5 Best Ice Cream Shops in Middletown

“The owner is fantastic, kind & generous! The icecream was perfectly delicious as it always has been & the everything was spotless & clean ! The new owner put a lot of work into the cleanliness of his establishment !“

“Love going to family farms , the staff and owners are great . The ice cream is delicious“

“Great place! The ice cream and snacks are always fresh and full of flavor. The staff especially Evelyn is very friendly and the service is quick. They have a lot of delicious options, and everything tastes authentic. It’s a perfect spot to stop by if you want something sweet or refreshing. Highly recommend!“

“best cookie dough cupcake I've ever had and that's saying something cause I bake myself!!“

“I am giving this Rita’s location a 4 star review because I have been coming here for years and it WAS always very good. But if this review was only for the last couple of weeks , it would be 1 star. I went last week for some treats, when I got there there were only 5/6 flavors of ice and the custard flavors were only vanilla, chocolate or twist. I understand things happen so I wasn’t going to write a bad review on one visit after all the previous visits have been exceptional. I went today and I ordered the cherry ice(one of my favorites) I took it to go. When I got home I tried the ice and it tasted strange, it seemed like the sugar was crystallized, I had to throw it in the toilet. I will continue to patronize this Rita’s, but if this continues, i am sad to say 😔I will stop coming and I’m sure many other people will as well.“