50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Milford

“Food is always good Friendly place to go and spend time with family friends Always good service“

“The Holiday Buffet was excellent. Everything was cooked to perfection and was so plentiful. Would definitely recommend Big Jim’s food. He gets 5 stars from me and my family.“

“A huge THANK YOU to Ken and everyone at Soprano's in NM for helping make our NMHS 40th reunion a success. Ken took his time to help me plan a menu, order, and execute a hot and cold buffet for over 60 people. The food came precisely when promised, piping hot, and everything was delicious. (All on a very busy Saturday Night might I add!). I will certainly be calling them again for my next catering as well as take-out dinner!“

“Quinoa Salad with chicken so good. The place is clean, the service is friendly. I will be back to try more items off the menu“

“My family and I enjoy this place very much and the food is absolutely delicious. I always have a drunken grandma slice and they have the best mozzarella sticks. The sub Sandwiches are a reasonable price and size and the penne vodka is also a favorite dish!“

“I Sent my friend a Johnny's pizza for his 70th birthday last week. Unbeknownst to me, my friend was in the hospital during that time. I called Johnny's and advised them of this and they very graciously Sent a free pizza, celebrating my friends healthy return home. My old friend just finished the pizza, and shared it was delicious. Not only are Johnny's Pizzas Large, their kind Hearts are even Bigger! Bravo and God Bless, Mike C from North Carolina“

“Good Pizza Great service Good Beer“

“I’ve been looking for a Neapolitan pizza place for a bit and I just happened to see one in my own neighborhood! The pizza was incredible. The dough was perfect and the toppings complemented eachother really well. Staff was so warm and welcoming. It’s a cute little spot and feels cozy and comfortable inside. Will be coming back! Also always a bonus when the staff is respectful of my service dog!“

“I wish I had taken photos of my carry out order. Pizza Knight is a hidden gem and highly recommend to anyone wanting to try a different pizzeria that is not in their usual rotation. Staff was kind and prompt with my order, having my pie ready in 30 minutes. One thing I do want to point out is their chicken tenders. They had no right to be as amazing as they were. Highly recommended. Garlic knots were also on point. Just a great place with good food and will now be in my pizza rotation.“

“The best pizza in Bergen County!“

“Thank you for doing the right thing!“

“Quinoa Salad with chicken so good. The place is clean, the service is friendly. I will be back to try more items off the menu“

“12/10!!! Great place! Awesome family owned restaurant and the pizza was amazing!! From Buffalo Ny!! We’ll be back !“

“If you are looking for GOOD NY style pizza, you need to try Nonno's. There are many pizzerias in the Clifton / Nutley area, but in my opinion the pizza here is one of the best I have had. Sauce is favourable. Cheese is good quality unlike some places where they fall off the moment you pick up the slice. Service is super friendly and accommodating. It's a small place with a feeling of a neighbourhood-go-to pizzeria“

“I have gone there more than 3 times and they never fail to impress us! Their pizza and pastas are delicious and don’t get me started with the wings! Such friendly staff too. They are now offering breakfast which is a plus. My go to place from now on.“

“The food and Prestos are good, and the service is funny, but sometimes the service might be a little bit angry and so. The atmosphere is okay, I guess, but the tables are a little bit squashed. Also, the students special was a really good idea for Prestos. My son loves it. In all, I give 4.6 stars?.“

“Really delicious pizza. Great location with outside seating.“

“Loved this place! So good, very authentic“

“IBest in Bergen county, it’s basically based on a part of Italy the food is phenomenal“

“walked in with my friend to eat :) got greeted by an amazing staff who was incredibly patient while we were being indecisive lol! def will not be my last visit the vibes are right up my alley ;)

Vegetarian options: just dont get meat! LOL“

“Perfect crust. Perfect pie. Sauce just right!“

“Wow! Always wanted to try a Detroit style pizza and realized I could get one right here in the neighborhood. Holy crap, I've been missing out! Got the Roni bomb and it is freaking delish. My favorite part is the cheese crust but it's all terrific. Would definitely recommend!“

