22 Best Bakeries near Stone Harbor

“Call ahead and order the Key Lime Pie, it is insanely delicious. We always fly in from California to visit my in-laws in Avalon and celebrate my husband’s birthday. Poor guy hasn’t had a good birthday cake in almost 10 years so I decided to call on our way from the airport to order his birthday pie.

This key lime pie has the best graham cracker crust with the perfect texture, the filling is just the right amount of creamy lime deliciousness, not too sweet and not too sour. Topped with fresh whipped cream that perfectly balances out the sweetness of the pie. We loved it so much that I ordered a strawberry & blueberry pie to try before we fly home. Pretty sure this is going to be our new tradition when we come visit now :)“

“Love the Bread & Cheese Cupboard!! It’s a must visit, year after year. Thank you for being one of my favorite locations in Stone Harbor 🧡“

“We've been going to Britton's for years and have always been happy--until this year. I bought 4 mega cream donuts, which are usually stuffed with cream. This year my family didn't have cream in the donut until halfway through. The Boston Cream (regular filled) were more full than the mega cream. I think we will just stick to apple fritters. It's just disappointing because we've always looked forward to this treat but the quality this year is only on par with grocery store made donuts.“

“They make the absolute best gluten-free cupcakes.“

“Yummy donuts cakes and cookies“

“Great products friendly people thx Joel for ur help with disabled customers“

“WOW! Dawn is the sweetest! I bought a German butter cake from her table at the harvest festival at Cape May courthouse. It was delicious!! My friend bought a Apple pie and I have never tasted an apple pie so different and special!! Can't wait to try everything else ?! It was nice meeting you today,! Thank you!“

“The best sticky bun.....drop the mic.“

“best breakfast and service“

“Pretzels were great..will be visiting again soon!“

“Are first time very good now I can see why you are so busy will be planting on my social media and tell everyone to go n get breakfast there“

“The best sticky bun.....drop the mic.“

“The ice cream sandwich is good. I enjoyed picking my cookies and ice cream. However, they do not have as much ice cream as the pictures on their Facebook account or at the store. I'm hoping that is because they are training and it will get better. I will give them another chance. Margate“

“Fantastic breakfast or lunch. It’s quick & affordable. Super friendly staff. Sit out on the patio or grab a table inside. Fresh baked rolls for sandwiches. My favorite is the turkey, prosciutto, Swiss with avocado & garlic mayo. Good coffee with $1 refills. Grab some Cajun crab dip to bring home.“

“sooo delicious i love it here 😋😋“

“Was going to Rio Grande a cover for my store and stopped in the Super Walmart to grab lunch looking for a Subway. And was very happy to find one and attached that Subway happens to be an Auntie Anne's pretzels. So after I was done with my lunch I could not resist definitely have to get it Auntie Anne pretzel cuz everybody loves them. So we grabbed four of them and it was buy 3 get 1 free. These pretzels have gone up in price over the last few years but they're worth it. Yummy“

“Best cream donuts ever! All varieties of Donuts are excellent as well.“

“My Fiancé found this amazing bakery online, we are from Lancaster PA but will be getting married in Cape May and did not want to try and travel with a wedding cake and 2 golden retrievers 3hrs... the shop is clean, cute, and very inviting. we tried 2 cupcakes (which were AH-MAZING) but I knew I would be happy with their work after talking to the owner and her 2 sweet daughters. I can not wait to see her take on our cake. now to schedule our official tasting so we can try to pick flavors lol“

“Stopped in for the 1st time and coffee was extremely good, had a bagel sandwich and a donut and both wjere excellent. Service was great, fast and just 1 person working possibly the owner. Definitely recommend and definitely will be stopping back when in the area“

“Always amazing service and food! We ordered the Cranberry Pear Streusel Pie for Thanksgiving and it was the best pie we’ve ever had! You could taste ever single flavor and it was so refreshing!“

“Started going to Mrs. Brizzles about 7 years ago. The owner Mike & his wife are 2 of the nicest people you could ever meet. Not only are their sandwiches huge, so are their personalities. Our entire family have made it a point to get to Mrs. Brizzles while vacationing at the Jersey Shore. You will not be disappointed! Would give them 6 stars!“

“Great pretzels and service!“