Pizza Restaurants near Short Hills

“Food was hot, service was on point. We enjoyed the app, our beverages, our meals and dessert. Always happy with the food.“

“I had a chance to visit Brooklyn Pizza in Short Hills today, and I really impressed! Im the Admin of Jersey Pizza Joints a public FB group, we know our Pizza and Jose and his team do it right. Highly Endorsed by Jersey Pizza Joints“

“As a known and admired brand, Eataly is first judged against itself and then other restaurants. At Eataly in Short Hills, the restaurant compares well, even if the size of the adjacent shopping area is a bit “short” relative to other locations, owing to its relatively smaller size.

The restaurant thankfully has plenty of space and space is what you need keep in your belly for a delectable Italian meal.

I’ve been to Italy many times and so that is my context, along from years of living in New York. That creates a high bar but I’m careful to give restaurants a fair shake.

To wit, I believe that Eataly provides the flavors and feels you want of an Italian restaurant. That is except for the bread, which you have to pay for – – probably the worst part of the experience for me.

I start with the Caesar salad, which is great except that it doesn’t taste like a Caesar salad. I can’t identify the ingredients all that much, but the leaves are soft and there is a dressing that is akin to a ceaser but not quite, and it has a crunch to it because of what seems to be breadcrumbs or something – – you think I’d know!

The pasta is fresh and seems to be al dente every time we visit. We enjoy the truffle pasta, but the truffle looks like tiny dots compared to the completely intact shavings thar ww get in Italy for half the price. Nevertheless, it’s delicious save for the excessive amount of butter. Just not necessary! Yet I’d get it again.

The sage Ravioli is as you would expect it to be and a delight. Also a tad too much butter, but still great.

You’ll want to try the Cannolo — It’s not a cannoli unless there’s more than one as Italian speakers would know. It is hearty and unusually flavored.

The staff is pleasant and attentive.

All in all in comparison to others in the chain, it may not be at the top, but still a delightful experience of Italian fare where you could then walk outside and pick up plenty of things straight from Italy Or is it Eataly?!“

“Omg it's been so long i haven't been here, but their pizza is the best and the all the foods that he has it's delicious especially the salads. I will recommend anybody to come here and sit down and eat a delicious pizza🍕🤗😉☺️“

“Best Gluten Free pizza you will find. Reminds Me of the days before I was diagnosed with Celiac, I will be back for more“

“The pizza and dessert were delicious and the service was even better. Highly recommend visiting if you are in the area!“

“We have been coming here for years! Love the service, the food and the ambiance ♥️“

“If you love good pizza and live in North Jersey, you have to check them out! The garlic knots are so good. I was sad to see the confetti cake go, but they suggested the cinnamon one — guess I've got my next visit planned! I ordered the garlic knot. It's the hugest l've ever seen. The pepperoni slice was so yummy.“

“I ordered half tray of mini arancini balls for Christmas appetizer and my guests and family loved them. it was so good, and even made them as requested without beef inside. we love their pizzas in the past. thank you PBP for great service and Quality.“