12 Best Italian Restaurants near Plumsted

Anthony's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
6 Jacobstown Rd, New Egypt

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and the Works Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
Pasta E Fagioli Soup
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Sicilian Pizza
Stuffed Shells
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread

“We came up from North Carolina to visit family and couldn’t wait to get some real New Jersey pizza — Anthony’s in New Egypt absolutely hit the spot. The pizza was amazing: crispy crust, perfect cheese, and that classic NJ flavor we’ve been missing. Great place, friendly staff, and awesome food. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town!“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
La Piazza Italian • $$
11 Church St, Allentown - 10.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Seafood Appetizer
Salmon Michaelangelo
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Hot Seafood Platter
Plain Cheese Pizza
Eggplant Rollatini
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Chicken Parm Boli
Chicken Fingers
Gnocchi Sorrento

“great family owned business with good food and interesting weekend specials“

4.7 Superb179 Reviews
Riccardo's Pizza & Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
567 Lakehurst Rd, Browns Mills - 7.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Broccoli and Cheese Tortellini
Browns Mills Tomato Pie
Browns Mill Tomato Pie
Poor Excuse for a Sub
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Philly Cheese Steak
Detroit-Style Pizza
Italian Pasta Combo
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Eggplant Rollatini

“Food was excellent! I’m a foodie, and have had seafood Alfredo at many places. This was by far De Best!!“

5 Superb547 Reviews
At Gio's Cafe Italian • $
29 Main St, New Egypt - 3.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken Parmesan Panini
Regular Crust Alfredo Pizza
Pan Alfredo Pizza
Cheesesteak Roll
Loca Taco Pizza
Nutella Pizza
Garlic Knots
Personal Pie
Caesar Salad
Baklava

“Today, I tried for the first time a spinach pizza made by Gio! It was incredibly delicious. I don't call myself an expert, but have had pizza over many years and in Italy. This was one of the tastiest and healthy pizza I ever had. Vince Sgro“

4.8 Superb87 Reviews
Pasquale's Naples Pizza and Pasta Italian • $
776 Monmouth Rd, Cream Ridge - 4.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grandma Pie - Marinara & Fresh Mozarella
Baked Ravioli w Meat Sauce
Seafood Combo Marinara
Sausage Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Veal Parmigiana
Vodka Rigatoni
Baked Rigatoni
Naples Pizza
Black Olives

“Just had their pizza for the first time this weekend and wow!! Amazing! 🤩 we went to Italian Villa for years but now they are closed and I am so happy to find another close place to get our pizza Highly recommended!“

4.6 Superb86 Reviews
Sorella's Trattoria Italian • $
1258 Yardville Allentown Rd, Allentown - 11.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
Special Cheese Steak MPO
Spaghetti w Meatballs
Chicken Parmesan
Vodka Rigatoni
French Fries
Garlic Bread
House Salad
Antipasto

“The food is incredible - highly recommend“

4.6 Superb49 Reviews
Via Roma 2 Italian • $
1280 Yardville Allentown Rd #4, Allentown - 10.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheesesteak with Peppers and Onions
Pepperoni Extra Cheese Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Gluten Free Stromboli
Gluten Free Calzone
Trenton Tomato Pie
Mac & Cheese Bites
Mozzarella Sticks
Lobster Ravioli
Cheesesteak Sub

“We ordered a tray of Chicken Parmigiana with vodka sauce for Christmas Eve dinner. It was absolutely amazing. We finished off with cannolis which were huge and so delicious! Romeo is the best, whatever you want, he will do!“

4.6 Superb47 Reviews
GianMarco's Pizza • $
504 Monmouth Rd, Millstone - 8.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baked Ziti with Meat Sauce
Pizza Style Cheesesteak
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Marsala
Margherita Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Chicken Parm

“The food here never fails to impress. It’s fresh, tasty, and expertly made. The staff are friendly, attentive, and work really hard to make your dining experience ( inside or takeout/delivery) an enjoyable one. We visit a couple of times a week!!“

4.6 Superb149 Reviews
Nonna’s Place Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$
108 Lacey Rd #17, Whiting - 8.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ricotta & Mozzarella Calzone
Nonna's Antipasto Salad
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Piccata
Pizza Margherita
Chicken Marsala
Pepperoni Pizza
Seafood Salad

“This place has THE BEST PIZZA in Jersey. It reminds me of the great pizza I used to eat growing up in Brooklyn. If you want great pizza this is the place to get it!“

3.9 Good145 Reviews
Ninuzzo Trattoria Italian • $$
409 County Rd 539, Cream Ridge - 4.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lemon Sorbet and Molten Lava Cake
Shrimp in Garlic Sauce
Cholate Molten Dessert
Eggplant Penne Pasta
Traditional Calamari
Pork Chop Giambottio
Paccheri Alla Mamma
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded Mozzarella
Chicken Francaise

“this is my third time catering from Ninuzzos and they never disappoint!! arrived on time and the food was delicious! everyone raved about all the food! love this restaurant!!!“

3.9 Good119 Reviews
Bella Napoli Pizza • $
441 Millstone Rd, Millstone - 9.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bella Napoli Millstone NJ
Pizza Carbonara
Pizza Margherita
Parmense Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cheese Pizza
Plain Slice
Cheese Steak
Vodka Sauce

“Went with friends after Six Flags closed for the night, and even as they were an hour from closing, the staff welcomed us in so warmly and the service was incredibly speedy! Portions were huge and affordable. If you’re going to Six Flags, or ever in the area, give this place a visit!“

4.7 Superb103 Reviews
12

Phil's

Phil's Italian • $
173 County Rd 526, Allentown - 9.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp and Broccoli Garlic and Oil
Pepper Jack Cheese Burger
Stuff Peppers over Rice
Chicken Focaccia Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Roll
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Quesadilla
California Chicken
Wings and Fries

“OMG. I tried Phil’s MULTIPLE times over the years and was so disappointed. My BF stopped on Thursday and brought me the most AMAZING PUPUSAS 🤤. And MAGICAL PLANTAIN EMPANADAS. I would have never tried it because I really didn’t like one thing any of the times I went before. I will DEFINITELY be going back. A LOT. This is a good and bad thing. Did I mention PUPUSAS??????!“

3.6 Good61 Reviews

You May Also Like