborhood and I think we found our new pizzeria“

“At Luca’s Pizza we just ordered a large cheese pizza to go. It’s amazing! Definitely the best pizza in the middlesex/Piscataway away. Lots of other places we tried just had average so-so pizza but this place is so good the pizza is so cheesy!! Prices were good too. Definitely try this hidden gem!! We only had once slice left to image cuz we ate the whole pie whoops“

“Fantastic customer service. Took great care to ensure we would be safe despite food allergies.“

“hi everyone yes I stopped by Kings Pizza many of times they have a good service they're super clean friendly people they always ready to figure out what exactly you wanted to order very good place I completely recommend it“

“The most amazing pizza and Italian dishes you will ever eat! Super fresh and always delicious! The owners are the sweetest and truly make you feel special every time you visit. We’ve been customers since they were located in the Meyers parking lot, however, we’ve moved in the last few years and are unable to get our fix of Bella La Pizzeria greatness since. We travel over 3 hours for the best pizza and meals because the food is that delicious! I’m sitting here in heaven this evening enjoying a slice of their perfect pizza. Yummmm!!!…….“

“Best pizza around, delivery is always FAST, kids love the food. Never had any issues and they are always friendly.“

“It was Saturday evening the 11 of March . We ordered on line and went to pick it and they didn't get the order right away. They took care of the problem right away, got right on it and delivered it to our Condo. The food was hot and excellent. We will be back. I Highly Recommend Villa Borghese ll.“

“Winner of multiple awards when it comes to the best pizza in the area try it when you can you won’t be disappointed“

“We were traveling from NC and stopped at this fabulous location. The food was hot and fresh!! Everyone was so warm and kind. We definitely recommend!! We ordered the spaghetti & meatballs, pizza, and a sub!! So much food and delicious!!“

“Ciccio‘s has the best pizza in town. They have a great Tasting sauce on their pizza! Everything we have ever ordered here has Never disappointment.“

“I have been a customer for over a decade. Maybe even two. Unpretentious place with outstanding food. They sneak in some great individual twists on various dishes while serving the usual hits.
I mostly get take out but have eaten in as well with great enjoyment.

Vegetarian options: Plenty of vegetarian options“

“The BEST pizza we’ve ever had!!!! The crust is perfectly crispy. They put a good amount of cheese and the pepperoni is amazing!! My fiancé and I have lived in Raritan for 3 years, and have been trying to find a good pizza place. We finally stumbled upon this hidden 💎 gem!! Highly recommended best pizza in the area, no comparison!! 🍕 😄“

“Best pizza in New Jersey! I’m honestly surprised Dave Portnoy hasn’t come to rate this place a 10. Their pizza is incredibly crispy, and the ingredients are simple but high quality. They’re always making different pies throughout the day, so there’s always something fresh and delicious coming out.

The customer service is impeccable. I’m not from New Jersey, but every time I walk in, they treat me like family. They also have a great lunch special—two slices of any kind. I usually go for the vodka cheese and a pepperoni slice, and it never disappoints. Oh, and you have to try the sugar-free cream soda—it’s so good!

100/10 would recommend!“

“I was searching online for good Italian to send to my family who were gathering for lunch before my favorite Aunt Harriets funeral. Trying to do this as a surprise for my family, I was calling from Colorado not knowing true reputations. I not only found good Italian, I found fantastic and authentic! Sal's genuine care for my phone order was beyond words. I ordered trays of eggplant rollatini, chicken parmesan, lasagna, fresh vegetables and garlic knots which was fresh, hot and delivered on time. Can't say THANK YOU enough for helping me feel present with my family when I couldn't actually be present. Someday during my travels back east, I'll find my way there and experience your cooking first hand. Thanks again Sal and keep doing (ministering in a way) what your doing. Diann R. Longmont, CO“

“Tried Carlo’s for the first time and got a 1/2 grandma 1/2 grandpa pie…..delicious!!!! So tasty!!! It also smelled amazing on the drive home. Got the sautéed broccoli which was also really good….loaded with flavor. Can’t wait to go back again!“

“Me and my co-workers have been coming here for a couple years, about once or twice a week. We've never had a bad meal, everything tastes fresh and delicious. Everything from their pasta dishes, pizza, freshly made salads and sandwiches are amazing. All of the food is fairly priced and its very convenient. These guys go above and beyond to satisfy their customers, keep up the amazing work.“

“Nice Server very Kind and delicious Pizza love it 😋“

“Have loved Franks for years!“

“Excellent food and service!! They catered my daughter’s graduation party and the food was excellent. We are Sicilian and the food was on the money. Rating: 10++“

“Found this place accidentally while we were in the area. Food is very fresh and tasty. Excellent personal service. We loved. all the items we ate. Special call out for the French Fries, it tasted very fresh without the taste of oil in the mouth. The Paneer tikka pizza was very good and non-greasy.

