50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Milford

“We engaged Roman to cater our Christmas Eve gathering, and the experience exceeded our expectations in every respect. The food was delivered promptly at the scheduled time, the portions were generous and well-balanced, and every dish was exceptionally well received by our guests. The selections—including Penne alla Vodka, Chicken Francese, Eggplant Parmigiana, and a fresh salad—were prepared to a high standard and demonstrated excellent quality. The pricing was very reasonable given the caliber of the cuisine. We would highly recommend Roman’s catering services.“

“A huge THANK YOU to Ken and everyone at Soprano's in NM for helping make our NMHS 40th reunion a success. Ken took his time to help me plan a menu, order, and execute a hot and cold buffet for over 60 people. The food came precisely when promised, piping hot, and everything was delicious. (All on a very busy Saturday Night might I add!). I will certainly be calling them again for my next catering as well as take-out dinner!“

“The Holiday Buffet was excellent. Everything was cooked to perfection and was so plentiful. Would definitely recommend Big Jim’s food. He gets 5 stars from me and my family.“

“Margarita Pizza was delicious. Will definitely be back to try some more adventurous styles.“

“Came to the restaurant with a nice greeting and straight to giving me the best pizza. Thankfully getting a pizza here doesn’t take that long and very understanding when we changed our mind to dine in. Pizza was really fresh and delicious, all of us had a amazing time eating. Can’t wait to come here again!“

“Loved this place! So good, very authentic“

“Great news! My go-to dinner spot now serves brunch and it's incredible! The pancakes are insanely good. The breakfast pizzas are spectacular: I can't decide which one I like better, the potato and egg or the smoked salmon with the everything bagel seasoning on the crust. Mouth is watering as I write this review. Do yourself a favor and go eat at Super Nice!“

“I’ve been looking for a Neapolitan pizza place for a bit and I just happened to see one in my own neighborhood! The pizza was incredible. The dough was perfect and the toppings complemented eachother really well. Staff was so warm and welcoming. It’s a cute little spot and feels cozy and comfortable inside. Will be coming back! Also always a bonus when the staff is respectful of my service dog!“

“With all the competition Johnny's faces in Mahwah, Ramsey, Allendale, and Suffern they have clearly shown from opening day to the present why they are the top choice. Every aspect of a business a customer would want they excel (product, cleanliness, customer service, and menu options). Besides a superlative slice of pizza their Sicilian is larger than others without being burnt on top (commonly found elsewhere), and their version of the Deep Dish slice is tremendous. If you want to dine in, take out, or not leave the comfort of your home and have the food delivered, they are the Must Go To spot in the area.“

“Really good food but please consider using real ham on the pizzas 🙏🏼 and not the mushy cubed stuff 😭 everything else is so good but this ham substitute stuff is always disappointing.“

“The best pizza in Bergen County!“

“Thank you for doing the right thing!“

“12/10!!! Great place! Awesome family owned restaurant and the pizza was amazing!! From Buffalo Ny!! We’ll be back !“

“Once again, Corleone’s doesn’t disappoint! Eggplant Parmesan hero! 5 Stars ⭐️… Love this place!“

“Seriously just had the BEST pizza I have tasted since Italian villa closed down!!!!! IF YOU ARE LOOKING FOR SOME GOOD PIZZA this is the spot! Such amazing and friendly people & amazing prices PLEASEEEEEE Give them a try . My new favorite spot !! You guys rock 😬😍“

“Rosario and his staff are the best! Consistently great food and service!! Always smile , a joke and a great meal!! Maywood needed this place!!!“

“Quinoa Salad with chicken so good. The place is clean, the service is friendly. I will be back to try more items off the menu“

“Always delicious pizza and the sauce is amazing. I usually order the personal round and personal square enough for my family. Love the Dad n Son great people and always have amazing conversations. I highly recommend this place. My cousins a professional Italian Chef making his own and he loves the pizza there.“

“Order of 40 Pizzas was delivered on time, hot and delicious. Highly recommend!“

“Perfect crust. Perfect pie. Sauce just right!“

“The best pizza and friendliest staff!!!“

“This place is like no other. Lovely owners and the most delicious authentic Italian food. Wow!“

