Surreal Creamery

$$ • Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream, Frozen Yogurt

8 Easton Ave, New Brunswick
(646) 389-8867


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Surreal Creamery

Overrated - I got the earl tea ice cream and bubble tea. The bubble tea was completely flavorless. The bubbles are not coated with honey so they were bland. The ice cream was good, which is why the review is 2/5 instead of 1/5.The staff were very quick and nice, but I would not come back.

I would give it 5 stars but there's no place to eat inside or even on the side walk. By the time you find a table near the train station or a park bench, your stuff is melted.Otherwise, if you need some emotional support comfort dessert, this is your place.I got a flotea and the hubby and his friend got the mason jars. They really do look as beautiful (and taste even better) as the pics on their website.

The ice cream was so delicious I could see myself going there at least once a week. Funny thing is I hate ice cream, my husband made me try it and I loved it. Recommendation: the ice cream mason jar with the lucky charms ice cream in it and the chocolate on chocolate on chocolate mason jar one. I completely forgot what they are both called.

More Reviews(149)


Monday 12 - 11PM
Tuesday 12 - 11PM
Wednesday 12 - 11PM
Thursday 12 - 11PM
Friday 12PM - 12AM
Saturday 12PM - 12AM
Sunday 12PM - 12AM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.