4.9
Superb
122 Reviews
2713 NJ-23 South, Newfoundland · 5.94 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
- Grilled Cheese Special
- Garlic Parmigiana Wings
- Pork Tostada Special
“We just discovered Big Mouth’s Deli & Catering, and honestly… how has this place been hiding in plain sight? This is not your average deli. The owners are right there, hands-on, making so much of the food themselves—from the sauces to the meats—and you can taste the difference. Everything feels fresh, intentional, and made with real pride. They also carry local honey and hot sauces, which just adds to that small-town, quality-first vibe that’s getting harder to find. It’s one of those spots you stumble upon and immediately want to tell people about—but also kind of want to keep to yourself. Great food, genuine people, and that rare feeling that you found something special. We’ll definitely be back… and next time we’re ordering more.”