“We’ve been ordering now for a few months & everything is always so good & portions are awesome! You are our favorite spot! & we always appreciate the free surprise you send with our delivery weather it be a can of soda, dessert or salad! Super thoughtful! Thank you!“

“The request was find the best pizza near our hotel. After comparing some reviews we headed to Urban Tomato. It’s in a neighborhood setting across from a church. The restaurant decor is simple but comfortable with a great hosts. We never felt cramped. The boys enjoyed a chicken pizza half garlic and half bbq drizzle and my wife and I enjoyed a fungi white pizza that was out of this world. I continue to say this, if g-d had given Jersey the water, their pizza would be king.“

“Greatest Pizza on Earth!!“

“Heads up! These slices are huge enough to share. Enjoy! ✌️“

“Always delicious pizza and the sauce is amazing. I usually order the personal round and personal square enough for my family. Love the Dad n Son great people and always have amazing conversations. I highly recommend this place. My cousins a professional Italian Chef making his own and he loves the pizza there.“

“I am a frequent customer in this establishment even before it was pizza D’Amore , every time I come in it is nothing short of a good experience . I came in this afternoon at about 1:20 pm , Matt the gentleman who works in the front counter who also picks up the phone is always very friendly and welcoming ,his demeanor definitely makes you want to keep coming back to this restaurant, excellent customer service.“

“Food: coal oven pizza was thin and light weight. Ingredients good and perfect blend!
It's not my favorite style pizza but it's still very good!
Waiter explained that pizza is their specialty from coal oven so no calzones and typical pizza menu available. They do serve dishes.
Location and parking can be hard at times. Off street parking is limited and can be frustrating to find if you are dining in.
Restaurant is CASH ONLY!
Two doors to restaurant! One for dine in only which is menu items and whole pies. Other door is at counter and no seating available!
Atmosphere is old school pizza feel. Pics line walls of different guests who have visited.“

“A gem in the neighborhood. I never had a bad meal there. They are consitant with their food.“

“Food and service is great! Price is very affordable. One of the best meal I’ve had in a while. The only thing I thought was offensive was French fries and hot dog pizza (and of course my kids ordered it) which apparently a big hit in Italy according to the owner.“

“Pizzamore Italian Kitchen is exceptional. I’ve been a customer for years and have enjoyed food from the pizzeria as well as the catering cuisine and it never disappoints. The owner has created a very welcoming atmosphere where you’re made to feel like family. Absolutely authentic and delicious!“

“Went for dinner. We were greeted and seated promptly. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive, devoting just the right amount of time to us. We ordered cesear salad to start, seafood fra diavolo, and the butternut squash ravioli with broccoli rabe and shallots in brown butter. The salad was crisp and dressed nicely, with shaved Parmesan and croutons. But the highlight was the seafood fra diavolo. The seafood was so fresh, plentiful, and the heat was just right. The platter was full of seafood and all of it was delicious. The butternut squash ravioli was stuffed full of puree and simply melted in your mouth. The broccoli rabe was somewhat bitter, but the shallot and brown butter sauce balanced it out. Both entrees were a nice portion size. We ordered pizzepoles for dessert which came with Nutella and raspberry dipping sauce. They came in the traditional brown paper bag for shaking to distribute the powdered sugar and they were hot and fresh. The atmosphere is upbeat with plenty of seating in comfortable chairs or bench seating. Lighting is good and music is not too loud. We were pleasantly surprised by our bill at the end despite having waited a little longer for the check than we liked, but we thoroughly enjoyed our meal and will be back to try some of the delicious pizzas we saw come out of the oven. Highly recommend!“

“We absolutely love Corleone’s the staff is so friendly and amazing. We never have any problems and the food is absolutely delicious“

