25 Best Italian Restaurants near North Cape May

“The food was delicious.I will make a point to come back next year!“

“Just bought some catering platters last night from Italian Affair! The chicken parm, and shrimp scampi were delicious, as were the salad, pasta, and homemade bread! There is plenty leftover for lunch today! Service and delivery were excellent, prompt, and friendly. We will definitely order again!! Thank you, I was able to enjoy my company instead of cooking!! Highly recommended!!“

“I haven’t been disappointed once! The staff is great. The food is awesome …especially the chicken, bacon, ranch pizza with a thin crust upon asking. Highly recommend!“

“I cannot say enough about this restaurant , great atmosphere, great food and very friendly staff. If you’re anywhere down the shore, it is a MUST try!“

“Our server Milos was incredible, great recommendations and the food was delicious and the atmosphere was great. Homemade gnocchi with shrimp and scallops on the side was to die for, will be back.“

“The vegetarian chicken parmigiana was out of this world and the bruschetta flat bread, perfection. We will be back.“

“Excellent service from Athena. Really good food. Still BYOB but now have Meadowcroft wines. Very nice wine very reasonably priced.“

“We had such amazing dinners and service! We loved our server, Amir’s , humor and service. Everything was delicious and our grandsons were happy; They were served so quick! Meals were fantastic!“

“Come in with a hug appetite. The Portion are huge and the food is delicious the service was outstanding. There are no reservations. If you pay cash you get a discount. We got the calamari for an Appetizer and we did taste of Italy which was 2 Raviolis, chicken parm, 1 meatball and Lasagna.“

“Everything we ordered was amazing! Fresh and delicious! 🥰“

“My husband and I come to Cape May every year for our anniversary we have our favorite places that we love to visit this was our first visit to Pacino's bistro and we went back the night after to pick up again!!! The food was phenomenal and the wait staff were very hard working and friendly!!! I am server myself and this not an easy job but they were excellent. The ambiance in restaurant made the experience that much better. Cannot say enough good things about this establishment!“

“Great food and service highly recommend“

“One of our favorite restaurants [Original] One of our favorite restaurants“

“Great food, great time, and great service! Shannon is an awesome hostess. Definitely will be coming back!“

“Always go when in Cape May…fabulous food“

“We visited Joey M's La Piazza this evening for the first time. We had the chicken parm w/spaghetti and the calamari w/white garlic sauce over spaghetti. Hot bread came out first, and both the entree's were excellent. Our waiter was friendly and attentive. The venue was adorned with many celebrity photos and had good Italian music playing in the background. We can recommend Joey's for a good dining experience.“

“fantastic food efficient service what more could you ask for“

“First time rating here at this BYOB and was pleasantly suprised with the quality of the food. We had Tortellini Alfredo and Lasagna for our main courses and the were both outstanding. We ate outside since the weather was so nice.
We will go back and try different mains next time.
Very affordable, especilly since they are a BYOB.“

“My daughter and I were really looking forward to having dinner there but were disappointed. Our reservation was handled poorly not to mention rudely. I indicated outdoor seating when I called, then also asked for outdoor seating when we arrived but were initially given an indoor table. I understand these things happen. But, the real disappointment was the lamb. One of the chops was so tough, my knife couldn't cut it nor could I chew it.“

“We had an amazing experience on our wedding day last weekend at Duffinetti’s. The owner was extremely accommodating and dedicated to making our day extra special. She allowed us to drop our wedding cake off prior to opening for storing, served an amazing meal for our large party, served our wedding cake and even arranged the performer to play our wedding song for our first dance. We couldn’t thank her and the staff enough for making our day amazing.“

“Love the Ravioli House! The food is fresh and delicious and the portions are good too. We had the garlic bread with cheese as an appetizer. My husband had the chicken marsala and I had mussels marinara. Both were delicious. We both also enjoyed a glass of sangria as well. They do have an assortment of desserts but we were too full for that! I did however go to the bakery in the back to get some treats for later. Our server was extremely pleasant and helpful.“

“I chose this restaurant for my husband’s birthday dinner. We had an amazing meal in a pretty setting. Aside from being extremely impressed with all of the flavors, from appetizer to dessert, our server, Ari (not sure I’m spelling it correctly) was just the sweetest, knowledgeable and kind young woman. She was very attentive but not annoyingly. There were other servers walking around making sure tables were cleared of finished apps, salads and such. They work as a team and made the experience so enjoyable. Everything flowed so smoothly. We enjoyed delicious cocktails and the food was so on point. We’re giving Santorini ALL the stars! We will most definitely be back, again and again!“

“Excellent pizza! I have been in cape may a lot this is the best pizza I have found! My family’s go to for pizza!“

“We have been going to Little Italy for at least 15 years. Food is fabulous atmosphere perfect staff warm and welcoming. never a bad meal. The host Michael always remembers who we are and we are treated like family. Highly recommend this establishment. five stars“

“Don’t let the off island location fool you, Mangia is a great spot!! Great food. Great service!! Highly recommended! I had the lasagna and it was awesome. Abby was our A+ server! Huge portions… we left with enough for lunch tomorrow! We’ll be back again!!“