30 Best Ice Cream Shops near Lakehurst

“Absolutely love Mrs. Walker’s Ice Cream Parlor in the Lakehurst area of New Jersey. The ice cream is incredibly delicious and surprisingly filling, with rich flavors that hit the spot every time. We’ve actually gone two days in a row because it’s just that good. The staff is friendly and the seating is very accommodating both inside and outside. Whether you’re looking to cool off or just treat yourself, this place is a must-visit. It’s got a great local vibe and you can tell they care about making the experience enjoyable for everyone. Can’t wait to go back again.“

“How are these ratings not a solid 5 star? best ice cream, anywhere.“

“I make ice cream at home. I’ve tried hundreds of recipes. The chocolate ice cream at Mueller‘s creamery blew my mind. It was off the hook good! I am now making it my official birthday gift to friends and relatives. Everything’s made from scratch, what do you expect but greatness.“

“Best ice cream flavors and assortment of items!“

“Such a warm and inviting shop! In addition to great food and pastries, it's full of handcrafted treasures. It's a lovely place to stop in for a snack and a coffee and a bit of shopping. Highly recommended!!!“

“Avery & Jay’s Handcrafted Ice Cream in Liberty Commons is basically a mitzvah and a nisayon in one place. You walk in “just to look,” and two minutes later you’re holding a towering sundae like you just got a shtikel nachas from Shamayim.
First of all, the place is mamash classy—clean, bright, and everything looks fresh and made b’kavod. You can tell they take the “handcrafted” part seriously, not just a nice word they put on the sign. The ice cream is smooth, rich, and legit “wow” from the first bite. And if you’re into Italian ice / soft serve / sundaes / waffles—they’ve got the whole sugya, with plenty of options to make you rethink your entire diet plan.
Now here’s the best part: you start simple—“one scoop, a regular cup.” Then you see toppings. Then you see the sundaes. Then your yetzer hara puts on a bekishe and starts giving you svaros:
“Take whipped cream—It’s basically air.”
“Sprinkles? That’s just simcha.”
“Waffle cone? That’s a kli, not a ta’ava.” 😄
And the staff? Sweet, patient, and helpful, even when you’re standing there like you’re choosing a shidduch: “Is this one more creamy? How’s this one? What’s the difference between these two?” They don’t rush you—very menschlich.
Perfect stop after errands in Liberty Commons, a family outing, or when you just need a quick pick-me-up that turns into a full-on “okay, we’re celebrating something now” moment.
Bottom line: If you’re anywhere near Jackson, do yourself a favor and go. Just don’t tell yourself “I’m only getting a small.” That’s not how this place works. 😉“

“2 hot dogs and a drink $5.85 Enough said“

“my four year old says " This has the best ice cream EVER" ALWAYS clean and greeted.“

“Had an excellent experience here! The service was super fast, even with a crowd, and the place itself is huge with plenty of seating—perfect whether you're coming with family or friends. The design is really unique and gives off a cozy, welcoming vibe.
They also have an incredible selection of ice cream with so many delicious options to choose from. Everything was fresh and tasted amazing. On top of that, the store was spotless—clearly very well maintained.
Definitely a spot I’d come back to again and again! 🍦“

“Special thanks to Kelly for being kind with a good heart so my nephew could have a positive experience. He enjoyed sampling a few flavors before deciding on Cookies and Cream with brownie pieces. She took the time to deliver excellent customer service with a smile.“

“Great place, I especially like the coffee coladas, but everything there is good best ice cream in lakewood for cheap. Shout out to hermenez“

“Yismach Yisroel is the kind of ice cream shop that makes you feel like you’re five years old again — in a good way, not the tantrum kind.

If you’ve ever needed a foolproof way to bribe—ahem—encourage your kids to behave in Westgate, this is the place. One mention of “Maybe we’ll stop by Yismach Yisroel…” and suddenly everyone is holding hands and saying Tehillim.

The store is bright, cheerful, and stocked like a dream:
• Ice creams, toppings, slushies — basically everything your kids will ask for before you even finish reading the menu.
• Tons of little toys and prizes on full display, expertly positioned at perfect “Tatty can we pleeeeease? 😇” height.
• Clean tables, quick service, and a staff that actually seems happy to help, which already puts them above half the places in town.

The portions are generous (Lakewood style — “small” means “don’t let it fall over”), the flavors hit the spot, and the whole vibe is just… geshmak. Great for families, great for bochurim looking to cool down after night seder, and great for parents who need five minutes of quiet while the kids focus on their soft serve like it’s a life mission.

Westgate parking can sometimes be a matzav, but once you’re inside, it’s all smooth sailing — just smiles, sprinkles, and a sugar rush waiting to happen.