“Hi, just wanted to say. How great this place is. I ordered on Satuday. They forgot to add my 2 chicken empanadas to my pick up oder. I called and left a message but they were closed. I called on Monday spoke to Stepanie and she was very apologetic. She suggested i pick them up. Which I did. Long story short. They replaced it with 4 empanadas. Great customer service. Empanadas are delicious. Recommend highly..Many blessings for their business.. Will order again...“

“We had an amazing culinary experience here on Saturday. Everything we ate was beyond incredible and the service was excellent. We will be back soon! Thank you.“

“The request was find the best pizza near our hotel. After comparing some reviews we headed to Urban Tomato. It’s in a neighborhood setting across from a church. The restaurant decor is simple but comfortable with a great hosts. We never felt cramped. The boys enjoyed a chicken pizza half garlic and half bbq drizzle and my wife and I enjoyed a fungi white pizza that was out of this world. I continue to say this, if g-d had given Jersey the water, their pizza would be king.“

“The best pizza and friendliest staff!!!“

“I was driving from Boston to DC and was looking for a pizza/Italian place outside NYC. My son found this simply googling for such a place while I was driving. Stumbled on Amadeo and glad I did. We had their classic margarita pizza and loved it. The crust was firm but not too crunchy and the sauce was unique and delicious. They told me it is homemade and a family recipe. Really liked it! Even had some delicious pumpkin cheesecake on the road.“

“This place. Was amazing food was made to perfection. The staff was amazing and the price was perfect“

“OK, this place is hands down the best, BEST pizza. Especially their Sicilian pie. Omg, the bottom has the perfect crunch, and the sauce is delicious, full of flavor, and just the right amount of mozzarella!!!!! I drive from Oakland to pick up a pie and or some slices. They always have fresh pies ready to go!!!! The staff is always very kind and helpful, and the owner will have a chat with you while he makes amazing food. This place is legendry and so well worth the drive. Thank you for the amazing food and memories with family sharing a slice!“

“We haven't ordered pizza since Joe's closed in Kearny. So tonight we thought would try Ferazzoli in NA. We ordered through the app. After 1.5 hrs. still nothing, so we called Ferazzoli. They said that they never got our order. They were so apologetic and rushed the order down to us. They threw in some free stuff for our troubles. It was well worth the wait; the pizza was great and even the delivery guy apologized for the issue. We have nothing but praises for this place and we'll order again.....“

“I went on a date with my boyfriend to this restaurant tonight not expecting much and it turned out to be great. Great pizza, great appetizers and a fantastic atmosphere. We loved the place, we loved the staff and we will definitely be back and can't wait to try their house made pasta.“

“Excelente atención !!! y la comida muy rica, la pizza de jamón y morrones muy buena!!“

“ROMAN INN PIZZARIA 19 Hudson Ave Englewood NJ 07631 phone (201) 567-2654 PURCHASED the store NEXT DOOR expanded combined both into one performing a complete renovation overhaul. consisting of Indoor & outdoor Dining areas (4)New stainless steel Pizza ovens Tech-pay method that accepts all major ? credit cards , LEGIBLE takeout MENU ?LAST & NOT LEAST? A PLASTIC BAGS FOR YOUR CARRY OUT SO THAT YOURE FIRST 1st TO LEAK WHERE YOU EAT.!! ??????“

“Outstanding food n great owners“

“Ordered subs and we loved everything. We can’t wait to try the old Judge pizza!“

“Great food, great service, very welcoming!“

“Our server, Natalie was so nice and cheerful served us with a smile and the food was delicious. We have a margarita pizza to start and it was the best go on a pizza decide the best place I’ve ever had.! Portobello meals were delicious as well. I recommend this place to everybody! What?“

“Francesca Pizza and Pasta in Elmwood Park, NJ. Wow this pizza shop has some amazing pizza but make sure to check out their apps too! My favorites were the mozzarella sticks, eggplant rollatini but their MVP pie was 10/10! Super airy crust but held the three sauces (pesto, vodka and tomato) super well. Everyone who works here is super nice and they are so attentive! I loved this NJ
Pasta/ Pizza spot! Insta: @thehungrysw“