Vegetarian options: Options without onion and garlic available.“

“Perfect! Delicious and highly recommend! So glad we found our new pizza place in town 😁“

“Loved this place since I was a kid“

“We finally got around to trying this local eatery and were not disappointed. The service and the pizza were excellent. We chose outside seating, so unfortunately we had to endure a couple of noisy begging dogs someone chose to bring to dinner on the sidewalk. 😩 They were not service dogs and they were not particularly well behaved, constantly whining for food and blocking the sidewalk so people had to trip over them or step into the middle of the street to walk around them. But the establishment, the food, service and employees were great. Next time we will go inside if the outside is overrun with inconsiderate dog owners.“

“We had a great time at Avellino’s today! They have great food and great service. I highly recommend this place!!“

“We tried Lubrano's for the first time tonight and it won't be our last. Can't believe it took us this long to find this place, we've lived in the Piscataway/Somerset area for years. The famous thin crust Margherita pizza and one of the best (and largest) antipasto salads, absolutely delicious.“

“Beautiful inside. The woodwork is fantastic and the painted clouds on the ceiling are. Cool.“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Our Place Pizzeria in Edison, and I can't recommend it enough! From the moment I walked in, the warm and welcoming atmosphere made me feel right at home. The staff were friendly and attentive, ensuring that my experience was top-notch!! And the food was absolutely amazing, 100% recommend“

“7 Tower Covid-19. evening shift were truly happy and bless with a hot meal. Thank you!“

“Five years ago, the owner and I had a huge fight in the crazy pandemic. The truth is, they are the BEST pizzeria in town and, New Rochelle has good pizza! But they are the BEST, and I believe the LONGEST running pizza business. Much love to my community. It’s time to forgive and forget and GIVE BACK to our communities. 🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️“

“This place was not only amazing and tasted great. Quiet local stop but the GrubHub driver delivered the completely wrong order. After calling the restaurant they confirmed the driver grabbed the wrong order. I went and picked it up, the team there was so nice and accommodating I will definitely be ordering from here again and telling people. Its really good....!!!!“

“It is easy to shine when they get it right. The real test of a business is how they make it right when things go wrong. TJ's has amazing customer service to compliment their delicious food! We will definitely be ordering again! Thank you!“

“Best Pepperoni Pizza and Rigatoni Bolognese!“

“This spot is a hidden gem. I’ve been living in the area for about 15 years now and just randomly tried this place one day, and let me just say it not only exceeded my expectations but blew them out of the park. The food is absolutely delicious and the service is nothing short of simply the best. I would highkey recommend trying their freshly house made pizzas, they’re finger licking good as well as their pastas which are chefs kisses. I’m genuinely amazed at how not many people know about this restaurant. The owner is the sweetest woman I’ve ever met, we talked for 15 minutes just about her business it was 2 minutes before they closed and she offered me all of the left over pizza they hadn’t sold that day FOR FREE. I’ve found my new favorite go to Italian spot.“

“I don’t get what all the hype is all about. It’s definitely good pizza, the best in this area but they’re the priciest. The location absolutely sucks. Parking is even worse. With all the money that place makes ud think they’d get a better location.
I came to eat w my 5 year old during dinner time and we ended up going somewhere else cause there wasn’t any tables.
The guys working are kinda hot tho :)“

“Great pizza! Time to get El Presidente there to do a review!“

“Make no mistake, this is 5-star pizza. Get a few “personal” pizzas for variety: a cheese, a white, and maybe a mushroom or pepperoni - well done. Absolutely the best in Somerset area. If you stop there for lunch, their slices are quite big, you only need 1. And the chicken fingers are a MUST. We just love Amici’s. I recommend calling them directly and pick up, or ask for delivery. The owners are just great people. ?“

“We had lunch at the new restaurant in Highland Park. We had the falafel plate which had great flavor and was very filling. My sister had a slice of pizza which she said was really good. The new place is a vast improvement over the old store in East Brunswick.“

“I don’t know what kind of deal John made with the pizza gods, but Pizza Heaven lives up to the name. This place doesn’t just serve pizza—it serves joy in a box. The crust? Perfect. The cheese? Melts like a dream. The sauce? I’d drink it if that wasn’t weird (okay, maybe just a sip).

And then there’s John—the legend himself. He’s like the unofficial mayor of deliciousness. Super friendly, always makes you feel welcome, and you can tell he genuinely cares about every pie that leaves his oven. It’s rare to find that kind of passion these days.

Honestly, if you haven’t been to Pizza Heaven yet, what are you even doing with your life? Go. Eat. Thank me later.“

“Came here for the first time this past Saturday with a few friends. Friendly and quick service. The pizzas were good! We got meatball, margarita, plain cheese and cheese with spinach. Dessert was good as well (Cannoli's and New York Cheesecake). Would definitely come back.

Inside is rather small though. I'm sure it gets packed all the time being right across from the mall. When I got there, it was fairly empty at around 6PM. By 7, it was already packed. Reservations highly recommended!“