“Best experience ever while visiting from canada best pizza ever“

“I placed an order with Frankie’s today, and they were a little backed up because of all the orders they had. The management team was very accommodating and apologetic when my food came out late. I truly appreciate their professionalism and hospitality. The food was amazing, and I’ll definitely be back. Thank you for the great service!“

“If you are looking for GOOD NY style pizza, you need to try Nonno's. There are many pizzerias in the Clifton / Nutley area, but in my opinion the pizza here is one of the best I have had. Sauce is favourable. Cheese is good quality unlike some places where they fall off the moment you pick up the slice. Service is super friendly and accommodating. It's a small place with a feeling of a neighbourhood-go-to pizzeria“

“Classic spot with hard working prideful staff and very good pizza—just remember to bring cash. Conveniently located right off the highway, with outdoor seating that’s perfect when the weather’s nice.
At first glance, the place might look a little run-down, but that’s part of its charm. Once you step inside, you can feel the history, and it carries a kind of legendary aura that takes you back in time to better days.“

“First time ordering. Food was amazing! We ordered fried calamari, penne vodka, chicken cutlet and NY strip steak. It came with salad and bread. Everything was delicious! Definitely will be ordering again!“

“Food was great, only thing I would mention is regarding delivery. We requested it be left at the door cause we were running late from daycare. We don’t think that note made it to the delivery driver. Food was great, delivered on time, maybe a little early.“

“The 🍅 sause is the 🔑 key Eggplant Mozz. Chicken Mozz Both the 💣“

“The request was find the best pizza near our hotel. After comparing some reviews we headed to Urban Tomato. It’s in a neighborhood setting across from a church. The restaurant decor is simple but comfortable with a great hosts. We never felt cramped. The boys enjoyed a chicken pizza half garlic and half bbq drizzle and my wife and I enjoyed a fungi white pizza that was out of this world. I continue to say this, if g-d had given Jersey the water, their pizza would be king.“

“My husband and I was craving some good authentic pizza and let me just say this place DID NOT disappoint. The owner and everyone that worked there was super nice which made me love it even more. I wanted my husband who’s from Baltimore to try zeppole, he’s never heard of it and for me, growing up in Bk and Staten Island it was one of my childhood favs. They didn’t have any made when I asked about it which was fine but while I was in conversation with their delivery driver the owner came out with some. He actually went out of his way to make me some zeppole, and it was delicious and extremely nostalgic for me. He has no idea how that made my day and brought back so many memories to me. Their food is delicious, atmosphere warm and friendly. I recommend this place and we will be back.“

“Got invited to a #yelp event. I said pizza. I’m in. This place is kind of hidden but well worth it. Many pizza slices available. Soon as you walked in and smell the greatness you are going to have. The had sandwiches as well. I decided to get the Popeye slice (spinach & ricotta) and a prosciutto slice. Oh my goodness was amazing!! They had about 10 flavors of gelato to pick from as well. I got a scoop of the pistachio & a scoop of fruity pebbles. I was told by the owners daughter who was at register (very polite & friendly) they make them in house. I had to drive little of 30 min to get there. If you’re in the area stop by or if you like me take a ride. You won’t be sorry. There’s a fountain outside where you or the kids can cool off. Very clean inside. Well maintained inside as well. Thank you again… decided to buy extra to bring home as well. @yelpnorthjersey #yelpnorthjersey SQ Pizza @yelpnewjersey @sq_pizza_co“

“im ivette rodriguez i know sal and his amazing one of a kind pizza,there best 100% garantee you be back for more .there original ,fresh made with love,not only his pizza his calzone patties sicillian,ices.so many things but most of all there clean enviorment.and the best part its a family place.full of love friendly and welcoming.can be all night saying all i experianced etc ...knowed them for 40 yests Greek up eating there and left to pr then orlando and never had one pizza like pugleys pizza.so much that i tell everyone in florida that goes to the bronx must make that stop and prove me wrong .hope one day they move to florida or im going back to the bronx just for there pizza 100% garantee.“

“Greatest Pizza on Earth!!“

“Had a 70th birthday party catered in December. Food was delicious. Everyone was talking about it, and were thrilled to take some home for the next day. And, they deliver!! Great good, great price. Highly recommend them for catering and eating at the restaurant itself.“

“This place gives off that run-down beat up pizza joint vibe, but it’s actually pretty solid. The pizza’s definitely way too greasy, but it's good. Prices for slices are overpriced but prices for pies are very fair. Being open late is a huge plus in this area. Far from the best pizza around, but it’s one of those spots you end up going back to anyway. sometimes the staff is in a great mood and helpful and sometimes they look cooked. You know what ur getting into when you walk in.“

“Dine-in section is classy with an “old” Italian charm. The food is fantastic! Classic Italian dishes like lasagna, wood fire pizzas and pastas.

