10 Best Ice Cream Shops near Plumsted

“I remember when Tootsie had the diner in Cookstown next to the Getty station....was always great food with a fabulous smile on her face!“

“TKs is my favorite ice cream place. I also ride a motorcycle so they're the perfect bike meet spot. They're so accommodating and friendly.“

“This is our go to for bagels!! their desserts are great too but best bagels I've had! there's nothing like a little coffee, bagel and conversation in a small hometown shop with great people!“

“Drove over an hour to get cookiepus and fudge the whale! Order on the phone with Brooke she was so friendly and helpful and Jade helped me out when picking up she was also very friendly and helpful and a pleasure to talk to! Highly recommend this carvel ! Worth the drive!!“

“Best Ice Cream in Central NJ in my opinion. Well worth the stop.“

“Love Rita’s different flavors everyday during the summer! Quart stock up for winter is great!“

“K & B Bagels is a hidden gem in Browns Mills. You can tell the owner takes pride in everything she does. The inside looks amazing. It is always so clean. The employees are always so sweet and the food is spectacular! The new Açaí bowls are fantastic and I love their new boba teas! I try a different one each time I go. The new ice cream addition was a great finishing touch to an already amazing establishment. The outside patio is beautiful and spacious. My food is always fresh and is ready quickly even though they always seem so busy. I wish I could give more than 5 stars because this place goes above and beyond!“

“My pop and I stop thru on my way home from work daily (except the past week or two when he went on an Alaskan cruise) and we typically get a cone each. I'm known for both by sarcastic personality and straight forward nature, and extremely outspoken. I get these traits from him. I think he ruffled a few feathers one of the first times we went in bc it seems one woman tends to short him with the amount of custard on his cone. No big deal, I know, but I think he's getting fed up, and if he speaks up, he will make her cry. Other than that, I dig the place. Just the other day I went solo and got a Blizzard (the new caramel fudge one) and the young girl was sure to flip it before giving it to me.“

“We just went here to try and the service was excellent as well as the delicious ice cream served! Very creamy, not super sweet, just very balanced. Highly recommend you go try for yourself!“

“My Mom & I bought a cup of Mint Chip Ice! The cashier lady was super friendly & polite! I was happy that she gave me a sample of Mint Chip to try first! � I have always loved Rita's because they have awesome flavors & a great staff!“