11 Best Ice Cream Shops near Wantage

Cow Patty's Burgers • $
154 NJ-23, Wantage

Customers` Favorites

Pineapple Jalapeño Burger
Buffalo Blue Cheese Burger
BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger
Sweet Potato Fries
Monsterella Sticks
The Jersey Burger
Border Burger
Fried Pickles
Chili Burger
Jumbo Wings

“This place is delicious! Our server was kind and quick and gave us recommendations on the menu. The pickled chicken sandwich was perfection! Perfectly crispy, full of flavor, generous portion. The cheese steaks were also delicious. We didn't see cheese steaks on the menu photos on Google, but we called and asked because that's what we were searching for. They have a separate menu for cheese steaks and I forgot to take a photo to add to Google, hopefully they add one soon.

We also ordered milkshakes, and we appreciated that they used real strawberry ice cream in their shake instead of strawberry-flavored syrup.

The building is cute and seems freshly updated. I would come here again and again if it wasn't 2 hours away from me! Definitely a great stop on our trip.“

4.5 Superb137 Reviews
Dairy Swirl Ice Cream Shop • $
71 NJ-94, Vernon - 6.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rainbow Sherbert & Chocolate Chip Mint
Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cake
Chocolate Ice Cream Cakes
Cake Batter Ice Cream
Cannoli

““A Must-Visit Classic Creamery!”

We absolutely adore this classic creamery! From the moment we first passed by, we knew it was a spot we had to try, and when we finally did, it completely lived up to the hype. Every bite was pure joy, and we left wishing we had discovered it sooner!

The Rum Raisin, Black Forest Cake, Brownie Butter, and graham central station flavors are highly recommended—each one is rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. And don’t forget to add hot fudge and wet walnuts on top for that extra indulgence 🔥.

I only wish I lived closer so I could bring home quarts of this incredible ice cream. If you’re in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by—you won’t regret it!

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

4.8 Superb72 Reviews
Dairy Queen (Treat) Ice Cream Shop • $
260 NJ-94, Vernon - 7.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Pie Blizzard Treat
Caramel Fudge Cheesecake Blizzard Treat
Oreo Hot Cocoa Blizzard Treat
Mint Chip Blizzard Treat
Oreo Brownie Cupfection
Sundae Soft Serve
Soft Serve Cup
Banana Split
DQ Sandwich
Hot Fudge

“50 years of great service and great ice cream!“

4.5 Superb28 Reviews
The Dairy O, Inc. Ice Cream Shop • $
581 County Rd 62, Westtown - 9.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Apple Crisp

“So Many flavors all tasting delicious. Great service. Join the club and get a free ice cream.“

4.5 Superb26 Reviews
Gio's Bakery Gelato • $
32 Front St, Port Jervis - 8.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pumpkin Cheesecake
Portobello Panini
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Salmon Crepe
Tomato Soup
Cupcakes
Cookies
Doughnut

“they did an amazing job for my granddaughter's cake looked amazing and it was a rush job the staff and everyone that works there were so polite and helpful I would recommend them to ever needs or wants something out of the ordinary but yes the cake tasted so delicious too“

4.2 Good57 Reviews
Stewie's Family • $
701 Pennsylvania Ave, Matamoras - 8.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatloaf and Mashed Potatoes
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Thanksgiving on a Bun
Meat Lovers Omelette
French Dip Sandwich
Biscuits and Gravy
Reuben Sandwich
Breakfast Bowl
Hash and Eggs
Eggs Benedict

“Great service and food.“

4.6 Superb113 Reviews
Dairy Queen (Treat) Ice Cream Shop • $
247 NJ-23, Sussex - 4.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vanilla Soft Serve Dipped in Cotton Candy Shell

“The young ladies operating this DQ today were wonderful. This has always been a nicely run establishment- even when the line of cars stretches around the store and into the road. They are always kind, patient, and exemplify what it means to provide a good service. Today, I just felt they needed the recognition that I feel is deserved.“