Take-out section is cash only, your pizza is ready in 10 minutes. The pizza guys are super busy and working fast so just pay and pick up once your order is called. Have cash in hand. The pizza’s are delicious no doubt about that, classic NYC thin crust. Try the vodka pizza sauce with fresh mozzarella and prosciutto.“

“Good Pizza Great service Good Beer“

“My daughter and I came here on our way back home from American dream and we are so glad we did. The alfredo pasta with chicken was superb! Much better than I’ve had at other spots for 50% higher prices.

We also got the pizza with the three different sauces (marinara, pesto, and something else) and the pasta filled me up so we got it to go and had it the next day. I don’t know if the pizza tastes better when reheated the next day, or if it normally tastes like that, but the pizza was excellent. Not too thick, not too thin, just right! We’ll be making more trips after our mall runs 🤤“

“It’s great place with very delicious pasta and artesanal pizza! 🍝🍕“

“We recently tried Mario’s Pizza and Pasta and ordered a meat lovers pizza along with a beef empanada and a chorizo empanada.

The pizza was decent, there was a good amount of meat toppings, which we appreciated, but overall it didn’t really stand out or wow us. It was satisfying for sure, just not something we’d go out of our way for.

The empanadas, on the other hand, were excellent. They seemed to be Argentinian-style and were packed with flavor. Both the beef and chorizo were well-seasoned and delicious, and the sauce they came with really elevated them even more.

Overall, we’d come back to try a pizza with fewer toppings to see if that makes a difference and definitely for the empanadas!“

“We recently discovered this amazing pizza and baked goods spot while dining at its sister restaurant, Al Dente Pasta Co., next door. Luciano's is now my favorite pizza spot in the area! Their dough is amazing and it really stands out in the white pizza with sausage and their simply amazing garlic knots (served with lots of fresh garlic and high quality olive oil). We are hooked! The staff go above and beyond (they treated us to a fabulous homemade chocolate chip cookie on a recent order). Their catering menu looks wonderful. You can tell a lot of thought and care has been put into this business! Check them out and Al Dente too!!“

“This restaurant is a self serve, me and my kids always love this Italian restaurant, every time we go to Bergen Town center and in a mood for Italian food this place is out go to, it's been here since they opened this outlet store and the taste of their food is consistent, its price is reasonable and they taste fresh, the server is nice and they are fast and efficient, inside they have enough table and sitting area to enjoy the food they also have a bathroom for customers, considering it's a fast food style this Italian food is one of the best in this area and I recommend for everyone that goes in Bergen town to give it a try.“

“Great pizza, great service loved dinner !!“

“Went here for brunch for NYC Restaurant week and did not disappoint!! Great service, delicious food and yummy drinks!! Will definitely come back!! Such a cozy cute atmosphere too!!“

“I can across double pie pizza while looking for an alternative to the overpriced artisanal pizzerias in the neighborhood.

Their pizza is fantastic! Great fresh ingredients, a thin crust, easy to order and customize.

And they deliver to the 80s on the UWS!

Must try!“

“Drove an hour and a half to take my Mom to lunch, and we loved the food here! The service was outstanding too! Highly recommend this place!“

“My son has food allergies and as soon as we started inquiring about ingredients, the associate called for their designated allergy handler. Before we even got into his specific allergies, she wiped down the prep area, changed her gloves and showed us their allergy binder. She prepped everything right in front of us and chose ingredients from under the counter as to avoid cross contamination. Bravo, Jiya! When casually talking with the owner, he mentioned having friends with food allergies so he definitely understood the severity of being diligent with prep. We were so impressed by the process, we ate here twice on our trip. And yes - the pizza was quite delicious!“

“Huge slices! so good! delicious!! We ❤️🍕🫶🏼👍🏼“

“***** The best Caesar salad.“