Bottom line:
If happiness came in a cup, it would look exactly like the ice cream at Yismach Yisroel. A top-tier Lakewood treat and a solid 5-star stop.“

“Great Italian ice!! Love getting them for dessert L’kavod shabbos Kodesh!! Vanilla, cotton candy, and blue raspberry are my favorite as of today!! Gotta try them all though! I remember when the sample spoon was bigger but now we got shrinkflation!! And seriously?? They charge for empty cups?? Give me a break!! But hey, the staff were very nice and the food was great so they’ve got me as a customer!!“

“My Mom & I bought a cup of Mint Chip Ice! The cashier lady was super friendly & polite! I was happy that she gave me a sample of Mint Chip to try first! � I have always loved Rita's because they have awesome flavors & a great staff!“

“Thank you Rita’s for the great service and the ice for Central Regional Band.“

“They only had one guy behind the counter, but he was flying, as fast as 3 workers. Was pretty amazing to see. Could have been in a video of fastest workers on YouTube. This guy wasn't just fast.... HE WAS FAST! Oh. And they had a lady doing checkout.Don't know his name, but as long as this dude is there, you never really have to worry how long the line is as it'll only be a few minutes either way.“

“My kids & I luv the variety of tea drinks, shakes & wraps. We go there all the time since they’ve opened & never a complaint. The staff is awesome! Gina, Bella, Aggie & all of them are just great �“

“Sprinkles – Lakewood North: The Only Place Where You Come for Ice Cream and Leave Questioning Every Middah You Ever Thought You Had

Let me tell you, walking into Sprinkles after a long day is mamash like entering Gan Eden — if Gan Eden had neon signs, kids running around with sprinkle-covered faces, and bochurim debating which flavor is “yeshivish enough.”

I came in thinking I’d be normal and get a small cone. Cute idea. Adorable.
Two minutes in, I’m standing there like a lost sheep while the guy behind the counter goes, “Nu, so what are you getting?”
And suddenly I’m ordering a double scoop, extra toppings, full send, like I didn’t promise myself last Chol Hamoed I’d “cut down.”

THE ICE CREAM:
Next level.
Creamy, smooth, geshmak — the kind of ice cream where after the first bite you’re like, “Okay, maybe the world is a good place.”
The flavors slap. The toppings are fresh. The presentation is so nice it almost makes you feel guilty eating it. Almost.

THE VIBE:
Peak Lakewood energy.
Mothers with strollers, bochurim pretending they’re only here because “the chevra wanted,” and that one guy who definitely came for a shake but is pretending to browse like he’s making life decisions.

It’s loud, it’s lively, it’s lebedig — mamash a taste of Klal Yisroel coming together for one purpose: frozen sugar and happiness.

THE SERVICE:
Quick, friendly, and zero judgment when I changed my order three times.
“Can I get a chocolate shake? No wait, vanilla. Actually, do you have mocha? No? Okay fine, chocolate again.”
They handled it like pros.
Not once did they give me the classic “bochur please” look. Respect.

PERSONAL MOMENT:
I took my first sip of the shake and immediately understood why people come here even in the middle of winter wrapped in a coat like it’s Antarctica.
It hits the spot, fills the neshamah, and for a solid 6 minutes you forget about life responsibilities like laundry, rent, or that you still haven’t called your mother back.

OVERALL:
If you’re in Lakewood and in the mood for something cold, sweet, and spiritually uplifting, Sprinkles North is a MUST.
It’s fun, it’s fast, it’s fresh, and it’s the perfect place to reward yourself for absolutely anything — finishing a seder, surviving a siyum, or just because “why not?”

Highly recommend.
Just don’t meditate on how many calories are in that shake. That’s bittul simcha.“

“Great staff and very clean! I take my kids there every time I go in the area. Beth and Dan are the owners that frequent the store and they are awesome to talk to and they are great with the kids!“

“My Mom & I bought a cup of Mint Chip Ice! The cashier lady was super friendly & polite! I was happy that she gave me a sample of Mint Chip to try first! � I have always loved Rita's because they have awesome flavors & a great staff!“

“There are numerous ice cream stores in New Jersey.Coney Waffle is hands down the best my family has been to.The ice cream is delicious with an endless choice of flavors. So many different variations for cakes! Store very clean and staff is friendly.“

“The customer service in this place is beyond fantastic. They helped me out last week when I needed a print for a cake when the printer and Tom‘s River was down. And now today, I’m memorial day when I needed a cake last minute with no notice, The lady at the front desk,Jane,first hesitated saying they need some notice,and then said “sure I will do it.” They also came through for me last year when I was in a pinch. I would never go to any other ice cream franchise but these guys, Tom River and Manchester.“

“everything's good lunch or dinner“

“The BEST yougurt in the Toms River/Seaside Area!!!!!!!!!!!!! Don’t miss it!!!!“

“We went today for opening day. We ordered burgers, chicken tenders and fries. We loved it all!! The chicken tenders were super juicy. My husband said the burger was great. The fries had a nice crunch. Everything was super good and can’t wait to go back!“

“Great and delicious selection of ice cream, shakes, and pastries that offers something for everyone. The flavors are rich and satisfying, and everything tastes fresh and well-made. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop, a creamy shake, or a sweet pastry, it’s a perfect spot to treat yourself and enjoy a quality dessert experience.“

“outstanding ice cream. best I've had in years“

“you make! my favorite vanilla chocolate twist custard it's creamy and dreamy“