3.4 Good26 Reviews
Ben's Fresh Hamburger • $
33 E Main St, Port Jervis - 9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Falafel Wrap and Fish and Chips
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
Chicken Tenders and Fries
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Benny Burger Combo
Fresh Cut Fries
Mushroom Burger
Belgian Burger
Chicken Wrap
Cheeseburger

“This place is a hidden gem. It looks like any run of the mill casual dining place, but the food says otherwise. There are menu staples which obviously are great, but the seasonal and daily specials are phenomenal. I have never been disappointed by anything I have ever ordered from Ben's Fresh. You can tell that the head chef actually really has passion for what he does by the dishes he comes up with, and that the food isn't made to fit some cost analysis- but to be delicious. They never skimp, one meal is probably enough for 2 average adults and pricing is reasonable for the quantity and quality of food you are getting. Honestly you are only gonna spend maybe 2-3$ more on a burger and fries than you would at McDonald's for a meal. The girls ( maybe there's boys too, I just always see the girls) are always friendly and seem to enjoy being there as well. It says a lot when your staff doesn't seem miserable. Also, just to conclude- icecream nachos. Get them. You will not regret it.

Logistically, large parking lot, with handicapped spots right by the door. Plenty of outdoor seating set back from the road in nice weather. Bathrooms are clean. Not a ton of seating inside but I have never not been able to find a table. Cool local art. You can call in your order ahead to pick it up. Check it out.“

4.3 Superb216 Reviews
Dairy Queen Fast Food • $
17 NJ-23, Montague - 7.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vanilla Soft Serve with Cherry Dip & Rainbow Sprinkles
Chicken Fingers
Ice Cream Cake
Birthday Cake
Hot Fudge

“It's a Dairy Queen so you know what you are getting. Felt that the service was good for the three visits I have made there in the last two months. Hot food was consistent and fresh. Milk shakes were what you would expect from them. I was able to play an arcade game while I waited for my food so that was cool. Place looked like it was clean. Freezer seemed stocked with an ample supply of DQ items.. I have nothing to complain about so a 5 star it is. If you like DQ this once is worth stopping at.“

4.2 Good49 Reviews
Cafe e Dolci Cafe • $
Recommended
270 NJ-23, Franklin - 9.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Strawberry Crêpe
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Edible Cookie Dough
Grilled Cheese
Nutella Crêpe
Avocado Toast
French Toast
Pesto Chicken
Macaroons
Croissant

“My wife loves this place so I gave it a shot. Ran into a classic customer service flaw at the get go and from there my experience was tainted. I ask for a large Americana which apparently is only small. I didn’t know that because my standard place gives me my Americano however I like and I usually get large 2 shots, they even let me modify the shots of espresso at my normal place. I asked for large and the staff had a very minor back and forth as to can it be done. One said sure why not and the other then said from the other side of the room NO, we don’t do that, one said why not, the other said “because we don’t do it that way”. That could have been handled better with the staffer saying “ sorry but here is the reason we can’t make a large in the Americano, may I offer you a similar which does come in large” instead of NO. I had the very small and dissatisfying Americano with a very good bacon egg and cheese sandwich. I kept it at 4 stars because my wife loves the place but for me, I will be going back to my go to.“

4.1 Good85 Reviews
The Crystal Cafe Deli • $
4 Church St, Vernon - 7.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Silver Dollar Pancakes Breakfast with 2 Eggs with One Side of Meat with Eggs and Meat
French Toast and Turkey Bacon
Egg Ham and Cheese Sandwich
Country Fried Steak Platter
Cheese Omelet Home Fries
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs
Make Your Own Omelette
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Chicken Fried Steak
Country Fried Steak

“This is the best food in Vernon served by the friendliest stuff at the best prices , t The Place is Amazing ,if you are new in the area or just visiting Vernon just stop by because there is no better place for breakfast lunch and dinner at the writing of this post. You don't have to trust me ( I traveled all in jersey and upstate NY for the last 6 years In a way I know as traveler and restaurant visitor) but don't take my word . Just go and see it for yourself ,"The feelings and the value is in the plates" as they say in the restaurant industry, You will be surprised, Be your own judge :)“

4.1 Good123 Reviews

You May Also Like